review galore

Head-to-head · Identity & access

CyberArk vs HashiCorp Vault

Vault publishes a lower-cost starting point; CyberArk covers broader identity needs but requires a custom quote.

CyberArk

4.6/10
VS

HashiCorp Vault

7.1/10

We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never changes a score or a ranking. How we make money

Short answer

Most buyers should pick HashiCorp Vault.

Pick HashiCorp Vault if your main job is storing application secrets and you can manage hourly cluster charges plus per-client fees: Essentials starts at $1.58 per cluster-hour and $73 per Vault client monthly. Pick CyberArk if you need broader controls for privileged, human, machine, and AI-agent identities and can get a custom quote. Neither has a listed free plan, and neither is an obvious budget buy without pricing and setup scoping.

01Side by side

CyberArkHashiCorp Vault
Free planNo free plan listedNo free plan listed
Cheapest paid planCustom quoteDevelopment: $0.62 per cluster-hour
Price per seatNot published$73/client monthly on Essentials and Standard
Cost for fiveCustom quote$365/month plus cluster-hour charges
Setup effortReview reports setup frictionReview says to budget for setup
Learning curveReview ease score: 3Review ease score: 5
Integrations and access routesAgent discovery spans SaaS, cloud, developer environmentsUI, CLI, and HTTP API
SupportReview support score: 5Review support score: 6

Choose CyberArk if

  • Choose CyberArk if you need broad identity-security controls.
  • Choose CyberArk if privileged access is a core requirement.
  • Choose CyberArk if custom pricing fits your procurement process.

Choose HashiCorp Vault if

  • Choose HashiCorp Vault if secrets management is your main need.
  • Choose HashiCorp Vault if hourly cluster pricing suits your budget.
  • Choose HashiCorp Vault if teams need UI, CLI, and API access.

02What each costs a small team

Neither vendor lists a free plan. The CyberArk pricing page lists custom quotes only, with no monthly or annual amount. So one person and a 3–5 person team both need a sales quote; the price per seat and a five-person total are not published. Ask for the minimum package, seat definition, implementation fees, and renewal terms.

Vault's HCP Dedicated Development tier starts at $0.62 per cluster-hour and allows up to 25 clients, but the vendor doesn't publish monthly or annual totals. For a paid team tier, Essentials starts at $1.58 per cluster-hour plus $73 per Vault client monthly. That means one client is $73 a month plus cluster hours; five clients are $365 a month plus cluster hours. Standard starts at $1.85 per cluster-hour with the same client fee. The $500 HCP trial credit applies to Essentials and Standard, not a listed free plan.

03Setup and day-to-day use

Neither vendor publishes a time-to-setup estimate, so don't plan a rollout around a promised number of days. CyberArk's scope spans privileged access, identity discovery, machine identities, agent discovery, lifecycle governance, and threat monitoring. A small team should scope which identity types and controls it actually needs before requesting a quote; the review reports setup friction.

Vault is focused on secrets and sensitive data, but still needs decisions about what to store, who can read it, and how apps connect. Its listed interfaces are a UI, CLI, and HTTP API; dynamic database credentials depend on preconfigured roles. Expect configuration work and budget for it, especially with a managed cluster. The review also flags setup costs and rising managed-service costs. Ask each vendor for implementation scope and who owns ongoing policy changes.

04What you get on the cheaper plans

CyberArk's pitch is broader than a secrets vault: its platform combines privileged access management with controls for human, machine, and agentic identities. Its feature list includes identity discovery, dynamic privilege controls, machine-identity and workload protection, finding AI agents across SaaS, cloud, and developer settings, lifecycle governance, and threat monitoring. But pricing is custom, so ask which capabilities are included in the entry package; CyberArk doesn't list a self-serve low-cost tier.

Vault focuses on storing secrets such as passwords, tokens, certificates, and encryption keys, then controlling access to them. The product description also lists key-value storage, dynamically generated database credentials, and transit encryption, with UI, CLI, or HTTP API access. Secret transformation, which maps sensitive data to cryptographically secure tokens, is identified as an Enterprise feature. The pricing page lists Development, Essentials, and Standard HCP Dedicated tiers, but doesn't publish feature mapping by tier. Confirm what Essentials includes before budgeting.

Questions people ask

What is the difference between a Vault and a safe in CyberArk?

CyberArk describes its platform in terms of privileged access and identity security. Vault is HashiCorp's tool for storing secrets and controlling access to sensitive data. “Safe” is CyberArk-specific terminology; ask CyberArk how its safe model maps to the access controls and use case you need.

What is the point of HashiCorp Vault?

Vault securely stores and manages secrets such as passwords, tokens, certificates, and encryption keys. It controls access to sensitive data and can provide dynamically generated database credentials and transit encryption. Teams can work with it through a UI, CLI, or HTTP API.

Who are CyberArk's main competitors?

The products compared here overlap in privileged access and secrets-related needs, but they have different emphasis: CyberArk presents broader identity security, while Vault focuses on secrets management. For a shortlist beyond these two, compare vendors against your required controls and ask for current pricing and scope.

Is CyberArk a PAM or PIM?

CyberArk explicitly presents privileged access management, or PAM, as part of its identity-security offering. Whether a particular CyberArk deployment also meets your organization's definition of PIM depends on the scope and controls you need. Ask the vendor to map the proposed package to those requirements.