review galore

Head-to-head · Rewards software

Goody vs Online Rewards

For small teams, Goody offers a free starting point; Online Rewards is for businesses seeking a managed, custom rewards program.

Goody

7.2/10
VS

Online Rewards

5.6/10

We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never changes a score or a ranking. How we make money

Short answer

Most buyers should pick Goody.

A small team that wants to send occasional gifts should start with Goody: its Starter plan costs $0 for unlimited seats and includes unlimited gifts, with shipping listed for the US, UK, and Canada. Goody Pro is the clearer choice if you need shipping to 140+ countries. Online Rewards is built for managed, branded incentive programs, not a simple per-seat budget; its custom, bill-on-redemption price means you’ll need a quote. Pick it when program design and fulfillment matter more than predictable spend.

01Side by side

GoodyOnline Rewards
Free planStarter: $0; unlimited seatsNo free plan
Cheapest paid optionPro: $20/user monthly, billed annuallyCustom quote; bill per redemption
Price per seatPro is priced per userPer-redemption pricing; seat price unpublished
Cost for five$100/month annual billing; $125 monthlyCustom quote; five-person cost unpublished
Setup effortSetup time and process unpublishedIn-house teams support program design and build
Learning curveNot publishedNot published
IntegrationsAutomation and Commerce APIs, plus MCP serverCatalog API for global rewards
SupportSupport details not publishedIn-house program strategy and ongoing support

Choose Goody if

  • Choose Goody if you want a free plan for a small team.
  • Choose Goody if you need to send gifts without addresses upfront.
  • Choose Goody if you want a per-user price for international shipping.

Choose Online Rewards if

  • Choose Online Rewards if you need a managed incentive program.
  • Choose Online Rewards if branded program design and fulfillment matter.
  • Choose Online Rewards if bill-on-redemption pricing fits your budget.

02What each costs a small team

Goody Starter costs $0 and includes unlimited seats, unlimited gifts and custom swag, and shipping to the US, UK, and Canada. One person or a team of five can use it at no seat charge. If you need Pro’s shipping to 140+ countries, the pricing page lists $20 per user per month with annual billing or $25 with monthly billing: one user costs $20 or $25 monthly, and five cost $100 or $125 monthly, respectively. Online Rewards has no free plan or published per-seat rate. Its pricing is custom and billed per redemption, so a one-person or five-person total isn’t available without a quote. Ask the vendor for the quote, any program fees, and what counts as a redemption before comparing budgets.

03Setup and day-to-day use

Goody’s basic gifting flow is straightforward on paper: send a gift by email, SMS, or shareable link, and the recipient adds a shipping address when accepting it. They can accept, swap for an equal-value option, or pay the difference to upgrade. You can also send by CSV and schedule milestone gifts. Goody doesn’t publish how long setup takes or what configuration a small team should expect, so ask about catalog selection and any account setup before committing.

Online Rewards involves shaping a program around business goals and rules. Its in-house teams support strategy, financial modeling, build, marketing, and ongoing support. That service may suit teams that want help designing a program, but setup time and the amount of work required from your team aren’t published. Ask who handles configuration, approvals, and day-to-day changes.

04What you get on the cheaper plans

Goody Starter gives small teams unlimited seats, unlimited gifts and custom swag, sends to 1,000+ recipients at once, and shipping to the US, UK, and Canada. Goody’s gifting flow lets recipients provide their address after receiving a link, then accept or swap a gift. The catalog covers physical products and gift cards from more than 600 brands. Pro adds shipping to 140+ countries; its listed price is per user. Team has custom pricing and includes SAML Single Sign-On, while SAML is also a paid add-on for Starter and Pro at an unpublished price.

Online Rewards doesn’t list a cheaper self-serve plan: its offer is custom-priced. The service includes program design, branded programs, rewards sourcing and fulfillment, and reporting. Its homepage describes a catalog with more than 2 million rewards across more than 80 regions. The Catalog API supports multiple countries, currencies, and languages. Ask which capabilities and services are included in your quote.

Questions people ask

Is Goody or Online Rewards cheaper for a small team?

Goody is easier to budget for: Starter is free for unlimited seats in its listed shipping regions. Pro has a published per-user rate. Online Rewards uses custom pricing billed per redemption, and the vendor doesn’t publish a sample cost for a small team. Get a quote before comparing totals.

Can a team of five use Goody for free?

Yes. Goody Starter lists unlimited seats and costs $0, with shipping to the US, UK, and Canada. If the team needs Pro’s shipping to 140+ countries, the listed cost for five users is $100 per month with annual billing or $125 with monthly billing.

Does Online Rewards have a free plan?

No free plan is listed. Online Rewards offers custom pricing based on business requirements and bills per redemption. Monthly and annual billing details aren’t published, so ask the vendor for a quote and a breakdown of any program costs before signing.

Which product is better for sending employee gifts?

Goody is the closer fit for sending individual gifts: recipients can receive a gift link, provide their address, and accept or swap the gift. Online Rewards is aimed at managed incentive and loyalty programs, with program design, fulfillment, and reporting.