review galore

Simpler and cheaper options · 6 options

Cisco Umbrella alternatives

For 1–6 people, start with DNS filtering that fits your budget; check the fine print on business pricing and setup.

We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never changes a score or a ranking. How we make money

A team of 1–10 may not need a full security platform to get DNS filtering. NextDNS is the closest small-budget fit here, though its business pricing starts at a 50-employee package. pfSense Plus and OPNsense are options for teams willing to manage network security themselves. One Reddit user reported paying $1,500 a year for Umbrella at a 45-person business, but that isn’t a like-for-like quote for a smaller team. Check the plan terms before comparing costs.

01Why people leave Cisco Umbrella

Renewal cost

One small-business admin reported paying about $1,500 a year for Umbrella at a 45-person company and began comparing options before renewal.

Setup uncertainty

Umbrella suits organizations with an IT administrator; a small team may find the setup effort hard to assess before buying.

Reported disruption

One software engineer said Umbrella redirects disrupted browser and development tools; a commenter cautioned that this wasn't default behavior.

02The alternatives, ranked by fit

  1. Budget DNS filtering

    NextDNS

    NextDNS is the closest fit if your main goal is DNS-level threat blocking without budgeting for a broader security platform. Its listing includes a free plan and starts at $2.325. Business pricing starts with a 50-employee package, so ask whether a 1–10-person team can buy a smaller business tier. One Reddit user signed up for a trial and was evaluating it within a few days.

    Trade-off: Business pricing starts at 50 employees; support and development pace drew criticism from Reddit users.

    7.6/10
    from
    CA$2.33/mo
    free plan
  2. Self-managed network

    pfSense Plus

    Consider pfSense Plus if your team manages its own network and wants firewall and VPN software rather than a DNS-only service. The listing shows a free plan and a starting price of $10.75. It can suit a budget-conscious team prepared to handle network administration, but the source notes that setup and upgrade choices take care.

    Trade-off: You take on network management and need to weigh setup and upgrade choices.

    6.8/10
    from
    $10.75/mo
    free plan
  3. Business firewall

    OPNsense Business Edition

    OPNsense Business Edition is for teams managing a business firewall, not buyers shopping for per-user DNS filtering. Its listed starting price is $11.08, and commercial features are priced per firewall installation rather than per teammate. That may make the bill easier to estimate for a single installation, but it is a different job from Umbrella's DNS-layer security.

    Trade-off: The price is per firewall installation, and it is not a direct DNS-filtering substitute.

    7.2/10
    from
    €11.08/mo
  4. School web filtering

    Linewize

    Linewize is worth considering if you are a school district focused on student web filtering, especially if you want to pair it with Classwize or cover school and home use. The vendor does not publish a price in the listing, so request a full quote before comparing it with Umbrella. It is a specific fit for education, not a general small-business pick.

    Trade-off: Pricing is quote-based, and its strongest fit is school districts.

    6.5/10
    from
    Custom
  5. Complex DNS operations

    BlueCat Edge

    BlueCat Edge is aimed at teams coordinating complex DNS, DHCP and IP address management across cloud and branch networks. It is a possible fit if your needs extend well beyond basic DNS filtering or you automate network operations. The vendor does not publish pricing in the listing, so a small team should ask for a quote before investing time in evaluation.

    Trade-off: It targets DDI complexity, and pricing requires a vendor quote.

    5.8/10
    from
    Custom
  6. Hybrid network security

    Check Point Quantum Security Gateways

    Check Point Quantum Security Gateways may suit a team securing a hybrid environment that needs dedicated gateway hardware. This is a broader infrastructure choice than a simple DNS-filtering replacement. The listing gives no public price or free plan, so ask for a quote covering the hardware and deployment you need before deciding whether it fits a small-team budget.

    Trade-off: No public price or free plan; dedicated gateway hardware may be more than a small team needs.

    5.8/10
    from
    Custom

03Side by side

ToolScoreFromFree planBest for
Cisco Umbrella (current)6.0CustomNoTeams needing DNS-layer security
NextDNS7.6CA$2.33/moYesFamilies filtering multiple devices
pfSense Plus6.8$10.75/moYesTeams managing their own network
OPNsense Business Edition7.2€11.08/moNoTeams managing a business firewall
Linewize6.5CustomNoSchools needing student web filtering
BlueCat Edge5.8CustomNoTeams coordinating complex DDI
Check Point Quantum Security Gateways5.8CustomNoTeams securing hybrid environments

Questions people ask

What is the cheapest Cisco Umbrella alternative for a small team?

NextDNS lists a free plan and a starting price of $2.325, but its business pricing starts with a 50-employee package. Ask whether a 1–10-person team can buy a smaller business tier and what it includes. pfSense Plus also lists a free plan, with a starting price of $10.75.

Are these alternatives direct replacements for Umbrella?

Not all of them. NextDNS is the closest match for DNS-level threat blocking. pfSense Plus and OPNsense are firewall and network-management choices, while Linewize is aimed at schools. BlueCat Edge focuses on complex DDI, and Check Point Quantum is for hybrid security with gateway hardware.

What should a small team ask before switching?

Confirm whether the price applies to your team size, what security features are included, and whether the plan is per user, per firewall or quote-based. Ask about setup and ongoing administration too: pfSense Plus requires care with setup and upgrades, while several other options have unpublished pricing.