We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never changes a score or a ranking. How we make money
A small team may not need a dedicated collection tool if it only takes occasional payments. Cheddar Up is aimed at group collections and forms, but one Reddit commenter called it clunky and another reported that its free plan didn’t accept eChecks. We’d compare alternatives against your actual needs: payment method, recurring collections, forms and organizer access. The options below range from free plans to $25 or more per month; seat pricing and setup effort are worth confirming before you switch.
01Why people leave Cheddar Up
Fees feel high
One Reddit commenter said Cheddar Up’s fees felt steep for a small troop; another reported a 3.95% + $0.95 card fee.
Free-plan payment limits
A Reddit user said their free plan could not accept eChecks. Confirm current payment options and fees before sharing a collection link.
Clunky for small groups
One commenter on r/girlscouts called the tool clunky and described bookkeeping as a concern for a small-budget troop.
02The alternatives, ranked by fit
- Best for simple payments
PayPalPayPalPayPal is worth a look if your group mainly needs to request or accept payments, rather than pair collections with forms. It has a free plan and a listed starting price of $5. The listing doesn’t give a per-organizer cost, so ask whether adding a few people changes the bill. Also ask about setup and account requirements; fees can vary.
Trade-off: It may not replace Cheddar Up’s group-collection and form workflow.
6.8/10from
$5/mofree plan - Best for selling in person
SquareSquareSquare Free covers core selling tools, and the listing names small in-person sellers and teams selling online and in person as fits. There’s a free plan, but no starting paid price is listed. For a few organizers, ask about account access costs, setup steps and which features require a paid plan; budget separately for processing and hardware.
Trade-off: Paid features, processing and hardware can add to the cost.
7.2/10from
Freefree plan - Best for groups and giving
VancoVancoVanco is aimed at churches starting online giving, nonprofits taking recurring donations and teams needing in-person payments. It lists a $0 starting plan, with pricing from $54; confirm what each plan includes and whether a few organizers affect the price. Ask about setup, processing fees and extras before choosing it for dues or fundraising.
Trade-off: Processing fees and extras shape the real cost.
6.8/10from
$54/mofree plan - Best for retail and events
CloverCloverClover fits small retail shops, restaurants needing POS hardware and service businesses taking payments. Its listing shows a free plan and a starting price of $29.95. Ask what that price covers, whether additional organizers cost extra and how much setup the hardware requires. Include device, processing and other hardware costs in your small-team budget.
Trade-off: Hardware and processing costs can push the total up.
6.8/10from
$29.95/mofree plan - Best for eCheck payments
Authorize.NetAuthorize.NetAuthorize.Net may suit a U.S. team that needs eCheck payments or already has a merchant account. The listed price starts at $25 per month, plus transaction fees, so it isn’t a free-plan pick. Ask whether a few organizers need separate access, what setup requires and which transaction charges apply to your collection type.
Trade-off: The monthly fee makes it a paid-first option.
6.2/10from
$25/mo - Best for card installments
SplititSplititSplitit is a narrower alternative for merchants that want to offer card installments, not a general-purpose dues or fundraiser tool. Pricing is custom-quote, so ask for the full cost before planning around it. Confirm setup requirements and whether organizer access changes the quote. It makes most sense when installment payments are central to what your team sells.
Trade-off: Custom pricing makes the cost hard to compare upfront.
5.3/10from
Custom
03Side by side
| Tool | Score | From | Free plan | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 6.5 | $15/mo | Yes | Volunteer groups collecting dues | |
| 6.8 | $5/mo | Yes | Small shops accepting online payments | |
| 7.2 | Free | Yes | Small in-person sellers | |
| 6.8 | $54/mo | Yes | Churches starting online giving | |
| 6.8 | $29.95/mo | Yes | Small retail shops | |
| 6.2 | $25/mo | No | Businesses already using a merchant account | |
| 5.3 | Custom | No | Merchants adding card installments |
Questions people ask
What is Cheddar Up used for?
Cheddar Up is positioned for group collections and forms, including volunteer groups collecting dues and clubs running fundraisers or events. That combination can help when you need to collect payment alongside information. If your team only needs occasional transfers, compare whether a simpler payment option covers the essentials.
Is there a better platform than GoFundMe?
It depends on the collection. For a team collecting dues or event payments, compare options such as PayPal, Square or Vanco against your payment methods, fees and organizer needs. The alternatives here aren’t all fundraising platforms, so check that the tool supports your specific campaign before moving money or sharing a link.
Is Cheddar Up secure?
We can’t confirm Cheddar Up’s security from the available details. Before collecting payments, ask the vendor about payment processing, data protection, account access controls and how it handles suspected fraud. Also check whether your organization or council has rules about which payment services volunteers may use.
