We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never changes a score or a ranking. How we make money
It's a split decision.
For a small team that mainly needs benefits enrollment, Employee Navigator is the more focused option: its named tiers include enrollment, integrations, and—at higher levels—onboarding and time-off tracking. UKG Pro is the broader choice when payroll and workforce management belong in the same system. Neither vendor publishes a rate or offers a free plan, so a team of one or five cannot compare costs from list prices; get written, scope-matched quotes before choosing.
01Side by side
| Employee Navigator | UKG Pro | |
|---|---|---|
| Free plan | No free plan | No free plan |
| Cheapest named plan | Enhanced; price requires a quote | UKG Pro; custom quote |
| Price per seat | Not published | Not published |
| Cost for five | Not published; request a quote | Not published; request a quote |
| Setup effort | Setup time not published | Setup time not published |
| Learning curve | Review ease score: 6/10 | Review ease score: 4/10 |
| Integrations | More than 600; includes payroll integrations | Integration count not published |
| Support | Priority phone support on Platinum | Support details not published |
Employee Navigator Choose Employee Navigator if
- Choose Employee Navigator if benefits enrollment is your main need.
- Choose Employee Navigator if its broker-supported setup fits your workflow.
- Choose Employee Navigator if you need onboarding and PTO at higher tiers.
UKG Pro Choose UKG Pro if
- Choose UKG Pro if payroll belongs in the same platform as HR.
- Choose UKG Pro if you need workforce management and scheduling.
- Choose UKG Pro if global payroll is part of your requirements.
02What each costs a small team
Neither vendor offers a free plan, and neither publishes a rate you can use to price one seat or a team of three to five. Employee Navigator lists Enhanced as its tier for brokers needing benefits administration, but the price and billing schedule are not published. UKG lists UKG Pro with custom pricing; its pricing page does not give a monthly or annual rate.
That means there is no reliable list-price total for one person, three people, or five. Ask both vendors for a written quote covering your team size, required modules, implementation, and support. For Employee Navigator, also ask about fees for 1095 and 1094 reporting and email or phone support. Its 834 EDI feed costs $0.45 PEPM on Enhanced Plus and Elite, and is free on Platinum. Confirm whether those items apply to your quote.
03Setup and day-to-day use
Neither vendor publishes a setup timeline, so we would not budget a specific number of days without asking. Employee Navigator’s listed tools cover benefits enrollment, integrations, ACA reporting, and—on Elite—new-hire onboarding and PTO tracking. A small team should confirm who configures each workflow, what data the vendor or broker needs, and whether help is included or billed separately.
UKG Pro combines HR, payroll, workforce management, scheduling, analytics, and compliance. Before signing, ask which modules are included in your quote and what your team must configure for payroll, schedules, and reporting. Review scores suggest Employee Navigator may feel easier: its ease-of-use score is 6/10, compared with 4/10 for UKG Pro. Those scores are directional, not a guarantee for your team. Ask for a tailored walkthrough and a clear implementation scope.
04What you get on the cheaper plans
Employee Navigator’s named entry tier, Enhanced, is aimed at brokers needing benefits administration. It includes online enrollment, carrier, payroll and TPA integrations, ACA reporting, and AI Plan Builds. Enhanced Plus adds 834 EDI files and third-party apps. Elite adds an enrollment assistance tool, new-hire onboarding, and PTO and vacation tracking. Platinum adds priority phone support and $0 PEPM for 834 EDI. The vendor says its platform has more than 600 integrations, but confirm which ones your quote includes.
UKG Pro brings HR, payroll, workforce management, scheduling, analytics, and compliance into its platform. Its product overview also highlights global payroll and union workforce scheduling. UKG does not publish a rate or feature breakdown by lower-priced tiers, so ask which capabilities are included in your custom quote. Employee Navigator connects to payroll systems, but its listed features describe payroll integrations—not a payroll system of its own.
Questions people ask
Is Employee Navigator a payroll system?
Employee Navigator lists payroll integrations, alongside benefits administration, HR, and compliance tools. That means it can connect with payroll systems, but its listed features do not describe it as a payroll system. Ask your broker which payroll providers integrate with the specific plan you are considering.
What's the difference between UKG Pro and UKG Ready?
UKG Pro is positioned for HR, payroll, and workforce management. We can’t substantiate a detailed Pro-versus-Ready feature split from UKG’s published details, so ask UKG to compare modules, team-size fit, implementation, and total quoted cost before treating Ready as the small-team option.
What are people saying about Employee Navigator?
The review rates Employee Navigator 6.5/10 overall, with 7/10 for features, 6/10 for ease of use, and 6/10 for support and user sentiment. Its practical takeaway: consider it through your broker, but get a written quote before putting it in the budget.
Does Employee Navigator have an app?
Employee Navigator’s published feature summary does not establish whether it offers a mobile app or what an app supports. Ask Employee Navigator or your broker whether employees can enroll, view benefits, or manage other tasks on mobile, and whether those functions depend on your plan.