We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never changes a score or a ranking. How we make money
Most buyers should pick QuickBooks Online.
Most 1–10-person businesses should look at QuickBooks Online first: it has a free, highly limited option and paid plans with published prices and user limits. ADP Workforce Now is worth considering if payroll and broader HR services, such as benefits or time and attendance, matter more than a clear small-team price. ADP’s plans generally target 50–999+ employees, and the vendor doesn’t publish prices or seat limits, so ask for a quote before budgeting.
01Side by side
| ADP Workforce Now | QuickBooks Online | |
|---|---|---|
| Free plan | No free plan listed | Free; one user, two invoices monthly |
| Cheapest paid plan | Price not published; request a quote | Solopreneur: $20 monthly for one user |
| Published seat cost | Seat limits and prices not published | Plus: $28 monthly per billable user |
| Cost for five people | Not published; ask for a quote | Plus: $140 monthly for five billable users |
| Setup effort | Setup time and process not published | Setup time and process not published |
| Learning curve | No published learning-time estimate | No published learning-time estimate |
| Small-team integrations | Specific integrations not listed | Simple Start lists up to three sales channels |
| Support | Support details not published | Support details not published |
ADP Workforce Now Choose ADP Workforce Now if
- Choose ADP Workforce Now if payroll and broader HR belong together.
- Choose ADP Workforce Now if you need time and attendance solutions.
- Choose ADP Workforce Now if your team fits its midsize focus.
QuickBooks Online Choose QuickBooks Online if
- Choose QuickBooks Online if you need low-cost accounting software.
- Choose QuickBooks Online if published user limits help you budget.
- Choose QuickBooks Online if invoices, payments, and time tracking matter.
02What each costs a small team
QuickBooks Online has a free plan for one user, one connected bank account, and up to two invoices a month; it has no mobile app, integrations, or accountant access. For one person, Solopreneur is $20 monthly or $215 annually. For a business needing basic bookkeeping, Simple Start is $38 monthly for one billable user, plus two accountant users.
For three billable users, Essentials is $85 monthly; for five, Plus is $140. The listed first-three-month offers are $42.50 for Essentials and $70 for Plus. ADP doesn’t publish prices or seat limits for Workforce Now, so neither a one-person nor a five-person cost is available; request a quote. Its plans generally target 50–999+ employees, making it a less obvious fit for a tiny team.
03Setup and day-to-day use
Neither vendor publishes a setup-time estimate, so we wouldn’t budget around a promised number of days. Before signing with ADP, ask what implementation includes, how employee and payroll details are brought in, and whether setup or training costs extra. Its listed offerings span payroll and HR, with time and attendance for small and midsize businesses; confirm which services your quote covers.
QuickBooks Online’s plan limits are easier to compare in advance, but the vendor doesn’t publish setup time either. A small team should decide who needs a billable seat, whether an accountant needs access, and which sales channels to connect. Essentials allows three billable users and two accountant users; Plus allows five billable users. Those limits can shape everyday access as much as the learning curve. Ask both vendors about support and training before committing.
04What you get on the cheaper plans
ADP lists payroll and HR solutions across business sizes, with time and attendance for small and midsize businesses. Its midsize offerings also include talent solutions; benefits administration is listed for midsize and large businesses. But the Select, Plus, and Premium plan details, seat limits, and included features aren’t published, so ask ADP to spell out what your quote includes. Its homepage positions Workforce Now plans for midsize to enterprise organizations, not as a simple starter package.
QuickBooks Online’s entry options are clearer. The free plan is narrow: one user, one connected bank account, and two invoices monthly, without integrations or accountant access. Solopreneur adds unlimited invoices, expense and mileage tracking, and management for up to three contractors. Simple Start includes one billable user, two accountant users, and up to three connected sales channels. Essentials raises billable users to three and includes unlimited time-tracking-only users. Payroll is an add-on, with listed prices starting around $50 monthly plus per-employee charges on these plans.
Questions people ask
Is ADP similar to QuickBooks?
They overlap in payroll, but they aren’t direct substitutes for every small business. ADP lists payroll and HR solutions, along with time and attendance for small and midsize businesses. Intuit presents QuickBooks as a business platform that includes accounting software, payroll, online payments, invoicing, and time tracking.
What is the best payroll system to use?
It depends on your needs and team size. QuickBooks Online payroll is an add-on with published starting prices for some plans, plus per-employee charges. ADP offers payroll solutions across business sizes, but doesn’t publish Workforce Now pricing. Get an ADP quote and compare the full monthly cost before deciding.
What is the difference between QuickBooks Online and QuickBooks Online Accountant?
QuickBooks Online is the business product with accounting plans and user limits. Essentials, for example, includes three billable users and two accountant users. Intuit’s homepage doesn’t detail the separate QuickBooks Online Accountant offering, so ask Intuit or your accountant which product and access level you need.
Why don't accountants like QuickBooks?
We wouldn’t assume accountants generally dislike QuickBooks. The listed Essentials plan allows two accountant users, and Intuit presents accounting software as part of its small-business offerings. If your accountant has a preference, ask which product and access they need; plan limits and product details can affect that choice.