We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never changes a score or a ranking. How we make money
Most buyers should pick APS.
For a 1–10-person team, APS is more transparent, but its $416.67 monthly minimum makes it expensive despite the $6-per-employee Payroll price. ADP Workforce Now has no published price or small-team plan details, and its listed tiers generally target 50–999+ employees. Pick APS if guided migration, self-service and payroll support justify the minimum; consider ADP only after getting a quote that confirms small-team availability, setup costs and included features.
01Side by side
| ADP Workforce Now | APS | |
|---|---|---|
| Free plan | No free plan | No free plan |
| Cheapest paid plan | Price not published | Payroll: $6 per employee monthly |
| Price per seat | Not published | $6 monthly, before fees and minimum |
| Cost for five | Not published | $416.67 monthly minimum |
| Setup effort | Setup details not published | Guided implementation and data migration |
| Learning curve | Not published | Not published |
| Small-team integrations | Integration details not published | QuickBooks integration costs extra |
| Support | Support details not published | Personalized support and expert tax team |
ADP Workforce Now Choose ADP Workforce Now if
- Choose ADP Workforce Now if your team is nearing 50 employees.
- Choose ADP Workforce Now if you want to compare Select, Plus and Premium.
- Choose ADP Workforce Now if you need payroll and HR from one vendor.
APS Choose APS if
- Choose APS if you need published per-employee starting prices.
- Choose APS if guided payroll-history migration matters.
- Choose APS if attendance, scheduling and HR belong together.
02What each costs a small team
Neither vendor offers a free plan, so even a one-person shop needs a paid quote or subscription. ADP does not publish Workforce Now prices: Select, Plus and Premium are listed for organizations generally sized 50 to 999+ employees, but plan prices and seat limits are not published. Ask ADP whether it will quote a 1–10-person business and what implementation or add-on charges apply.
APS publishes Payroll at $6 per employee monthly, plus a $50 monthly base fee and a $416.67 monthly minimum. Before the minimum, one employee calculates to $56 and five to $80; both fall below the stated minimum, so budget at least $416.67 a month. Payroll + Attendance is $10 per employee and Payroll + HR + Attendance is $14, with the same minimum. No annual rate is listed.
03Setup and day-to-day use
APS describes a guided, step-by-step implementation that includes employee data and payroll history migration. It does not publish a launch timeline, so ask how long setup takes and what your team must provide. ADP does not publish Workforce Now setup details; ask about implementation time, migration scope and fees before accepting a quote.
For daily use, APS Payroll includes employee and manager self-service, while its Attendance plan adds scheduling, geofencing and time capture across mobile, desktop and timesheets. Decide who will manage schedules and time records, and confirm any extra charges. Neither vendor publishes a learning-curve measure, so request a walkthrough for the roles your team will use.
04What you get on the cheaper plans
APS's $6 Payroll plan includes federal, state and local payroll tax filings, direct deposit, paycards, on-demand pay, and employee and manager self-service. Its payroll processing also includes tax calculations, filings and payments supported by an expert tax team.
At $10 per employee, Payroll + Attendance adds scheduling, geofencing, time capture, and overtime, lunch, break and shift calculations. The $14 Payroll + HR + Attendance plan adds recruiting and onboarding, document management with e-signature, and benefits and COBRA administration. APS notes that some features cost extra; its examples include QuickBooks integration, scheduling, recruiting and onboarding, and benefits administration, so confirm what the quoted package includes.
ADP lists payroll and HR solutions across business sizes, plus time and attendance for small and midsized businesses. Its listed plans do not spell out Workforce Now features by tier, so ask for an itemized feature list.
Questions people ask
What is ADP Payroll software?
ADP offers payroll solutions for small, midsize and large businesses, alongside HR and workforce solutions. ADP Workforce Now is the product being compared here; a small team should ask ADP to confirm its exact package, price, seat fit and included features before buying.
How do I check my payroll on ADP?
Ask your employer's payroll administrator for your organization's sign-in link and instructions for viewing pay information. ADP offers payroll solutions to businesses of different sizes, but the exact Workforce Now steps can depend on your employer's setup. Avoid assuming another company's menu path will match yours.
Who is a competitor to ADP?
APS is one alternative for a business comparing payroll and HR tools. It publishes per-employee prices for payroll, attendance and HR packages, while ADP Workforce Now pricing is not published. Compare the full monthly minimum, included services, support and setup requirements—not just the starting per-employee rate.
Are Workforce and ADP the same company?
No. ADP is the provider, and ADP Workforce Now is the product named in this comparison. APS is a separate provider of payroll, HR, attendance and workforce tools. If you mean the general term “workforce,” it describes a group of workers rather than a company.