We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never changes a score or a ranking. How we make money
Most buyers should pick Employee Navigator.
For a 1–10-person team that mainly needs benefits enrollment, ACA reporting, and HR paperwork through a broker, Employee Navigator is the more focused fit—but its price still requires a quote. Choose ADP Workforce Now when you want a broader payroll-and-HR platform and can get a quote that fits your headcount. Neither has a listed free plan or public price, and ADP’s listed tiers generally target 50 or more employees.
01Side by side
| ADP Workforce Now | Employee Navigator | |
|---|---|---|
| Free plan | No free plan listed | No free plan listed |
| Cheapest paid plan | Select; price not published | Enhanced; price not published |
| Price per seat | Not published | Not published; EDI fee may apply |
| Team of five cost | Quote required; not calculable | Quote required; not calculable |
| Setup effort | Timeline and process not published | Timeline and process not published |
| Learning curve | Ask vendor for a walkthrough | Ask broker for a walkthrough |
| Integrations | Integration details not listed | More than 600 integrations listed |
| Support | Support terms not published | Priority phone support on Platinum |
ADP Workforce Now Choose ADP Workforce Now if
- Choose ADP Workforce Now if you need broader payroll and HR solutions.
- Choose ADP Workforce Now if your team matches its midsize-oriented tiers.
- Choose ADP Workforce Now if a custom quote fits your budget.
Employee Navigator Choose Employee Navigator if
- Choose Employee Navigator if benefits administration is your main need.
- Choose Employee Navigator if you work with a benefits broker.
- Choose Employee Navigator if you need ACA reporting and payroll integrations.
02What each costs a small team
Neither vendor lists a free plan, and neither publishes a free trial. ADP does not publish Workforce Now rates; its listed Select, Plus, and Premium tiers have no public monthly or annual prices and are generally aimed at 50–999+ employees. Employee Navigator also requires a sales quote: its lowest listed tier, Enhanced, is aimed at brokers, and the vendor does not publish plan rates or billing terms.
For one person, budget cannot be calculated for either product. The same is true for a team of three to five: there is no published per-seat price to multiply. Employee Navigator lists a $0.45 PEPM charge for 834 EDI feeds on Enhanced Plus and Elite; the fee is free on Platinum and unavailable on Enhanced. Ask for a written quote for your headcount, broker arrangement, and required add-ons.
03Setup and day-to-day use
Neither vendor publishes a setup timeline, so ask what implementation involves and whether it carries a separate fee. With ADP, clarify which payroll and HR services are included in your quote, what information your team needs to provide, and who handles setup. Its homepage lists payroll and HR across business sizes, with time and attendance for small and midsized businesses.
Employee Navigator connects employers, brokers, and partners. A small team should ask its broker who configures benefits, payroll integrations, new-hire onboarding, and time-off tracking. Those tools vary by plan: onboarding and PTO tracking are listed on Elite. Neither product has a published learning-curve rating. Request a walkthrough using your team’s actual benefits and payroll needs before committing.
04What you get on the cheaper plans
ADP’s public homepage describes payroll and HR solutions across business sizes, but does not detail Workforce Now’s individual plan features. Its listed business-size offerings include time and attendance for small and midsized businesses, talent solutions for midsized businesses, and benefits administration for midsized and large businesses. The Select tier’s included features are not published, so ask which tools are in your quote.
Employee Navigator’s lowest listed tier, Enhanced, includes online enrollment, carrier, payroll and TPA integrations, ACA reporting, and AI Plan Builds. Enhanced Plus adds 834 EDI files and third-party apps. Elite adds an enrollment assistance tool, new-hire onboarding, and PTO and vacation tracking. Platinum adds priority phone support and $0 PEPM for 834 EDI. Extra fees apply to 1095 and 1094 reporting and email and phone support; the amounts are not published. These tiers are described for brokers, so confirm access and pricing with yours.
Questions people ask
Is Employee Navigator a payroll system?
Employee Navigator is presented as a benefits, HR, and compliance platform, not as a payroll system. It lists payroll integrations that connect with payroll services. Ask your broker which integrations are available for your payroll provider and whether setup or support carries an extra fee.
What does ADP Workforce Now cost?
ADP does not publish Workforce Now prices. The listed Select, Plus, and Premium tiers require a quote, and seat limits are not published. Ask ADP for a written price based on your headcount, required modules, billing schedule, and any add-ons.
How long does ADP take to process payroll?
ADP does not publish a payroll processing timeline in the information available from its homepage. Timing may depend on your setup and payroll schedule, so ask ADP how long implementation takes and what cutoffs apply before your first payroll.
Is ADP or Workday better?
The right choice depends on your team size, payroll needs, and budget. ADP lists payroll and HR solutions for different business sizes, but a useful comparison with Workday requires current pricing, features, and fit for your headcount. Get quotes from both vendors.