review galore

Head-to-head · Payroll tools

ADP Workforce Now vs Paylocity

For a 1–10-person team, Paylocity looks like the closer fit, but get a quote before budgeting.

ADP Workforce Now

5.2/10
VS

Paylocity

5.2/10

We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never changes a score or a ranking. How we make money

Short answer

Most buyers should pick Paylocity.

For a 1–10-person team, we’d start with Paylocity if you need HR and payroll alongside finance or IT: it says it serves small businesses, but pricing is quote-based. ADP Workforce Now is harder to justify without a quote; its listed tiers target organizations generally starting around 50 employees, though that estimate is low-confidence. Neither lists a free plan or publishes prices, so request itemized quotes before choosing.

01Side by side

ADP Workforce NowPaylocity
Free planNo free plan listedNo free plan listed
Cheapest paid planSelect, Plus, Premium; prices unpublishedCustom quote; module choices
Price per seatNot publishedNot published
Cost for fiveNot published; request a quoteNot published; request a quote
Setup effortTimeline and effort unpublishedTimeline and effort unpublished
Learning curveEstimate not publishedEstimate not published
Integrations for small teamsSpecific integrations not publishedSpecific integrations not published
SupportSupport terms not publishedPayroll includes expert support

Choose ADP Workforce Now if

  • Choose ADP Workforce Now if you need its listed HR and payroll offerings.
  • Choose ADP Workforce Now if its quoted package fits your requirements.
  • Choose ADP Workforce Now if you need benefits administration for a larger team.

Choose Paylocity if

  • Choose Paylocity if you want HR and payroll with finance or IT tools.
  • Choose Paylocity if you need a platform that says it serves small businesses.
  • Choose Paylocity if its custom quote fits your budget and module needs.

02What each costs a small team

Neither vendor lists a free plan, and neither publishes a starting price. ADP’s listed tiers are Select, Plus, and Premium for midsize-to-enterprise organizations; tier prices, seat limits, and monthly versus annual rates are unpublished. The listed audience is generally 50–999+ employees, a low-confidence estimate. Paylocity offers a custom quote for selected HR, payroll, talent, or finance modules; seat limits and billing terms are unpublished.

For one person, there is no public per-seat figure for either product. A three-to-five-person team likewise cannot calculate a monthly or annual total from published rates. Ask each vendor for a written quote covering five employees, required modules, implementation, and add-on or overage charges. Those extra costs are not published either.

03Setup and day-to-day use

Neither vendor publishes a setup timeline or the staff time a small company should budget. ADP lists payroll and HR across business sizes, with time and attendance for small and midsized businesses. It does not publish a Workforce Now implementation timeline. Paylocity brings HR, payroll, finance, and IT into one platform, but does not publish onboarding steps or duration.

Paylocity lists a mobile app and analytics dashboards, and describes payroll and tax filing as supported by experts. ADP does not publish a learning-curve estimate. Before signing, ask both vendors to outline data migration, payroll setup, administrator training, launch timing, and support responsibilities. Treat these as questions, not confirmed inclusions: the scope and fees are not published.

04What you get on the cheaper plans

Do not assume the lowest-cost quote includes every capability: neither vendor publishes a feature-by-tier matrix or public module prices. ADP names Select, Plus, and Premium but does not publish what each tier includes. Its broader offerings list payroll and HR across business sizes; time and attendance for small and midsized businesses; workforce management for large businesses; talent for midsized businesses; and benefits administration for midsized and large businesses.

Paylocity says its custom offering can combine HR, payroll, talent, and finance modules. Its broader platform also describes tax filing, workforce management, spend management, IT asset and access tools, a mobile app, and analytics. That breadth does not confirm which items a small team gets in its quote. Ask for a module-by-module proposal and clarify whether mobile access, reports, and support are included. Neither vendor publishes usage limits or add-on charges.

Questions people ask

Does either ADP Workforce Now or Paylocity have a free plan?

Neither vendor lists a free plan. Paylocity uses custom quotes, while ADP’s tier prices are unpublished. Neither vendor lists a free-trial offer either, so ask sales whether a trial or evaluation option is available before committing.

Which is cheaper for a small business?

There is no published price comparison. ADP does not publish tier prices, and Paylocity quotes based on selected modules. Ask both for itemized pricing for the same employee count and required features; include implementation and add-on costs in the comparison.

How much would five employees cost?

Neither vendor publishes a price that lets us calculate a five-person total. ADP’s seat limits and prices are unpublished, and Paylocity’s quote is custom. Request a written quote for five employees and ask whether the amount changes with selected modules.

Which product is a better fit for a 1–10-person team?

Paylocity is the more natural first quote to request: it says it serves small businesses and brings HR, payroll, finance, and IT together. ADP’s listed audience is generally 50–999+ employees, but that estimate is low-confidence. Compare quotes before deciding.