review galore

Head-to-head · Password managers

1Password vs OneLogin

For password management, consider 1Password; for lower-cost workforce identity and SSO, OneLogin starts cheaper per seat.

1Password

6.8/10
VS

OneLogin

7.4/10

We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never changes a score or a ranking. How we make money

Short answer

Most buyers should pick OneLogin.

For a small team that mainly needs password management, 1Password is the closer fit: its Teams Starter Pack costs $24.95 per month with annual billing and covers up to 10 members. Choose OneLogin if your priority is workforce identity, such as centralized sign-on and lifecycle management; Basic lists $3 per user per month. Neither has a permanent free plan. Before choosing, check which features are included in the specific plan and ask about setup and support terms.

01Side by side

1PasswordOneLogin
Free planNo permanent free plan; 14-day trialNo permanent free plan; trial not published
Cheapest paid planBusiness: $8.99/user/month, annual billingBasic: $3/user/month
Price per seatStarter Pack: $24.95 for up to 10Basic: $3 per user monthly
Cost for five$24.95/month Starter Pack, annual billing$15/month on Basic
Setup effortSetup time not publishedSetup time not published
Learning curveEase-of-use review score: 6/10Ease-of-use review score: 7/10
Small-team integrationsSaaS discovery; specific integrations not listedNames Active Directory, LDAP, Google Workspace
SupportSupport review score: 5/10Support review score: 8/10

Choose 1Password if

  • Choose 1Password if your team needs business password management.
  • Choose 1Password if up to 10 members fit the $24.95 Starter Pack.
  • Choose 1Password if SaaS access discovery matters to your team.

Choose OneLogin if

  • Choose OneLogin if workforce identity is your main need.
  • Choose OneLogin if you want Basic at $3 per user monthly.
  • Choose OneLogin if directory sync or lifecycle management matters.

02What each costs a small team

Neither vendor lists a permanent free plan. 1Password offers a 14-day free trial; OneLogin's trial terms aren't published. For one person, 1Password Business is listed at $8.99 per user per month with annual billing. The Teams Starter Pack is $24.95 per month with annual billing and covers up to 10 members. OneLogin Basic is $3 per user per month, so one seat is $3 monthly; its annual-billing price isn't published.

For three to five people, the Starter Pack costs $24.95 per month, billed annually, and covers the group. Five seats on 1Password Business would be $44.95 per month on the same listed billing basis. OneLogin Basic comes to $9 monthly for three or $15 for five. OneLogin lists lifecycle management for five applications and five security policies on Basic. Check with 1Password about additional Starter Pack seat pricing; it isn't published.

03Setup and day-to-day use

Neither vendor publishes a setup-time estimate in its listed plans, so we wouldn't budget a specific number of hours without asking about your apps, directories, and rollout. OneLogin's feature list includes directory synchronization with Active Directory, LDAP, Workday, and Google Workspace, plus lifecycle provisioning and deprovisioning. A team using those systems should confirm which connections and setup help come with its chosen plan.

1Password describes password management alongside credential brokering, privileged access, and SaaS management. That broader scope may mean more decisions than a team looking only for a shared password manager needs; ask which parts apply to your plan. The review scores give OneLogin a 7/10 for ease of use and 1Password a 6/10, but don't describe the steps involved. For either product, clarify the rollout process, admin workload, and support terms before committing.

04What you get on the cheaper plans

1Password's listed Teams Starter Pack covers up to 10 members, allows up to 10 additional seats, and includes a 14-day trial. Its plan listing doesn't spell out which of the platform's wider features come with that pack. The company describes password management for human, machine, and agent credentials, plus SaaS discovery and access management. Ask which of those capabilities are included before treating the Starter Pack as a full access-management bundle.

OneLogin Basic lists lifecycle management for five applications and five security policies. The broader OneLogin platform supports single sign-on, multifactor authentication, lifecycle management, and directory integration, but the Basic plan listing doesn't confirm the precise scope of those features. Essentials, at $6 per user per month, removes the five-application lifecycle limit. For a small team, compare the app limit with your actual needs and confirm which SSO and MFA options are included. Business costs $10 per user per month; its plan inclusions aren't published.

Questions people ask

Is 1Password or OneLogin better for a small team?

It depends on the job. 1Password is the more direct fit for business password management, with a $24.95-per-month Starter Pack for up to 10 members when billed annually. OneLogin is a workforce identity platform; its Basic plan starts at $3 per user per month and lists lifecycle management for five applications.

Is OneLogin a password manager?

OneLogin is described as a cloud-based identity and access management platform for workforce and customer identities. Its features include single sign-on, multifactor authentication, and lifecycle management. 1Password explicitly describes password management for human, machine, and agent credentials, so the two products have different primary focuses.

Which is cheaper for five people?

OneLogin Basic totals $15 per month for five users at its listed $3-per-user monthly price. 1Password's Teams Starter Pack is $24.95 per month with annual billing and covers up to 10 members. 1Password Business would total $44.95 per month for five at its listed annual-billing rate.

Do 1Password or OneLogin have a free plan?

Neither lists a permanent free plan. 1Password lists a 14-day free trial. OneLogin's listed pricing doesn't specify a free trial, so ask the vendor whether one is available. If you need a free option rather than a trial, these plans don't meet that requirement.