We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never changes a score or a ranking. How we make money
A team of 1–10 may not need a full security platform to get DNS filtering. NextDNS is the closest small-budget fit here, though its business pricing starts at a 50-employee package. pfSense Plus and OPNsense are options for teams willing to manage network security themselves. One Reddit user reported paying $1,500 a year for Umbrella at a 45-person business, but that isn’t a like-for-like quote for a smaller team. Check the plan terms before comparing costs.
01Why people leave Cisco Umbrella
Renewal cost
One small-business admin reported paying about $1,500 a year for Umbrella at a 45-person company and began comparing options before renewal.
Setup uncertainty
Umbrella suits organizations with an IT administrator; a small team may find the setup effort hard to assess before buying.
Reported disruption
One software engineer said Umbrella redirects disrupted browser and development tools; a commenter cautioned that this wasn't default behavior.
02The alternatives, ranked by fit
- Budget DNS filtering
NextDNSNextDNSNextDNS is the closest fit if your main goal is DNS-level threat blocking without budgeting for a broader security platform. Its listing includes a free plan and starts at $2.325. Business pricing starts with a 50-employee package, so ask whether a 1–10-person team can buy a smaller business tier. One Reddit user signed up for a trial and was evaluating it within a few days.
Trade-off: Business pricing starts at 50 employees; support and development pace drew criticism from Reddit users.
7.6/10from
CA$2.33/mofree plan - Self-managed network
pfSense PluspfSense PlusConsider pfSense Plus if your team manages its own network and wants firewall and VPN software rather than a DNS-only service. The listing shows a free plan and a starting price of $10.75. It can suit a budget-conscious team prepared to handle network administration, but the source notes that setup and upgrade choices take care.
Trade-off: You take on network management and need to weigh setup and upgrade choices.
6.8/10from
$10.75/mofree plan - Business firewall
OPNsense Business EditionOPNsense Business EditionOPNsense Business Edition is for teams managing a business firewall, not buyers shopping for per-user DNS filtering. Its listed starting price is $11.08, and commercial features are priced per firewall installation rather than per teammate. That may make the bill easier to estimate for a single installation, but it is a different job from Umbrella's DNS-layer security.
Trade-off: The price is per firewall installation, and it is not a direct DNS-filtering substitute.
7.2/10from
€11.08/mo - School web filtering
LinewizeLinewizeLinewize is worth considering if you are a school district focused on student web filtering, especially if you want to pair it with Classwize or cover school and home use. The vendor does not publish a price in the listing, so request a full quote before comparing it with Umbrella. It is a specific fit for education, not a general small-business pick.
Trade-off: Pricing is quote-based, and its strongest fit is school districts.
6.5/10from
Custom - Complex DNS operations
BlueCat EdgeBlueCat EdgeBlueCat Edge is aimed at teams coordinating complex DNS, DHCP and IP address management across cloud and branch networks. It is a possible fit if your needs extend well beyond basic DNS filtering or you automate network operations. The vendor does not publish pricing in the listing, so a small team should ask for a quote before investing time in evaluation.
Trade-off: It targets DDI complexity, and pricing requires a vendor quote.
5.8/10from
Custom - Hybrid network security
Check Point Quantum Security GatewaysCheck Point Quantum Security GatewaysCheck Point Quantum Security Gateways may suit a team securing a hybrid environment that needs dedicated gateway hardware. This is a broader infrastructure choice than a simple DNS-filtering replacement. The listing gives no public price or free plan, so ask for a quote covering the hardware and deployment you need before deciding whether it fits a small-team budget.
Trade-off: No public price or free plan; dedicated gateway hardware may be more than a small team needs.
5.8/10from
Custom
03Side by side
| Tool | Score | From | Free plan | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 6.0 | Custom | No | Teams needing DNS-layer security | |
| 7.6 | CA$2.33/mo | Yes | Families filtering multiple devices | |
| 6.8 | $10.75/mo | Yes | Teams managing their own network | |
| 7.2 | €11.08/mo | No | Teams managing a business firewall | |
| 6.5 | Custom | No | Schools needing student web filtering | |
| 5.8 | Custom | No | Teams coordinating complex DDI | |
| 5.8 | Custom | No | Teams securing hybrid environments |
Questions people ask
What is the cheapest Cisco Umbrella alternative for a small team?
NextDNS lists a free plan and a starting price of $2.325, but its business pricing starts with a 50-employee package. Ask whether a 1–10-person team can buy a smaller business tier and what it includes. pfSense Plus also lists a free plan, with a starting price of $10.75.
Are these alternatives direct replacements for Umbrella?
Not all of them. NextDNS is the closest match for DNS-level threat blocking. pfSense Plus and OPNsense are firewall and network-management choices, while Linewize is aimed at schools. BlueCat Edge focuses on complex DDI, and Check Point Quantum is for hybrid security with gateway hardware.
What should a small team ask before switching?
Confirm whether the price applies to your team size, what security features are included, and whether the plan is per user, per firewall or quote-based. Ask about setup and ongoing administration too: pfSense Plus requires care with setup and upgrades, while several other options have unpublished pricing.
