We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never changes a score or a ranking. How we make money
If your team only screens occasional hires, start by comparing Checkr’s per-report cost with the checks you actually need. The pricing lists a free plan and a starting price of $24.99, but ask what each screening package includes. The alternatives below focus on recruiting workflows, not background checks, so they may help if Checkr feels too complex for hiring—but they won’t replace screening. We’ve prioritized free plans and lower listed starting prices; ask vendors about seat costs and setup before committing.
01Why people leave Checkr
Per-report costs add up
Checkr charges per report, so occasional hiring can still mean unpredictable spend. Compare your expected checks with the cost of each package.
Check scope can be unclear
In one Reddit thread, candidates questioned whether a general check included employment or education verification.
Accuracy concerns
One HR commenter said their team saw reports with convictions assigned to the wrong candidates and missed prior convictions; treat this as anecdotal.
02The alternatives, ranked by fit
- Small teams hiring regularly
GemGemGem is worth a look if your bigger need is managing recruiting, not running background checks. Its listing includes a free plan and a starting price of $130, and it can work alongside an existing ATS. The listed details don’t establish your cost for several seats or setup effort, so ask for both before choosing it.
Trade-off: It supports recruiting workflows, not background screening.
6.5/10from
$130/mofree plan - Developer hiring
HackerRankHackerRankFor teams hiring software developers, HackerRank offers a free plan and a listed starting price of $165. It focuses on technical screening and interviews, which can help assess candidates before later hiring steps. It isn’t a Checkr substitute for background checks; ask the vendor about free-plan limits, seat pricing, and setup for your team.
Trade-off: Its focus is developer assessments, not background checks.
6.5/10from
$165/mofree plan - ATS and candidate CRM
CATSCATSCATS fits teams that want recruiting workflows and candidate relationship management in one tool. Its listed starting price is $95, and its pricing is per user, so get a quote for your actual headcount. The available details don’t specify setup effort. It can support hiring operations, but it does not replace Checkr’s screening function.
Trade-off: Per-user pricing can make several seats costly.
5.8/10from
$95/mo - Small staffing agencies
BullhornBullhornBullhorn is aimed at staffing agencies that want ATS and CRM tools together. Its listed starting price is $99, and its listing highlights free implementation, which may help with getting started. Ask whether that applies to your plan and what several seats cost. It’s a recruiting workflow option, not a background-check provider.
Trade-off: Best suited to staffing workflows, not occasional screening.
6.8/10from
$99/mo - LinkedIn candidate sourcing
LinkedIn RecruiterLinkedIn RecruiterLinkedIn Recruiter may fit a solo recruiter or a small team that needs LinkedIn’s candidate pool and recruiting pipeline tools. Its listed starting price is $140, and the listing warns that costs climb when a team needs multiple seats. Ask for a team quote and setup details; it helps source candidates, but doesn’t run background checks.
Trade-off: Multiple seats can push costs up quickly.
6.2/10from
$140/mo - Growing hiring teams
AshbyAshbyAshby combines recruiting tools for teams hiring regularly or replacing separate recruiting products. Its listed starting price is $400 per month, so it is a higher-cost option for a small team than the picks above. Ask about seat costs and setup before budgeting. It can consolidate recruiting work, but it isn’t a Checkr replacement for screening.
Trade-off: The $400 monthly starting price is steep for small teams.
6.2/10from
$400/mo
03Side by side
| Tool | Score | From | Free plan | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 5.6 | $24.99/mo | Yes | Teams screening occasional hires | |
| 6.5 | $130/mo | Yes | Small teams hiring regularly | |
| 6.5 | $165/mo | Yes | Teams hiring software developers | |
| 5.8 | $95/mo | No | Recruiting teams needing ATS and CRM | |
| 6.8 | $99/mo | No | Staffing agencies building a recruiting workflow | |
| 6.2 | $140/mo | No | Solo recruiters sourcing on LinkedIn | |
| 6.2 | $400/mo | No | Teams hiring regularly |
Questions people ask
Which Checkr alternative is best for a small team?
It depends on the task you need covered. Gem lists a free plan and focuses on recruiting tools; CATS offers ATS and CRM workflows. Neither is a like-for-like background screening replacement. If you still need checks, ask vendors what screening options they support and compare that cost with Checkr’s per-report pricing.
Does Checkr have a free plan?
Checkr’s listing includes a free plan and a starting price of $24.99, and says the service charges per report. Ask Checkr what the free plan covers, which checks are included in a paid report, and whether any additional costs apply to the checks your team needs.
Can recruiting software replace Checkr?
Not based on the tools listed here. Gem, CATS, Bullhorn, LinkedIn Recruiter, Ashby, and HackerRank focus on recruiting, sourcing, or candidate assessment. They may help with other parts of hiring, but ask each vendor directly whether it offers background screening before treating it as a Checkr substitute.
