We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never changes a score or a ranking. How we make money
It's a split decision.
A small team may not need a paid CMS if it can self-host Umbraco or fit Craft’s one-account Solo plan. Choose Craft when you want a customizable back end and a clear five-account Team license: $279 per project, including one year of updates. Choose Umbraco if your team is comfortable with .NET and managing its own hosting, or wants managed hosting from €45 per month. Setup time and per-seat pricing aren’t published, so budget for developer work.
01Side by side
| Craft CMS | Umbraco CMS | |
|---|---|---|
| Free plan | Solo: one account, localization, Twig, and GraphQL | Free self-hosting includes authoring, users, and APIs |
| Cheapest paid plan | Team: $279 per project | Starter managed hosting: €45 monthly |
| Price per seat | $55.80 first year at five accounts | Per-seat price and user limit aren’t listed |
| Cost for five | $279 per project, including five accounts | €45 monthly for Starter hosting |
| Setup effort | Custom back end and front end need configuration | Self-hosting means managing hosting yourself |
| Learning curve | Flexible tools leave choices for developers | .NET flexibility suits developer-led teams |
| Small-team integrations | Plugin Store, custom plugins, GraphQL, and marketing integrations | Headless APIs, webhooks, and flexible integrations |
| Support | Enterprise includes dedicated premium support | Enterprise includes 24/7 support and customer success |
Craft CMS Choose Craft CMS if
- Choose Craft CMS if you need a customizable authoring back end.
- Choose Craft CMS if five included accounts suit your team.
- Choose Craft CMS if Twig or GraphQL fits your front end.
Umbraco CMS Choose Umbraco CMS if
- Choose Umbraco CMS if your team can self-host a .NET CMS.
- Choose Umbraco CMS if managed hosting at €45 monthly fits.
- Choose Umbraco CMS if you want free multilingual authoring and APIs.
02What each costs a small team
Craft’s Solo plan is free forever for one account. A single person can use it for unlimited content types, entries, pages, and locales, plus Twig and GraphQL. For a team, the pricing page lists Team at $279 per project, with up to five accounts and one year of updates. That works out to $55.80 per account if all five slots are used; later updates cost $99 a year.
Umbraco’s Free plan is for self-hosting and includes authoring, media management, user management, multilingual setup, APIs, and webhooks. The pricing page lists Starter managed hosting at €45 per month. That’s the listed hosting price whether you have one person or five; a user limit isn’t published. These prices use different currencies and billing terms, so compare your hosting needs as well as the sticker price.
03Setup and day-to-day use
Neither vendor publishes a setup-time estimate. Craft offers a customizable back end and lets teams use Twig templates or a decoupled GraphQL API. That flexibility means deciding how the authoring experience and front end should work, then configuring or developing them. A small team without a developer should confirm who will handle that work before choosing Craft.
Umbraco is an open-source .NET CMS aimed at editors and developers. Its Free plan is self-hosted, so the team needs to arrange and manage hosting; Starter is the listed managed-hosting option. Editors get authoring tools, while developers can customize the CMS. For either product, plan time for content structure, user setup, and any integrations you need. The learning curve depends on who configures the system and how much customization the project requires.
04What you get on the cheaper plans
Craft Solo includes one account, unlimited content types, entries, pages, and locales, plus multi-site support, Twig, and GraphQL. Its Team plan adds room for up to five accounts and one user group. Craft also describes localization, a plugin framework, and Craft Commerce, but the pricing details don’t say those paid features are included with Team.
Umbraco Free includes content authoring, media management, user management, multilingual setup, headless APIs, and webhooks. Starter adds managed hosting with five regions, 5 GB of media storage, 50 GB monthly bandwidth, 10 custom domains, and five included secrets. The vendor lists Forms, Commerce, and several other add-ons, but their prices aren’t published. UI Builder is paid on Free and Starter and included with Standard and Professional. For a small team, check add-on needs before treating the entry price as the full bill.
Questions people ask
Which is cheaper for a small team, Craft or Umbraco?
Umbraco has a free self-hosted plan and managed Starter hosting listed at €45 per month. Craft Solo is free for one account; its five-account Team plan is $279 per project, with one year of updates included. The currencies and billing terms differ, so the cheaper fit depends on hosting and team needs.
Can a five-person team use Craft’s free plan?
No. Craft’s Solo plan includes one user account. Its Team plan includes up to five accounts for $279 per project, with one year of updates. Umbraco Free includes user management, but the vendor doesn’t publish a user limit on the plan details.
Does Umbraco Free include hosting?
Umbraco describes its Free plan as an option for teams self-hosting the CMS. The plan includes authoring, media management, user management, multilingual setup, APIs, and webhooks. The pricing page lists managed Starter hosting separately at €45 per month.
Which CMS is better for a custom front end?
Craft explicitly supports Twig templates and a decoupled GraphQL API, alongside a customizable back end. Umbraco describes its CMS as flexible for developers and includes headless APIs and webhooks on Free. Compare the implementation your developer wants to build; neither option removes the need to configure the project.