review galore

Head-to-head · Observability tools

incident.io vs PagerDuty

Both have free plans. incident.io costs less per paid seat; PagerDuty spells out its free plan’s user and notification limits.

incident.io

7.5/10
VS

PagerDuty

7.0/10

We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never changes a score or a ranking. How we make money

Short answer

Most buyers should pick incident.io.

For a small team that wants to start without a bill, incident.io Basic offers Slack or Microsoft Teams response, single-team on-call, a status page and essential automation at no charge. PagerDuty Free is explicit about its five-user cap and includes one schedule, one escalation policy and 100 monthly SMS or phone notifications. For paid seats, incident.io Team starts at $15 per user monthly with annual billing; PagerDuty Professional starts at $21. Choose based on which free-plan limits fit.

01Side by side

incident.ioPagerDuty
Free planFree; response, on-call, status page, essential automationFree; 5 users, schedule, policy, 100 notifications
Cheapest paid planTeam: $15/user/month annually; $19 monthlyProfessional: $21/user/month annually; $25 monthly
Annual price per seat$15 per user/month on Team$21 per user/month on Professional
Five-seat cost$75/month annual rate; $95 monthly billing$105/month annual rate; $125 monthly billing
Setup effortSetup time not published; configure schedules and workflowsSetup time not published; configure schedule and escalation policy
Learning curveVendor does not publish learning-curve dataVendor does not publish learning-curve data
IntegrationsTeam includes unlimited integrationsIntegration count not published
SupportReview support score: 7/10Review support score: 5/10

Choose incident.io if

  • Choose incident.io if you want a free response hub with a status page.
  • Choose incident.io if lower per-seat pricing matters for a small team.
  • Choose incident.io if unlimited integrations on Team suit your setup.

Choose PagerDuty if

  • Choose PagerDuty if its five-user free plan fits your on-call needs.
  • Choose PagerDuty if you want a free plan with stated notification limits.
  • Choose PagerDuty if you need its listed escalation-policy setup.

02What each costs a small team

Both vendors have a free plan. incident.io Basic includes Slack or Microsoft Teams response, single-team on-call, a status page and essential incident automation. PagerDuty Free covers five users, one on-call schedule, one escalation policy and 100 SMS or phone notifications per month.

For paid seats, incident.io Team is $19 per user monthly, or $15 with annual billing. That’s $19 or $15 monthly for one person, and $95 or $75 for five. On-call is a separate $10 per user monthly add-on on Team, so ask how it applies to annual billing.

PagerDuty Professional is $25 per user monthly, or $21 annually billed: $25 or $21 for one person, and $125 or $105 for five. PagerDuty also lists platform-fee plans, starting at $2,800 per year for Starter.

03Setup and day-to-day use

Neither vendor publishes a standard setup time, so we wouldn’t budget a specific number of hours based on the pricing pages alone. Ask each vendor what it takes to connect your alert sources and configure an initial on-call rotation.

For incident.io, the free plan lists single-team on-call and response in Slack or Microsoft Teams. Team adds two schedules and three workflows; the team will need to decide how those schedules and automations should work. PagerDuty Free lists one schedule and one escalation policy, which gives a small team explicit starting limits to configure.

Neither vendor publishes comparable learning-curve data. PagerDuty Professional adds an enhanced chat experience and post-incident reviews. Before choosing, check that the chat, alert routing and escalation setup match how your team handles incidents now.

04What you get on the cheaper plans

incident.io Basic includes response in Slack or Microsoft Teams, single-team on-call, a status page and essential incident automation. Its Team plan adds two schedules, three workflows, three custom fields and unlimited integrations. The pricing page lists the on-call feature as a separate $10-per-user monthly add-on with Team, so confirm which plan and add-ons cover your rotation.

PagerDuty Free includes five users, one on-call schedule, one escalation policy and 100 SMS or phone notifications each month. Professional adds up to five users per escalation level, an enhanced chat experience and post-incident reviews. The vendor lists AIOps, PagerDuty Advance, Runbook Automation, Status Pages and Live Call Routing as separate Professional add-ons.

Both products describe AI and broader reliability features, but don’t assume every feature is included in these entry plans. incident.io lists root cause analysis and its autonomous agent as paid add-ons, with prices not published.

Questions people ask

Is incident.io cheaper than PagerDuty?

For paid per-seat plans, yes: incident.io Team is $15 per user monthly with annual billing, compared with $21 for PagerDuty Professional. Monthly billing is $19 and $25, respectively. incident.io’s On-call add-on costs extra on Team, so include it when comparing the plans your team needs.

Which product has the better free plan?

It depends on what you need. incident.io Basic lists Slack or Microsoft Teams response, single-team on-call, a status page and essential automation. PagerDuty Free specifies five users, one schedule, one escalation policy and 100 monthly SMS or phone notifications. Compare those limits with your team’s workflow.

How much does each cost for five people?

For five seats, incident.io Team is $75 monthly at its annual-billing rate or $95 with monthly billing. PagerDuty Professional is $105 monthly with annual billing or $125 monthly. incident.io lists On-call as a separate $10-per-user monthly add-on on Team.

Which is easier to set up for a small team?

Neither vendor publishes a standard setup time or comparable learning-curve data. incident.io’s free plan lists single-team on-call, while PagerDuty Free lists one schedule and one escalation policy. Ask both vendors about connecting your alert sources and configuring your team’s routing.