We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never changes a score or a ranking. How we make money
It's a split decision.
Choose Sumo if your small team wants email capture and a real $0 starting point: its free plan allows 10,000 emails a month and unlimited subscribers, with limits on Sumo-driven revenue and stats. Choose OptinMonster if you need a wider range of targeted website campaigns, templates, and testing; its free offer is only a limited trial, and ongoing plans are site- and impression-based. Neither publishes seat rules, so confirm five-person access before buying.
01Side by side
| Sumo | OptinMonster | |
|---|---|---|
| Free plan | Free: 10,000 emails/month; unlimited subscribers | 500-credit trial; auto-upgrades after impressions are exceeded |
| Cheapest paid plan | Pro: $49 monthly or $39/month annually | Basic: $9/month first year; renews at $210/year |
| Price per seat | Seat limits and per-seat pricing aren't published | Seat limits and per-seat pricing aren't published |
| Cost for a team of five | $39/month annually; five-person access unconfirmed | $9/month introductory; five-person access unconfirmed |
| Setup effort | Setup steps and time aren't published | Setup time isn't published; campaign configuration required |
| Learning curve | Not published | Not published |
| Integrations a small team needs | Integration details aren't published | Custom integrations listed for Enterprise |
| Support | Support details aren't published | Dedicated support listed for Enterprise |
Sumo Choose Sumo if
- Choose Sumo if you need a genuine free email-capture plan.
- Choose Sumo if 10,000 monthly emails covers your current needs.
- Choose Sumo if unlimited subscribers matter more than campaign testing.
OptinMonster Choose OptinMonster if
- Choose OptinMonster if you need popups, bars, overlays, or slide-ins.
- Choose OptinMonster if you want 700+ campaign templates.
- Choose OptinMonster if A/B testing is worth the Plus price.
02What each costs a small team
Sumo has a genuine free plan: 10,000 emails per month, unlimited subscribers, up to $500 in Sumo-driven revenue, and 30 days of email stats. One person can start at $0. Pro is $49 month-to-month or $39/month on annual billing ($468/year), with 50,000 emails/month and unlimited stats and Sumo-driven revenue. Pricing isn't listed per seat, and Sumo doesn't publish team-seat limits, so get the five-person access rules in writing.
OptinMonster's free offer is a trial, not an ongoing free tier: 500 impression credits, then it auto-upgrades to Plus if impressions are exceeded. Basic is the cheapest paid plan: $9/month introductory pricing for the first year, renewing at $210/year ($17.50/month equivalent). It covers one site and 2,500 monthly impressions. For three to five people on one site, user pricing isn't published; ask about seats and billing before committing.
03Setup and day-to-day use
Neither vendor publishes a setup-time estimate, so we wouldn't budget this as a same-day job without checking your site and email stack. Sumo is the simpler fit if the task is email capture and managing subscribers: its free plan includes email volume and basic stats, but setup steps and team access rules aren't published. Ask whether your current site and email tools connect, and who can access the account.
OptinMonster has more campaign decisions to configure. A small team will pick a template and form type, set behavior and page targeting, and monitor impression usage; A/B testing starts on Plus, not Basic. Its templates may reduce design work, but the time needed to configure a useful campaign isn't published. Decide who will own campaign edits, especially if several people need access.
04What you get on the cheaper plans
Sumo's free tier gives a small team 10,000 emails per month and unlimited subscribers, but Sumo-driven revenue is capped at $500 and email stats cover 30 days. Pro raises the email allowance to 50,000 per month and removes those revenue and stats limits. The listed plan details don't specify team permissions or campaign-building features, so check those before treating it as a shared team tool.
OptinMonster Basic includes one site, 2,500 impressions per month, unlimited campaigns and subscribers, and 700+ templates. That's a broader set of campaign-building tools, but A/B testing and full analytics reporting start on Plus, which lists 10,000 impressions and an introductory price of $27/month. Exit Intent technology is listed on Pro, not Basic. Its trial is limited to 500 impression credits and can auto-upgrade to Plus when impressions are exceeded.
Questions people ask
Does Sumo have a free plan?
Yes. Sumo lists a $0 plan with 10,000 emails per month, unlimited subscribers, up to $500 in Sumo-driven revenue, and 30 days of email stats. That makes it an ongoing free option, unlike OptinMonster's trial, which has 500 impression credits and can auto-upgrade to Plus.
Is OptinMonster Basic really $9 per month?
The pricing page lists Basic at an introductory $9/month for the first year, with annual billing as the default. It renews at $210/year, or $17.50 per month when divided across the year. Monthly subscription prices aren't published in the listed pricing.
Can a team of five use either product?
Both vendors' listed pricing leaves seat limits and per-seat charges unclear. OptinMonster plans are described by sites and impressions, while Sumo's plans list email volumes. Before buying for five people, ask each vendor how many users can access the account and whether extra seats cost more.
Which is better for website popups and targeted campaigns?
OptinMonster is the clearer fit for building popups, floating bars, fullscreen overlays, and slide-ins with behavior targeting. Its Basic plan includes templates and unlimited campaigns, while A/B testing starts on Plus. Sumo's listed strengths center on email volume, subscribers, and email stats.