We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never changes a score or a ranking. How we make money
Most buyers should pick Google Search Console.
Most small teams should start with Google Search Console: it’s free and covers Google search performance, indexing, page experience and security alerts. Pick Semrush when you need broader keyword research, backlink analysis, rank tracking, site audits or AI visibility tools. Its SEO plan starts at $117.33 per month when billed annually, and additional users start at $45 per month. For a five-person team, confirm the seat total with Semrush before budgeting; its published pricing doesn’t state the included-seat allowance.
01Side by side
| Google Search Console | Semrush | |
|---|---|---|
| Free plan | Free Search performance and site reports | 10 reports daily; one demo project |
| Cheapest paid plan | No paid plan listed | $117.33/month annual; $139 monthly |
| Price per seat | $0/month | Additional users start at $45/month |
| Cost for five | $0/month | Total not published; extra users cost more |
| Setup effort | Setup time not published; focused Search tools | Setup time not published; broader toolset |
| Learning curve | Review ease score: 7/10 | Review ease score: 6/10 |
| Small-team integrations | Search Console reports and site tools | MCP access on Starter |
| Support | Review support score: 5/10 | Review support score: 5/10 |
Google Search Console Choose Google Search Console if
- Choose Google Search Console if you need free Google Search performance reports.
- Choose Google Search Console if indexing and site issue reports are your priority.
- Choose Google Search Console if a paid SEO suite won’t fit your budget.
Semrush Choose Semrush if
- Choose Semrush if you need keyword and competitor research in one platform.
- Choose Semrush if backlink analysis, rank tracking and site audits matter.
- Choose Semrush if you need AI visibility tools and can budget for seats.
02What each costs a small team
Google Search Console costs $0 per month, with performance reports, URL inspection, indexing and sitemap reports, page experience, and security alerts listed as included. The pricing page lists no paid plan.
Semrush’s cheapest paid option is SEO: $117.33 per month when billed annually, or $139 month to month. That plan covers five websites and 500 daily tracked keywords. Starter, aimed at small teams and agencies, is $165.17 monthly with annual billing or $199 month to month.
For one person, those are the listed subscription prices; Semrush also lists additional users starting at $45 per month. For a team of three to five, the exact total isn’t published because the included-seat allowance isn’t stated. Ask Semrush for the cost with your required logins before signing up. Search Console remains free for a small team.
03Setup and day-to-day use
Neither product publishes a setup-time estimate, so we wouldn’t budget a specific number of hours from the pricing details alone. Search Console has a narrower job: check search performance, inspect URLs, review indexing and sitemaps, and monitor page experience or security alerts. That scope can keep day-to-day work focused on Google Search.
Semrush combines keyword research, competitor and backlink analysis, rank tracking, content tools, technical audits and AI visibility tracking. A small team will need to decide which of those areas it plans to use and who needs access. The pricing page lists different website, keyword and prompt limits by plan, so check those against your workflow. Review ease-of-use scores are 7/10 for Search Console and 6/10 for Semrush; treat those as review ratings, not a setup guarantee.
04What you get on the cheaper plans
Search Console’s free service includes performance reports for clicks, impressions, CTR and position, with filters for queries, pages, countries, devices and search types. It also offers URL inspection and live tests, indexing and sitemap reports, Core Web Vitals and HTTPS status, structured-data monitoring, and security and manual-action alerts. It is useful for Google Search visibility, not a replacement for broader rank tracking or analytics.
Semrush’s free plan is limited to one demo project and 10 reports per day across its vital tools; the pricing page also lists AI Visibility features. Its paid SEO plan adds five websites, 500 daily tracked keywords, keyword research and competitor analysis, Position Tracking and Site Audit, plus AI search performance and sentiment monitoring. Starter adds MCP access, 50 daily tracked prompts and 300 AI visibility reports per day. For a team that only needs Google’s own search reporting, paying for that wider suite may be unnecessary.
Questions people ask
Is Google Search Console still a thing?
Yes. Google describes Search Console as a free service for site owners to measure search traffic and performance, fix issues, and improve visibility in Google Search. Its listed tools include performance reports, URL inspection, indexing and sitemap reports, page experience reporting, and security alerts.
Is Google Search Console good for SEO?
Yes, for understanding and improving a site’s visibility in Google Search. It reports clicks, impressions, CTR and position, and helps monitor crawling, indexing, page experience and security issues. It is narrower than a broader SEO suite: it isn’t a replacement for analytics or broader rank tracking.
What are the top three SEO tools?
There isn’t one top-three list that fits every small team. For free Google Search reporting, Search Console is a practical starting point. Semrush covers keyword research, backlink analysis, rank tracking, content optimization and technical audits. Choose based on the work you need and what your budget can support.
Is Semrush better than Google Analytics?
They serve different jobs based on their listed features. Semrush focuses on SEO and AI-search visibility, including keywords, backlinks and rank tracking. Search Console focuses on Google Search performance and site issues. If you need general website analytics, check each vendor’s current product details against that specific need.