We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never changes a score or a ranking. How we make money
It's a split decision.
Small teams should pick Basecamp if they want predictable billing and a simple home for discussions, tasks, files, and schedules: Freelancer is $29/month for up to five users. Pick Nifty if unlimited members on the free plan, more project views, or Google Docs sync matter more. Its five-person Pro team costs $80/month billed monthly or $50/month equivalent with annual billing. Basecamp is cheaper at five; Nifty offers more room in its free tier, but only 100 MB storage.
01Side by side
| Basecamp | Nifty | |
|---|---|---|
| Free plan | 1 project, 3 users, 1 GB | 2 projects, unlimited members, 100 MB |
| Cheapest paid plan | Freelancer: $29/month | Pro: $16 monthly; $10 annual equivalent per seat |
| Price per seat | Flat $29/month; $5.80 effective across five seats | $16 monthly or $10 annual-equivalent per seat |
| Cost for five people | $29/month for up to five users | $80 monthly; $50 annual equivalent for five seats |
| Setup effort | Typical setup time not published | Typical setup time not published |
| Learning curve | Described as straightforward and easy to use | Multiple task views; learning curve not published |
| Useful integrations | ChatGPT and Claude connectors on Free | Google Docs sync |
| Support | 24/7/365 support on Freelancer | Support coverage not published |
Basecamp Choose Basecamp if
- Choose Basecamp if you want a flat $29 plan for five.
- Choose Basecamp if you want discussions, tasks, files, and schedules together.
- Choose Basecamp if a straightforward approach is your priority.
Nifty Choose Nifty if
- Choose Nifty if free access for unlimited members matters most.
- Choose Nifty if Google Docs sync or varied task views matter.
- Choose Nifty if you need time tracking and workflow automations on Pro.
02What each costs a small team
Both offer free plans, but the limits differ. Basecamp Free covers one project, three users, and 1 GB of storage. Nifty Free allows two active projects, unlimited members, and 100 MB. For one paid user, Basecamp’s cheapest option is Freelancer at $29/month, which allows up to five users and three active projects. Nifty Pro costs $16 per user monthly, or $10 per user/month with annual billing. For a five-person team, Basecamp stays $29/month on Freelancer. Nifty Pro is $80/month billed monthly or $50/month equivalent with annual billing. Nifty’s flat-rate Pro plan is listed for teams of 7–10, so it is not the five-person option. Basecamp is cheaper for five; Nifty’s annual rate reduces its per-seat cost.
03Setup and day-to-day use
Neither vendor publishes a typical setup time, so we wouldn’t promise a same-day rollout. Basecamp’s listed toolkit is easy to scan: create projects and use message boards, to-dos, schedules, docs and files, plus chats and pings. A small team still needs to decide which work belongs in each project and who owns each to-do.
Nifty has more choices to configure: roadmaps, five task views, discussions, connected docs, forms and Orbit AI. Start by choosing a default task view, deciding where requests enter, and linking the docs people need. The pricing page lists time tracking and workflow automations on Pro. Basecamp describes itself as straightforward and easy to use; Nifty does not publish a learning-curve rating.
04What you get on the cheaper plans
Basecamp Free gives one project, three users, 1 GB of storage, and ChatGPT and Claude connectors. Its core toolkit covers message boards, to-dos, card tables, chats and pings, scheduling, and docs and files. The pricing page lists three projects and 10 GB on Freelancer, plus up to five users and 24/7/365 support. Pro raises the limit to eight active projects, 25 GB, and ten users, with multiple tools per project and templates.
Nifty Free includes tasks, docs, chat and portfolios, with two active projects, unlimited members and 100 MB. Pro adds 100 active projects, 250 GB, five guests per paid seat, time tracking and workflow automations. The wider product also lists roadmaps, task views, discussions, forms, Google Docs sync and Orbit AI. Basecamp keeps its plan options compact; Nifty lists more workflow features, but Pro is seat-priced unless your team qualifies for its 7–10-member flat plan.
Questions people ask
Which is cheaper for a team of five?
Basecamp Freelancer is $29/month for up to five users. Nifty Pro for five costs $80/month at monthly rates, or $50/month equivalent with annual billing. Nifty’s flat-rate Pro is listed for teams of 7–10, so it is not the listed five-person plan.
Can a small team use either product for free?
Yes, if the limits fit. Basecamp Free allows one project and three users, with 1 GB storage. Nifty Free allows two active projects and unlimited members, but has 100 MB storage. Nifty suits a larger free team; Basecamp offers more free storage.
How many projects can each plan handle?
Basecamp Free includes one project, Freelancer three active projects, and Pro eight active projects. Nifty Free includes two active projects, while its per-member Pro plan lists 100. Nifty’s flat Pro plan also lists 100 active projects for teams of 7–10.
When might a team outgrow Basecamp or Nifty?
A team may need a higher Basecamp plan when it exceeds Freelancer’s five-user or three-active-project limits; Pro covers up to ten users and eight active projects. Nifty’s per-member Pro plan may stop fitting when a team needs Business features such as goals tracking and custom roles.