We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never changes a score or a ranking. How we make money
It's a split decision.
Choose Pirate Ship if your team mainly needs to compare USPS and UPS rates and print labels without a monthly subscription. You still pay for postage and labels. Choose ShipStation if several people need shared order and fulfillment workflows: Starter is $14.99 monthly for up to three users, while a five-person team needs Standard at $29.99 monthly. ShipStation also lists a free plan for 50 shipments monthly, but its free-plan seat limit isn’t published.
01Side by side
| ShipStation | Pirate Ship | |
|---|---|---|
| Free plan | 50 shipments monthly; seat limit not published | No monthly fee; pay for postage |
| Cheapest paid plan | Starter: $14.99 monthly | No paid subscription plan |
| Price per seat | Starter includes 3 users for $14.99 monthly | Seat limit and per-seat price not published |
| Cost for a team of 5 | Standard: $29.99 monthly for up to 10 users | $0 subscription; postage and labels cost extra |
| Setup effort | More workflows and order management to configure | Web-based rate comparison and label printing |
| Learning curve | More tools for orders, automation, and returns | Focused on rates, labels, and tracking |
| Small-team integrations | Unlimited store connections on paid plans | USPS and UPS rate comparisons |
| Support | Review score: 3/10 for support | Review score: 6/10 for support |
ShipStation Choose ShipStation if
- Choose ShipStation if several teammates need shared order workflows.
- Choose ShipStation if you need unlimited store connections.
- Choose ShipStation if you want automation and returns tools.
Pirate Ship Choose Pirate Ship if
- Choose Pirate Ship if you want no monthly subscription fee.
- Choose Pirate Ship if USPS and UPS rates cover your needs.
- Choose Pirate Ship if you mainly need labels and tracking.
02What each costs a small team
Pirate Ship has no monthly fee or volume minimum, but you pay for actual postage and shipping labels. That keeps the subscription bill at $0 for one person or a team of three to five; total shipping costs depend on the labels you buy. Pirate Ship doesn’t publish a seat limit or per-seat price.
ShipStation’s free plan includes 50 shipments monthly, but its seat limit isn’t published. For a paid account, the pricing page lists Starter at $14.99 monthly for up to three users. That price covers one person or three; the plan starts at 50 shipments and allows up to 5,000. A team of five needs Standard at $29.99 monthly, which includes 10 users. Exact annual prices aren’t published.
03Setup and day-to-day use
Neither vendor publishes a setup-time estimate, so we wouldn’t budget a specific number of hours based on the plan pages. Pirate Ship is web-based: the core routine is comparing USPS and UPS rates, choosing a service, and printing labels. Its listed features also include saved package presets, bulk label printing, and package tracking.
ShipStation covers more of the shipping workflow. A small team may need to organize incoming orders, connect stores, set filters or tags, and decide whether to use fulfillment rules, returns, or freight shipping. The product lists unlimited store connections on Starter and Standard. That wider scope can mean more decisions to make before a team settles into a routine. Setup details and the learning curve aren’t published, so ask each vendor about onboarding for your order sources and workflow.
04What you get on the cheaper plans
Pirate Ship’s free account gives a small team rate comparisons for USPS and UPS, discounted rates, label printing, tracking, and saved presets. It also lists private label sharing and bulk label printing. There’s no monthly subscription, but postage and labels still cost money. The vendor doesn’t publish a seat limit, so ask how multiple teammates can access the account.
ShipStation’s free plan is limited to 50 shipments monthly, and its seat limit isn’t published. Starter is the lowest paid plan listed: it starts at 50 shipments, allows up to 5,000 monthly, includes three users, and supports unlimited store connections. ShipStation lists order management, rate comparison, label printing, automation, returns, and shipping APIs among its capabilities. The vendor doesn’t publish which of those features are restricted by plan, so confirm access before choosing. For five users, Standard is the listed option at $29.99 monthly.
Questions people ask
Is Pirate Ship cheaper than USPS?
Pirate Ship offers discounted USPS rates, but whether a label costs less depends on the shipment and the rate you compare it with. Check the specific service, package, and destination before deciding. The vendor doesn’t publish a single price that applies to every shipment.
How much does ShipStation cost per month?
ShipStation lists a free plan with 50 shipments monthly. Its Starter plan is $14.99 monthly for up to three users, and Standard is $29.99 monthly for up to 10 users. Exact annual prices aren’t published, though the pricing page lists a 20% annual-billing savings.
Can a five-person team use ShipStation?
Yes. ShipStation’s Standard plan is listed at $29.99 monthly and includes up to 10 users, so it covers five seats. Starter is limited to three users. The free plan’s seat limit isn’t published, so ask ShipStation before relying on it for a group.
Does Pirate Ship have monthly fees?
No monthly subscription fee is listed for Pirate Ship, and it has no volume commitments or minimums. You still pay for actual postage and shipping labels. That means the software subscription can be free, but shipping itself isn’t.