We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never changes a score or a ranking. How we make money
It's a split decision.
Choose Employee Navigator if benefits enrollment, ACA reporting, and broker-connected administration are your main needs. Choose Paylocity if you want HR and payroll alongside finance and IT tools. Neither has a published price or free plan, so a small team can’t compare costs from list prices alone. Ask both vendors for written quotes covering five employees, required modules, implementation, support, and any reporting or integration fees before choosing.
01Side by side
| Employee Navigator | Paylocity | |
|---|---|---|
| Free plan | No free plan listed | No free plan listed |
| Cheapest paid plan | Prices not published; request a quote | Custom quote; prices not published |
| Price per seat | Not published | Not published |
| Cost for five | Not published; ask for a five-person quote | Not published; ask for a five-person quote |
| Setup effort | Setup time not published | Setup time not published |
| Learning curve | Not published | Not published |
| Integrations | Homepage says more than 600 integrations | Integration count not published |
| Support | Priority phone support on Platinum | Expert support for payroll and taxes |
Employee Navigator Choose Employee Navigator if
- Choose Employee Navigator if benefits enrollment is your main need.
- Choose Employee Navigator if ACA reporting matters to your team.
- Choose Employee Navigator if your broker recommends its platform.
Paylocity Choose Paylocity if
- Choose Paylocity if you want HR and payroll together.
- Choose Paylocity if finance or IT tools are also priorities.
- Choose Paylocity if you want one platform across those functions.
02What each costs a small team
Neither vendor lists a free plan or a starting price. Employee Navigator’s Enhanced, Enhanced Plus, Elite, and Platinum plan prices are not published; the pricing page says to contact sales. Paylocity lists a custom plan, with quote-based pricing and no published monthly or annual terms.
For one person, neither vendor provides a public per-seat price. The same goes for a team of three to five: there’s no published total to calculate. Employee Navigator also lists a $0.45 PEPM charge for 834 EDI feeds on Enhanced Plus and Elite; the feed is free on Platinum and unavailable on Enhanced. Additional 1095 and 1094 reporting fees, plus email and phone support fees, are not published. Paylocity’s add-on and overage costs aren’t published either. Ask both vendors for a written quote for your headcount and required features.
03Setup and day-to-day use
Neither vendor publishes a setup timeline or enough detail to compare implementation effort. Before signing, ask who configures the account, what information your team must provide, whether setup is included in the quote, and what support costs extra.
For Employee Navigator, clarify how your broker, benefits enrollment, carrier or payroll integrations, and ACA reporting will be configured. If you need onboarding or time-off tracking, ask about those too. For Paylocity, ask which HR, payroll, talent, and finance modules your quote includes, and who handles payroll and tax setup.
The learning curve is not published for either product, so don’t assume one will be easier for a small team. Request a walkthrough focused on the tasks your employees and administrator will actually use, then confirm training and ongoing support terms in writing.
04What you get on the cheaper plans
Employee Navigator’s listed tiers start with Enhanced, which includes online enrollment, carrier, payroll and TPA integrations, ACA reporting, and AI Plan Builds. Enhanced Plus adds 834 EDI files and third-party apps. Elite adds an enrollment assistance tool, new-hire onboarding, and PTO and vacation tracking. Platinum adds priority phone support and $0 PEPM for 834 EDI. Prices aren’t published, so these tiers can’t be compared by cost without a quote.
Paylocity lists custom HR, payroll, talent, and finance modules, but doesn’t publish a low-cost bundle or the modules included at a particular price. Its platform also covers IT management, mobile access, and analytics and reporting. A small team should ask which of those functions are included in its proposed package. Employee Navigator is the more benefits-centered option; Paylocity describes a broader collection of workplace tools.
Questions people ask
What does Paylocity do?
Paylocity combines HR, payroll, finance, and IT tools for employers. Its listed capabilities include payroll and tax filing, workforce management, spend management, IT asset and access management, a mobile app, and analytics and reporting. Pricing is custom, and the vendor doesn’t publish a starting price.
How does Employee Navigator work?
Employee Navigator brings benefits administration, HR, and compliance tools together. Its listed features include online enrollment, ACA reporting, payroll integrations, onboarding, and time-off tracking. The homepage says it connects employers, brokers, and partners, with more than 600 integrations. Ask your broker or the vendor which tier fits your needs.
What are the reviews and complaints about Paylocity?
Our review score for Paylocity is 5.2 out of 10, with a higher features score than value, support, ease of use, or user sentiment. A key budget concern for small teams is that the vendor doesn’t publish prices or add-on costs, making costs harder to assess before requesting a quote.
What is similar to Paylocity?
Employee Navigator is an alternative if your main need is benefits administration, enrollment, and related HR or compliance tools. It is not a like-for-like match for Paylocity’s listed finance and IT functions. Compare the specific modules you need, then request written quotes from both vendors.