review galore

Head-to-head · Observability tools

Nagios XI vs New Relic

Compare free limits, real team-of-five costs, setup effort, and when each tool fits a small team.

Nagios XI

6.2/10
VS

New Relic

7.2/10

We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never changes a score or a ranking. How we make money

Short answer

Most buyers should pick New Relic.

For a small team that needs application, infrastructure, log, and user-experience monitoring, we’d start with New Relic: its free plan includes 100 GB of monthly ingest and one full-platform user. Add paid users carefully; five full-platform users on Standard list at $406 per month. Pick Nagios XI for active infrastructure monitoring if its 7-node free limit is enough or a one-time license fits your budget. Its paid 100-node Standard tier lists at $2,595, with user-seat limits unpublished.

01Side by side

Nagios XINew Relic
Free planUp to 7 nodes or 100 services100 GB monthly; 1 full-platform user
Cheapest published paid planStandard, 100 nodes: $2,595 one-timeStandard: $10/month for first full-platform user
Price per seatUser-seat limit and pricing not published$10 first; $99 each additional full-platform user
Cost for five$2,595 one-time for listed 100-node tier$406/month for five full-platform users
Setup effortConfigure active polling; setup time not publishedSetup time not published; telemetry scope is broad
Learning curveEasier configuration for teams moving from Nagios CoreMany monitoring areas to understand
Breadth for a small-team stackServers, networks, databases, applications, cloudApplications, infrastructure, logs, security, user experience
SupportFirst year included; renewal details unpublishedStandard lists two-business-day response SLA

Choose Nagios XI if

  • Choose Nagios XI if active polling is your main need.
  • Choose Nagios XI if you already run Nagios Core.
  • Choose Nagios XI if a one-time license suits your budget.

Choose New Relic if

  • Choose New Relic if you need application and infrastructure observability.
  • Choose New Relic if its 100 GB free allowance fits.
  • Choose New Relic if you can budget for added user seats.

02What each costs a small team

Nagios XI’s Free Edition costs $0 and covers up to 7 nodes or 100 services, whichever comes first. New Relic Free allows 100 GB of monthly data ingest, one full-platform user, unlimited basic users, and at least 8 days of retention.

For one paid New Relic full-platform user, Standard lists $10 per month. Three full-platform users cost $208 monthly; five cost $406 monthly, because each user after the first is $99. Core users list at $49 each. For Nagios XI, the listed Standard entry tier is 100 nodes for a one-time $2,595, with first-year maintenance and support included. That license does not price by seat, and user limits are unpublished. Ask Nagios about renewal costs before budgeting beyond year one.

03Setup and day-to-day use

Neither vendor publishes a setup-time estimate, so we wouldn’t budget this as a plug-and-play decision. Nagios XI uses active polling to check device health, service availability, and performance. Your team will need to decide which servers, networks, applications, and services to monitor, then configure those checks. Nagios says its enterprise dashboards and configuration tools make the move from Nagios Core easier.

New Relic combines application, infrastructure, log, security, and user-experience monitoring. That wider scope can be useful, but a small team should decide what data it needs and who needs full-platform access before adding users. The docs and pricing details don’t give a setup-time estimate. Compare the work of configuring Nagios checks with the telemetry your team wants in New Relic, and confirm any required integrations with each vendor.

04What you get on the cheaper plans

Nagios XI focuses on infrastructure checks: servers, networks, databases, applications, and services. Its monitoring uses active polling, and Standard includes unlimited services per licensed node. The free edition has a tight ceiling of 7 nodes or 100 services, so check which limit your environment will reach first. Enterprise dashboards and easier configuration are part of the product’s offering for teams moving from Nagios Core.

New Relic covers more observability areas, including application performance, infrastructure, logs, security, and digital experience. Its free plan has a 100 GB monthly ingest allowance, 500 synthetic checks, and at least 8 days of retention. Standard adds a two-business-day support response SLA; data beyond the included 100 GB lists at $0.40 per GB. For a small team, its free limits and ability to use basic users can help contain seat costs, but check ingest and full-platform user needs before upgrading.

Questions people ask

Is Nagios XI free for a small team?

Nagios XI has a Free Edition, limited to 7 nodes or 100 services, whichever comes first. If your environment exceeds that ceiling, the listed Standard tier starts at 100 nodes for a one-time $2,595. User-seat limits are unpublished, so confirm access needs with Nagios.

Is New Relic cheaper than Nagios XI?

For one paid full-platform user, New Relic Standard lists at $10 per month, and its free plan may be enough to start. Five full-platform users list at $406 monthly. Nagios XI’s published Standard entry tier is $2,595 one-time for 100 nodes, so compare your monitoring scale and budget horizon.

How much does New Relic cost for five people?

If all five need full-platform access, Standard lists $10 for the first user and $99 for each of the next four: $406 per month. New Relic also lists unlimited basic users on Free, while Standard Core users cost $49 each.

Which tool is better for infrastructure monitoring?

Nagios XI is centered on active polling for servers, networks, services, databases, and applications. New Relic combines infrastructure monitoring with application, log, security, and user-experience tools. Choose based on whether you mainly need infrastructure checks or a broader observability platform.