review galore

Head-to-head · Payroll tools

Heartland Payroll vs RUN Powered by ADP

Heartland shows a starting price and detailed platform features; RUN offers a quote-based alternative with less pricing detail.

Heartland Payroll

6.0/10
VS

RUN Powered by ADP

5.8/10

We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never changes a score or a ranking. How we make money

Short answer

Most buyers should pick Heartland Payroll.

For a small team that needs a known starting price and wants payroll, tax administration, time tracking and HR tools, Heartland is easier to size up: Essentials starts at $89 per month for 1–5 employees. Choose RUN Powered by ADP if you want to compare ADP’s small-business services and are willing to request a quote. Neither vendor lists a free plan, and neither publishes setup time or a specific learning curve.

01Side by side

Heartland PayrollRUN Powered by ADP
Free planNo free plan listedNo free plan listed
Published entry priceEssentials starts at $89/monthEssential Payroll price not published
Price per seatStarting price; exact seat cost variesNot published
Cost for fiveStarts at $89/month for 1–5Request a quote
Setup effortSetup time not publishedSetup time not published
Learning curveNot publishedNot published
Small-team integrationsIntegrations not publishedIntegrations not published
Support (review score)Score: 6Score: 5

Choose Heartland Payroll if

  • Choose Heartland Payroll if you want a published starting price.
  • Choose Heartland Payroll if you need payroll and tax administration.
  • Choose Heartland Payroll if time, hiring and HR tools matter.

Choose RUN Powered by ADP if

  • Choose RUN if you want to compare ADP’s small-business services.
  • Choose RUN if you’re willing to request custom pricing.
  • Choose RUN if you want to ask about payroll and HR options.

02What each costs a small team

Neither vendor lists a free plan. Heartland’s Essentials plan starts at $89 per month for businesses with 1–5 employees. That is the published starting price for a one-person team; for three to five people, the plan still starts at $89, but the vendor doesn’t publish a final quote for each team size. At the starting price, dividing $89 by five gives $17.80 per person, but treat that as a floor, not a confirmed per-seat rate.

ADP lists Essential Payroll for businesses with 1–49 employees, but doesn’t publish its monthly or annual price. ADP advertises a “3 Months Free” promotion; that’s not a published free plan or trial. For either vendor, ask what the quote includes and whether add-ons change the bill. Heartland lists Time as an add-on with no published price; ADP’s add-on prices aren’t published either.

03Setup and day-to-day use

Neither vendor publishes a setup timeline or a specific learning curve, so ask how long payroll setup typically takes for a team your size and what help is included. Heartland describes tools for payroll, tax administration, time and attendance, hiring, onboarding, HR resources and employee self-service. That range may mean configuring more than payroll alone if you plan to use the broader platform.

For day-to-day work, Heartland says employees can view pay stubs and tax forms, update details and submit hours. Its time tools cover hours, schedules, overtime estimates and PTO requests. ADP lists payroll and HR solutions for small businesses, along with time and attendance, but doesn’t specify which features come with each RUN plan. Before choosing either, confirm who handles setup, what information you must provide, and whether the features you need are included in the quoted plan.

04What you get on the cheaper plans

Heartland describes a broad platform: payroll processing, direct deposit, printed checks and pay cards; federal, state and local payroll tax administration; time and attendance; hiring and paperless onboarding; HR resources; and employee self-service. But the pricing page lists only the employee range and starting price for Essentials. It doesn’t publish which of those tools are included at that tier, so confirm the Essentials feature list before treating it as an all-in-one package.

ADP lists Essential Payroll as its entry plan for businesses with 1–49 employees. ADP’s small-business lineup includes payroll, HR, time and attendance, retirement, health benefits and workers’ compensation. The vendor doesn’t specify which of these are included with RUN’s cheaper plans, and add-on prices aren’t published. For a fair comparison, ask both vendors for a quote that spells out payroll, tax filing, employee access, time tracking and any services your team needs. Don’t compare the full platform descriptions with a plan until the vendor confirms what that plan includes.

Questions people ask

Does Heartland Payroll or RUN have a free plan?

Neither vendor lists a free plan. ADP advertises a “3 Months Free” promotion, but that is not a published free plan or trial. Heartland Essentials starts at $89 per month for businesses with 1–5 employees. Ask ADP for a quote and confirm how its promotion applies to your business.

How much does Heartland Payroll cost for a team of five?

Heartland lists Essentials starting at $89 per month for businesses with 1–5 employees. That is the published starting price for a five-person team, not a guaranteed final quote. The vendor doesn’t publish a separate price for exactly five employees, so confirm the total and any add-on costs.

Is RUN Powered by ADP cheaper than Heartland?

There isn’t enough published pricing to establish that. Heartland Essentials starts at $89 per month for 1–5 employees, while ADP doesn’t publish RUN plan prices. Request quotes for the same headcount and services, including any time, benefits or workers’ compensation add-ons, before comparing totals.

Which is easier to set up for a small team?

Neither vendor publishes a setup timeline or a specific learning curve. Heartland describes a wider set of payroll and HR tools, while ADP doesn’t spell out RUN-specific features on its small-business homepage. Ask each vendor what setup involves, what support is included and how long it usually takes for a team like yours.