We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never changes a score or a ranking. How we make money
A small team may not need to replace Adobe Firefly if it already works in your Adobe apps and your image and video needs fit the credit allowance. But video uses credits differently from images: one Reddit commenter cited a rate of 20 credits per second for video generation at the time, and another said the plan details were easy to miss. These eight alternatives start at $4.79 or offer a free plan. Check seat costs and usage limits before choosing for the whole team.
01Why people leave Adobe Firefly
Video credits can add up
A commenter on r/Adobe cited video generation at 20 credits per second at the time, compared with one credit per image. Check current rates before budgeting.
Credit rules can be unclear
In one r/Adobe thread, a buyer said they expected image credits and found the video credit cost only after subscribing.
Some creators prefer other tools
Opinions vary: one commenter on r/Adobe preferred other platforms, while r/videography users discussed AI as a tool for creative workflows.
02The alternatives, ranked by fit
- Lowest entry price
SeaArtSeaArtSeaArt starts at $4.79 and has a free plan, so it is a lower-cost place for a small team to explore image and video tools. Its listed fit includes solo creators and small teams. Before making it a shared workflow, check the limits and recent user reports; those are worth reviewing before you pay.
Trade-off: Check the free-plan limits and recent user reports before paying.
6.1/10from
$4.79/mofree plan - Shared creative workspace
ScenarioScenarioScenario starts at $10.05 and offers a free plan, with a listed focus on consistent creative assets, several media types, and teams sharing one workspace. That makes it a candidate for a small team that wants more than image generation. Its free-plan limits are unclear, so confirm them before inviting the team or budgeting for paid seats.
Trade-off: Free-plan limits are unclear; confirm them before committing.
7.3/10from
$10.05/mofree plan - Image exploration
MidjourneyMidjourneyMidjourney starts at $8 and suits teams focused on creative image exploration, storyboards, and visual concepts. It is a narrower fit than Firefly’s broader creative toolkit if images are the main need. Budget for each user: a small team must pay for every person, so confirm the total before rolling it out.
Trade-off: Every user adds to the team budget.
7.2/10from
$8/mo - Text-heavy visuals
IdeogramIdeogramIdeogram starts at $15 and has a free plan. Its listed strengths include text-heavy visuals and iterating on specific compositions, making it worth considering when those are the team’s main jobs. It also has a per-seat cost, so price the actual number of users and check how variable free credits fit your workflow.
Trade-off: Per-seat pricing and variable free credits need checking.
6.8/10from
$15/mofree plan - Product image batches
PhotoroomPhotoroomPhotoroom starts at $7.50 and is aimed at small online shops making product visuals, reusing brand layouts, and creating images in batches. That focus can suit an ecommerce team better than a broad creative toolkit. There is no free plan, and important limits make the price harder to judge, so check your expected usage first.
Trade-off: No free plan; important limits affect price planning.
6.2/10from
$7.50/mo - Product photo scenes
PebblelyPebblelyPebblely starts at $9 per month and focuses on product scenes and image batches for small ecommerce marketing teams. If the team mainly needs fresh product visuals, that narrower job may be a better fit than paying for a broad set of creative tools. There is no free plan, and the vendor does not publish seat pricing; ask for a small-team quote.
Trade-off: No free plan or published seat pricing.
6.8/10from
$9/mo - Varied creative assets
FreepikFreepikFreepik starts at $12 and has a wide creative toolkit, stock content, and multiple AI models. It may suit a small design team that needs more than image generation in one place. Budget for each person and check how the usage limits fit your workflow; the available details do not establish a team total.
Trade-off: Budget for each person and verify usage limits.
6.3/10from
€12/mo - Multiple AI models
OpenArtOpenArtOpenArt starts at $13 and suits creators switching between AI models, building recurring AI characters, or making images and video. It offers a wider set of AI tools in one place for teams with varied creative needs. There is no free plan, and video credits can go quickly, so check likely usage and the cost for your team before signing up.
Trade-off: No free plan; video credits can go quickly.
6.8/10from
$13/mo
03Side by side
| Tool | Score | From | Free plan | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 7.1 | $9.99/mo | Yes | Small teams already using Adobe apps | |
| 6.1 | $4.79/mo | Yes | Solo creators exploring AI art | |
| 7.3 | $10.05/mo | Yes | Teams producing consistent creative assets | |
| 7.2 | $8/mo | No | Creative image exploration | |
| 6.8 | $15/mo | Yes | Small teams creating text-heavy visuals | |
| 6.2 | $7.50/mo | No | Small online shops making product visuals | |
| 6.8 | $9/mo | No | Small ecommerce marketing teams | |
| 6.3 | €12/mo | No | Small teams making varied creative assets | |
| 6.8 | $13/mo | No | Creators switching between AI models |
Questions people ask
What are Adobe Photoshop's main competitors?
For AI image and creative work, the alternatives here include Midjourney, Ideogram, Freepik, and Scenario. Product-focused teams can also look at Photoroom or Pebblely. These tools have different uses and pricing models, so compare the work your team needs to do and check per-seat costs before choosing.
What is Adobe AI Firefly?
Adobe Firefly is a broad AI creative toolkit for image and video workflows, including teams making mood boards together. Its listed starting price is $9.99, with a free plan. For video, check the current credit rate and plan terms: a Reddit commenter reported that video generation used credits differently from image generation.
What can I substitute for Adobe?
For creative image exploration, consider Midjourney; for text-heavy visuals, Ideogram; and for product images, Photoroom or Pebblely. SeaArt and Scenario offer free plans, though their limits should be checked. Seat pricing varies or is not published for some options, so confirm the total for your team before switching.
