We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never changes a score or a ranking. How we make money
It's a split decision.
For a small team that needs basic on-call coverage at no cost, choose PagerDuty: its free plan covers five users, one schedule, and one escalation policy. Choose Rootly if you want Slack or Teams paging and incident-response tools for $20 per user monthly, and can budget for every seat. PagerDuty's paid Professional plan costs $21 per user monthly with annual billing, or $25 monthly. The right pick depends on whether free coverage or Rootly's included workflows matter more.
01Side by side
| Rootly | PagerDuty | |
|---|---|---|
| Free plan | No free plan; two-week trial | Five users, one schedule, 100 monthly notifications |
| Cheapest paid plan | $20/user/month for On-Call or Incident Response | $21/user/month annually for Professional |
| One-person price | $20/month | $21 annual; $25 monthly |
| Five-person entry cost | $100/month | Free tier, or $105 monthly equivalent for Professional |
| Setup effort | Time unpublished; configure schedules and workflows | Time unpublished; configure schedules and escalation policies |
| Learning curve | Not published; combines incident and on-call tools | Not published; includes incident, AI, and automation tools |
| Small-team integrations | Paging in Slack and Teams | Specific chat platforms not published |
| Support | Dedicated priority 24/7 support on Enterprise | Support terms for these plans not published |
Rootly Choose Rootly if
- Choose Rootly if Slack or Teams paging is important.
- Choose Rootly if $20 per seat fits your budget.
- Choose Rootly if you want workflows and retrospectives included.
PagerDuty Choose PagerDuty if
- Choose PagerDuty if you need free coverage for five users.
- Choose PagerDuty if one schedule and one escalation policy are enough.
- Choose PagerDuty if you prefer per-user Professional pricing.
02What each costs a small team
PagerDuty is the only option with a free plan: it covers five users, one on-call schedule, one escalation policy, and 100 SMS or phone notifications monthly. Rootly has no free plan, but its pricing page lists a two-week trial.
Rootly's On-Call and Incident Response plans each cost $20 per user monthly. One seat is $20; three cost $60; five cost $100. Annual rates aren't published. PagerDuty Professional is $25 per user monthly, or $21 with annual billing: $25 or $75 for one or three users monthly, and $125 or $105 for five. PagerDuty also lists a Starter platform plan at $2,800 per year, equivalent to $233.33 monthly, with five seats plus five bonus seats. For a small team needing paid coverage, compare Professional's per-seat price with Rootly's $20 plans.
03Setup and day-to-day use
Neither vendor publishes a time-to-setup estimate, so a team should ask what configuration and onboarding its use case requires. Rootly's On-Call plan includes schedules, escalation policies, a live call-routing number, and basic alert grouping. Its Incident Response plan includes workflows and retrospectives, so teams should decide which plan fits their needs before budgeting.
PagerDuty's free plan includes one schedule and one escalation policy, giving a small team a defined starting point. Professional adds an enhanced chat experience and post-incident reviews. Teams will need to decide who is on call and how escalations work; the specific setup steps and time aren't published in these plan details. Neither product has a published learning-curve rating. Rootly brings incident response and on-call tools together, while PagerDuty also offers AI and operations automation features that teams may need to evaluate.
04What you get on the cheaper plans
Rootly's two $20 plans cover different needs. On-Call includes paging in Slack and Teams, 20 schedules and escalation policies, one live call-routing number, and basic alert grouping. Incident Response includes the Rootly agent across platforms, AI Scribe and retrospectives, insights, workflows, a catalog, and status pages. Don't assume one plan includes the other's features: check which product your team needs. AI SRE costs extra, requires Incident Response, and has no published price.
PagerDuty's free plan is limited but usable for a small on-call setup: five users, one schedule, one escalation policy, and 100 monthly SMS or phone notifications. Professional adds post-incident reviews and an enhanced chat experience, with up to five users per escalation level. PagerDuty lists AIOps, automation, status pages, and live call routing as separately purchased add-ons for Professional. If your team needs those, ask for the full cost before choosing.
Questions people ask
Does Rootly have a free plan?
No. Rootly's pricing lists a two-week free trial, but no free plan. Its On-Call and Incident Response plans each start at $20 per user monthly. Eligible startups may receive up to 50% off, and companies with fewer than 25 employees can pay what they can, starting at $1.
How many people can use PagerDuty for free?
PagerDuty's free plan covers five users, one on-call schedule, and one escalation policy. It also includes 100 SMS or phone notifications per month. That's a defined starter setup, but teams needing more schedules or paid-plan features should compare Professional and the platform plans.
What does PagerDuty Professional cost for five people?
The pricing page lists Professional at $25 per user monthly, or $21 per user monthly with annual billing. For five seats, that's $125 monthly or a $105 monthly equivalent with annual billing. PagerDuty also lists platform plans with annual fees, so check which pricing model fits.
Which is better for a small team, Rootly or PagerDuty?
PagerDuty is a practical starting point if its free plan's five users, one schedule, and one escalation policy are enough. Rootly may fit better if your team wants Slack or Teams paging and its $20-per-seat plans. Compare the included features you need, since Rootly's on-call and incident-response features are sold in separate plans.