review galore

Head-to-head · Password managers

Proton Pass vs 1Password

Proton Pass is the budget pick; 1Password makes team coverage easier to price. Neither publishes a setup-time estimate.

Proton Pass

7.5/10
VS

1Password

6.8/10

We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never changes a score or a ranking. How we make money

Short answer

Most buyers should pick Proton Pass.

For a small team watching every subscription, start with Proton Pass if free password storage and sharing with up to two others are enough. Its paid plans aren’t priced per team seat, so check how you’ll manage access as the group grows. Pick 1Password if you want a plan explicitly covering up to 10 members: Teams Starter Pack costs $24.95 per month with annual billing. There’s no permanent free plan, but it has a 14-day trial.

01Side by side

Proton Pass1Password
Free planFree: unlimited logins, notes, devices; share with two others.No permanent free plan; 14-day trial.
Cheapest paid planMail Plus: $3.99/month billed annually.Business: $8.99/user/month billed annually.
Price per seatNo team-seat price published; individual plans listed.Business: $8.99 per user/month, annual billing.
Cost for fiveNo five-seat team price published.$24.95/month annually for up to 10 members.
Setup effortSetup-time estimate not published.Setup-time estimate not published.
Learning curveReview ease score: 8/10.Review ease score: 6/10.
IntegrationsPlan-specific integration list not published.Plan-specific integration list not published.
SupportReview support score: 5/10; details not published.Review support score: 5/10; details not published.

Choose Proton Pass if

  • Choose Proton Pass if free password management covers your needs.
  • Choose Proton Pass if sharing with up to two others is enough.
  • Choose Proton Pass if you want a lower-cost paid option.

Choose 1Password if

  • Choose 1Password if you need a plan covering up to 10 members.
  • Choose 1Password if you want published per-user Business pricing.
  • Choose 1Password if its 14-day trial helps your team evaluate fit.

02What each costs a small team

Proton Pass has a permanent Free plan: two vaults, unlimited logins and notes, unlimited devices, and sharing with up to two others. The lowest listed paid option with those Pass limits is Mail Plus at $3.99 per month billed annually ($47.88 upfront for a year), or $4.99 month to month. Unlimited is $9.99 per month billed annually ($119.88 yearly), with 50 vaults and sharing with up to 10 others; neither is priced per team seat.

1Password has no permanent free plan. Teams Starter Pack costs $24.95 per month with annual billing and covers up to 10 members, so five people fit at that listed price. Added seats are available, but the vendor doesn’t publish their cost. Business costs $8.99 per user per month annually, or $44.95 monthly equivalent for five. It includes a 14-day trial. Proton is cheaper for one person; 1Password’s team plan makes member coverage clearer.

03Setup and day-to-day use

Neither vendor publishes a setup-time estimate, so we wouldn’t promise a same-day rollout. Proton Pass’s described core job is to generate and store passwords, sync across devices, share, and send breach alerts. Its review scores rate ease of use 8/10. For a small group, decide whether sharing with up to two others is enough; Proton’s team administration and seat model aren’t clearly priced.

1Password presents a wider access platform, including password management, credential brokering, privileged access, and SaaS management. Its review scores rate ease of use 6/10. Teams Starter Pack covers up to 10 members; Business is billed per user. Before buying, ask which controls and integrations come with your selected plan and who will administer access. The 14-day trial is an evaluation window, not a published onboarding estimate.

04What you get on the cheaper plans

Proton Pass Free covers the basics for an individual or a very small sharing circle: two vaults, unlimited logins and notes, unlimited devices, and sharing with up to two others. Proton says its apps are open source and independently audited. The listed Mail Plus plan shows the same Pass limits. Unlimited adds 50 vaults, a built-in 2FA authenticator, and sharing with up to 10 others.

1Password has no permanent free plan. Its offerings include password management and broader access features, such as credential brokering, privileged access, and SaaS management. The pricing listings give Teams Starter Pack and Business trial and billing details, but don’t specify which of those features come with each plan. Ask the vendor to confirm the features and integrations included in your quote. For a team that mainly needs shared passwords, Proton’s free tier is easier to assess; for a wider access program, 1Password describes a broader set of capabilities.

Questions people ask

Is Proton Pass as safe as 1Password?

Proton says its apps are open source and independently audited. 1Password describes its platform as securing and auditing access for people, AI agents, and machines. Those claims don’t establish that one is safer than the other. Compare each vendor’s security documentation and ask about audit scope, account recovery, and incident disclosures.

Has Proton Pass ever been hacked?

Proton says its apps are open source and independently audited, but that doesn’t answer whether Proton Pass has ever suffered a security incident. We can’t confirm an incident history from those claims alone. Ask Proton for dated incident disclosures and details on how it handles vulnerabilities.

What is the best replacement for 1Password?

For a small team prioritizing free password storage, Proton Pass is a practical alternative: its Free plan includes unlimited logins, notes, and devices. If your team needs a plan explicitly covering up to 10 members, 1Password’s Teams Starter Pack is clearer on seat coverage. Fit depends on your access needs and budget.

What has happened to 1Password?

1Password describes itself as a Unified Access platform for discovering, securing, and auditing access for people, AI agents, and machines. Its offerings extend beyond password management to credential brokering, privileged access, and SaaS management. A small team needing passwords alone may not need that wider set of capabilities.