We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never changes a score or a ranking. How we make money
It's a split decision.
A small team that mainly needs recruiting, onboarding, learning, and performance tools should shortlist ClearCompany. Paylocity fits better if payroll, HR, finance, and IT in one platform matter more. Neither vendor lists a free plan or public rates, so we can’t name a cheapest option or calculate a five-person bill. Get quotes for your exact modules and headcount, then compare setup help, support, and any add-on costs.
01Side by side
| ClearCompany | Paylocity | |
|---|---|---|
| Free plan | No free plan listed | No free plan listed |
| Cheapest paid plan | Custom quote; price not listed | Custom quote; price not listed |
| Price per seat | Not published | Not published |
| Cost for five | Ask for a five-person quote | Ask for a five-person quote |
| Setup effort | Mixed reports; ask about implementation | Setup details not published |
| Learning curve | Usability reports are mixed | Learning-curve details not published |
| Integrations | Connects with existing systems | Specific integrations not listed |
| Support | Review support score: 4 | Review support score: 4 |
ClearCompany Choose ClearCompany if
- Choose ClearCompany if recruiting and onboarding are your main needs.
- Choose ClearCompany if you want talent tools connected to performance and learning.
- Choose ClearCompany if you want a vendor quote for talent-focused modules.
Paylocity Choose Paylocity if
- Choose Paylocity if payroll and tax filing are central needs.
- Choose Paylocity if finance and IT tools belong in the same platform.
- Choose Paylocity if your organization needs a platform aimed at small businesses, midsize businesses, or enterprises.
02What each costs a small team
Neither vendor lists a free plan, so a one-person team pays for a quote-based option rather than starting on a published free tier. ClearCompany lists several custom-quote plans, including ClearRecruit for hiring and ClearLearn for learning. Paylocity lists a custom option for HR, payroll, talent, and finance modules.
For one person or a team of three to five, neither vendor publishes a monthly or annual price, a per-seat rate, or a minimum headcount. We can’t calculate a reliable bill from the listed plans. Paylocity also says add-on and overage costs aren’t published. Ask both vendors for a written quote covering your headcount, chosen modules, implementation, and any add-ons. That is the only sound way to compare the cost of a small-team setup.
03Setup and day-to-day use
Neither vendor publishes a setup timeline in the details available. ClearCompany lists enhanced implementation and talent support under ClearCare, which is a separate custom-quote offering. Its review describes mixed reports on setup and usability, so ask what implementation includes and who handles data migration, integrations, and employee onboarding.
Paylocity’s platform combines HR, payroll, finance, and IT tools, but the vendor doesn’t list setup effort or a learning curve here. Before signing, ask for a rollout plan, training details, and the work your team must do to configure payroll, permissions, and workflows. For a small team, a broad platform can mean more choices to set up; get the vendor to spell out which modules are included and what your admin will manage day to day. Treat promised timelines and support terms as quote questions, not assumptions.
04What you get on the cheaper plans
There isn’t a published cheapest plan for either product, so compare the modules in each quote rather than assuming a low-priced tier includes everything. ClearCompany’s ClearRecruit quote covers candidate attraction, recruiting workflows, background checks, and onboarding. ClearLearn is listed for learning management. ClearTalent adds goals and alignment alongside recruiting and onboarding; broader options connect performance, engagement, learning, or compensation.
Paylocity’s custom option can include HR, payroll, talent, and finance modules. Its platform also lists workforce management, spend management, IT asset management, access control, a mobile app, and analytics. The vendor doesn’t publish seat or usage limits for the option. For a small team, ask which capabilities are included in your specific quote, and whether payroll, reporting, integrations, and employee access add to the bill. ClearCompany’s site says it connects with existing systems; ask both vendors to confirm the integrations your team relies on.
Questions people ask
How safe is Paylocity?
Paylocity lists IT features including centralized asset management, access control, and service support. Those features alone don’t establish how payroll or employee data is protected. Before signing, ask for security documentation, details on access controls and data handling, and the terms for reporting and responding to incidents.
Who is ClearCompany talent management?
ClearCompany is a talent-management platform for HR and business leaders. Its tools connect recruiting, onboarding, learning, engagement, performance, and talent data. The company also describes AI-assisted tasks and people analytics as part of its platform.
Are Paychex and Paylocity the same company?
Paylocity is described as a platform for HR, payroll, finance, and IT. That platform description doesn’t establish whether it has a corporate connection to Paychex. For a contract or payroll decision, check each company’s current corporate disclosures or ask both vendors directly.
Who are Paylocity's biggest clients?
Paylocity describes its customer base as including small businesses, midsize businesses, and enterprises. Its platform description doesn’t name its largest clients. Ask Paylocity for customer references in your industry and at a similar company size.