We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never changes a score or a ranking. How we make money
It's a split decision.
Choose Employee Navigator if benefits administration, ACA reporting, and a broad integration catalog matter—and your broker can get a written quote. Choose GoCo if you already use it and want to keep its HR tools and Gusto-powered embedded payroll. For a new 1–10-person buyer, neither has a published price to compare, and GoCo's current-customer continuity statement is not a new-customer offer. Get a quote and confirm availability, onboarding help, and total fees before deciding.
01Side by side
| Employee Navigator | GoCo | |
|---|---|---|
| Free plan | No free plan listed | No free plan listed |
| Cheapest paid plan | Enhanced; price not published | GoCo pricing not published |
| Price per seat | Base PEPM not published; EDI costs extra | Per-seat price not published |
| Cost for a team of 5 | Five-seat total needs a quote | Five-seat total not published |
| Setup effort | Timeline unpublished; coordinate with broker | Timeline and onboarding terms unpublished |
| Learning curve | No published learning-curve details | No published learning-curve details |
| Useful integrations | 600+ integrations listed | Embedded payroll powered by Gusto |
| Support | Priority phone support on Platinum | Support terms not published |
Employee Navigator Choose Employee Navigator if
- Choose Employee Navigator if benefits enrollment and ACA reporting are priorities.
- Choose it if your broker can help scope and quote the setup.
- Choose it if you need a broad integration catalog.
GoCo Choose GoCo if
- Choose GoCo if you already use it and want to continue.
- Choose it if Gusto-powered embedded payroll fits your current workflow.
- Choose it if you can get written pricing and availability for your team.
02What each costs a small team
Neither product gives a small team a published free option: Employee Navigator lists no free plan, and GoCo publishes no GoCo plan prices or billing terms. Employee Navigator names Enhanced, Enhanced Plus, Elite, and Platinum, but says to contact sales for a quote. Enhanced is the entry named tier for broker-led benefits administration; its price is not published, so a one-person monthly bill and a three-to-five-person bill cannot be calculated.
GoCo's per-seat rate and cheapest paid tier are also not published. Its current-customer notice says existing customers can keep using GoCo, but that does not establish a price or availability for a new buyer. One visible add-on is Employee Navigator's 834 EDI feed: $0.45 per employee per month on Enhanced Plus and Elite, free on Platinum, unavailable on Enhanced. For five employees, that fee alone is $2.25 monthly; base plan and other fees remain unknown. Ask both vendors for a five-seat quote and all reporting and support charges.
03Setup and day-to-day use
Neither vendor publishes a setup timeline, so we wouldn't budget a day or a week without an estimate from the vendor. Employee Navigator covers online enrollment, carrier, payroll and TPA integrations, and ACA reporting. Ask how benefits data and payroll connections are configured, who handles reporting, and whether your broker will help set up the account. Its homepage lists more than 600 integrations, but confirm your payroll and carrier are among them and ask about any related fees.
GoCo describes HR workflows, time tracking, and team management, with embedded payroll powered by Gusto. Ask what employee records, time rules, payroll settings, and compliance workflows need configuring, and what support is included. GoCo says current customers can keep using the product; ongoing investment in onboarding and compliance is planned. Ask either vendor for migration scope, training, launch timing, and named support before signing.
04What you get on the cheaper plans
Employee Navigator's entry named tier, Enhanced, is aimed at brokers needing benefits administration. It includes online enrollment, carrier, payroll and TPA integrations, ACA reporting, and AI Plan Builds. Enhanced Plus adds 834 EDI files, third-party apps, and unlimited companies and employees. Elite adds an enrollment assistance tool, new-hire onboarding, and PTO and vacation tracking; Platinum adds priority phone support and $0 PEPM for 834 EDI. Base prices are not published, and extra fees apply for 1095/1094 reporting and email and phone support; the amounts are unpublished.
GoCo's published feature description covers HR workflows, embedded payroll powered by Gusto, time tracking, and team management. It says current embedded payroll continues to work. Ongoing investment in onboarding and compliance is planned, but no named lower-tier feature bundle or GoCo price is published. Ask which features are included in your quote rather than assuming a feature list maps to a low-cost plan.
Questions people ask
Can a small team use Employee Navigator or GoCo for free?
Neither product lists a free plan. Employee Navigator plan prices and GoCo billing terms are also unpublished, so a team can't compare a no-cost tier for its workflows. Ask each vendor about demo or trial terms directly; neither publishes free-trial terms in the pricing details.
Which is cheaper for a team of five?
There isn't enough published pricing to say. Employee Navigator requires a quote, and GoCo doesn't publish its plan prices or billing terms. Employee Navigator's 834 EDI feed adds $2.25 per month for five employees on Enhanced Plus or Elite, but that is only the add-on fee, not the plan total.
Does Employee Navigator include payroll?
Employee Navigator lists payroll integrations, not a payroll service in its plan descriptions. GoCo describes embedded payroll powered by Gusto and says it continues to work for current customers. Ask Employee Navigator which payroll connections it supports and ask GoCo what payroll costs and terms apply to your account.
Can a new customer still sign up for GoCo?
GoCo says current customers can keep using the product and that embedded payroll powered by Gusto continues to work. That statement doesn't confirm whether new customers can sign up. Contact GoCo to confirm availability, pricing, and what ongoing support applies to your business.