We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never changes a score or a ranking. How we make money
It's a split decision.
Pick Asana if your small team needs a shared place for tasks, projects, owners, and deadlines: its free Personal plan covers two users, and Starter adds seats for a per-user fee. Pick BerniePortal if benefits administration is your priority and you work with a benefits broker; its Starter Edition costs $5 per employee monthly plus a $25 base fee. These tools aren't direct substitutes, so decide whether you need work management or HR administration before comparing the bill.
01Side by side
| Asana | BerniePortal | |
|---|---|---|
| Free plan | Free for two users | No free plan |
| Cheapest paid plan | $10.99/user monthly, billed annually | $5/employee monthly plus $25 base |
| Price per seat | $10.99 annual-billed; $13.49 monthly | $5/employee, plus shared base fee |
| Cost for a team of 5 | $54.95 annual-billed; $67.45 monthly | $50/month, including base fee |
| Setup effort | Set up projects, owners, and timelines | Configure HR needs with your broker |
| Learning curve | Learn project planning workflows | Learn HR and benefits workflows |
| Integrations a small team needs | 100+ free integrations | Specific integrations not published |
| Support | Support terms not listed | Support terms not listed |
Asana Choose Asana if
- Choose Asana if you need shared tasks, projects, and deadlines.
- Choose Asana if a free plan for two users is enough to start.
- Choose Asana if you want 100+ free integrations.
BerniePortal Choose BerniePortal if
- Choose BerniePortal if benefits administration is your main need.
- Choose BerniePortal if your benefits broker is part of the process.
- Choose BerniePortal if you want recruiting, onboarding, and compliance in one HRIS.
02What each costs a small team
Asana's free Personal plan covers two users, unlimited tasks and projects, 100MB per file, and 100+ free integrations. BerniePortal has no free plan. Its Starter Edition is $5 per employee monthly plus a $25 base fee.
For one person, Asana Starter is $10.99 per user monthly when billed annually, or $13.49 with monthly billing. BerniePortal Starter is $30 monthly for one employee, including the base fee. For three people, Asana is $32.97 monthly on annual billing or $40.47 with monthly billing; BerniePortal is $40 monthly. For five, Asana is $54.95 or $67.45, respectively, while BerniePortal is $50 monthly. BerniePortal doesn't publish annual rates. The prices cover different jobs: project management versus benefits administration.
03Setup and day-to-day use
Neither vendor publishes a setup-time estimate, so we wouldn't budget a specific number of hours from the available plan details. The work to configure each tool depends on what you plan to manage.
In Asana, teams can organize project tasks with owners, timelines, and dependencies. A small team will need to decide how to structure its projects and deadlines. BerniePortal is an HRIS designed to work with an employer's benefits broker. Its listed employee-lifecycle features include recruiting, onboarding, benefits, and compliance, so setup centers on the HR functions your business needs and its broker relationship.
Neither product has a published learning-time estimate here. Asana's core concepts are projects and tasks; BerniePortal's are employee and HR workflows. Ask each vendor what onboarding help is available and what your team must configure.
04What you get on the cheaper plans
Asana Personal is free for two users and includes unlimited tasks and projects, 100MB per file, and 100+ free integrations. Starter is the paid option for small teams: it has no user seat limits, unlimited automations and free guests, plus 75,000 AI Studio credits per billing account monthly. Asana also describes project planning with tasks, owners, timelines, and dependency tracking.
BerniePortal's Starter Edition focuses on benefits administration. At $5 per employee monthly plus a $25 base fee, its listed inclusions are recruiting, onboarding, benefits, compliance, and COBRA administration. It is designed to work with the employer's benefits broker.
PTO, time, performance, and payroll sit under BerniePortal's HR Upgrades, which require a quote; per-user rates aren't published. So compare Asana when you need project coordination, and BerniePortal when benefits and HR administration are the job—not just by feature count.
Questions people ask
Is Asana or BerniePortal better for a small business?
It depends on the work you need to manage. Asana is a work management platform for tasks, projects, goals, and dependencies, with a free plan for two users. BerniePortal is an HRIS designed to work with a benefits broker. Choose based on whether your priority is project coordination or employee and benefits administration.
How much does BerniePortal cost for five employees?
The pricing page lists Starter Edition at $5 per employee monthly plus a $25 base fee. For five employees, that totals $50 per month. HR Upgrades such as PTO, time, performance, and payroll require a quote, and their per-user rates aren't published.
Can I use Asana for free with a small team?
Yes. Asana's Personal plan is free for two users and includes unlimited tasks and projects, 100MB per file, and 100+ free integrations. Teams needing more seats can consider Starter, listed at $10.99 per user monthly with annual billing or $13.49 with monthly billing.
Does BerniePortal include payroll and PTO in Starter Edition?
No. BerniePortal lists PTO, time, and payroll under HR Upgrades, alongside performance. The vendor requires a quote for those upgrades and doesn't publish their per-user rates. Starter Edition lists benefits administration, recruiting, onboarding, compliance, and COBRA administration.