review galore

Simpler and cheaper options · 6 options

Criteria alternatives

Criteria’s custom pricing can be hard to justify for a small team. These alternatives offer different ways to handle assessments and recruiting.

We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never changes a score or a ranking. How we make money

A team of 1–10 may not need a dedicated assessment platform if it hires rarely or can evaluate candidates another way. If you do need structured screening, Criteria covers assessments, interviews, and development, but its custom pricing makes the cost hard to judge upfront. The alternatives below include free-plan options and listed starting prices, though free-plan limits and setup effort aren’t clear across the board. Ask vendors about those details before budgeting for a few seats.

01Why people leave Criteria

Candidates may resent the assessment

One Reddit thread describes a candidate rejecting a Criteria assessment, especially when the job posting did not list salary.

Concerns about fairness and access

Some Reddit commenters say timed cognitive tests can disadvantage applicants, including people whose first language is not English.

Questions about job relevance

Commenters question whether fast math and pattern puzzles are a useful measure of performance in the role being hired for.

02The alternatives, ranked by fit

  1. Developer assessments

    HackerRank

    For teams hiring software developers, HackerRank is the closest fit here to Criteria’s structured assessment focus. It lists a free plan and a starting price of $165, though annual pricing and free-plan limits need scrutiny. Ask what setup and assessment configuration involve before committing; those details can affect the work a small hiring team has to take on.

    Trade-off: It is aimed at technical hiring, not broad assessments or employee development.

    6.5/10
    from
    $165/mo
    free plan
  2. Small teams hiring regularly

    Gem

    Gem may suit a small team that wants recruiting tools alongside candidate assessment rather than an assessment-only purchase. It lists a free plan and pricing from $130. Check what the free plan covers, how the price changes with seats, and what setup requires; the listed starting price alone won’t tell you the cost for your team.

    Trade-off: It focuses on recruiting workflows, not Criteria’s full assessment and development scope.

    6.5/10
    from
    $130/mo
    free plan
  3. Occasional screening

    Checkr

    If your hiring process needs background checks more than aptitude tests, Checkr is a different, potentially more relevant spend. It lists a free plan and starts at $24.99, with teams paying per report. That can suit occasional hiring, but ask about report costs and setup before estimating your budget; a per-report price is not a full assessment-platform comparison.

    Trade-off: It offers background screening, not structured candidate assessments.

    5.6/10
    from
    $24.99/mo
    free plan
  4. ATS and recruiting CRM

    CATS

    CATS is worth considering if the bigger problem is managing candidates and recruiting workflows, rather than assessing them. It starts at $95 and covers ATS and CRM needs, but its per-user pricing means a few seats can change the bill. Ask for the total for your team and what onboarding involves before comparing it with Criteria’s custom quote.

    Trade-off: Per-user pricing can add up, and it is not an assessment-first alternative.

    5.8/10
    from
    $95/mo
  5. Staffing agencies

    Bullhorn

    Bullhorn fits small staffing agencies that need recruiting workflow tools, not employers shopping for a general assessment platform. It starts at $99 and includes free implementation, a concrete setup advantage for a lean team. Ask how the listed price applies to your seats and needs; Bullhorn is positioned for agencies rather than every small employer.

    Trade-off: It is agency-focused, not a direct substitute for Criteria assessments.

    6.8/10
    from
    $99/mo
  6. Growing hiring teams

    Ashby

    Ashby can make sense for a small company planning to hire regularly and replace separate recruiting tools. It combines recruiting tools and starts at $400 per month, so the cost is a substantial step up from lower-priced options. Ask what setup entails and whether your team needs the bundled scope before choosing it over Criteria.

    Trade-off: Its $400 monthly starting price may be too high for a small team.

    6.2/10
    from
    $400/mo

03Side by side

ToolScoreFromFree planBest for
Criteria (current)5.2CustomNoTeams hiring across several roles
HackerRank6.5$165/moYesTeams hiring software developers
Gem6.5$130/moYesSmall teams hiring regularly
Checkr5.6$24.99/moYesTeams screening occasional hires
CATS5.8$95/moNoRecruiting teams needing ATS and CRM
Bullhorn6.8$99/moNoStaffing agencies building a recruiting workflow
Ashby6.2$400/moNoTeams hiring regularly

Questions people ask

Is Criteria worth it for a small team?

It may be if your team hires across several roles and needs structured assessments, interviews, and development tools. But Criteria uses custom pricing, so you can’t judge its value from a public starting price. If you hire infrequently, first consider whether you need a dedicated assessment tool at all.

Which Criteria alternative has a free plan?

Checkr, Gem, and HackerRank list free plans. Their free-plan limits are not clear from the listed details, so ask each vendor what is included and whether usage, seats, or features are restricted. HackerRank is aimed at developer hiring; Checkr focuses on background screening.

How much do Criteria alternatives cost for a few seats?

Listed starting prices range from $24.99 for Checkr to $400 per month for Ashby, but those figures aren’t directly comparable: Checkr charges per report, and CATS uses per-user pricing. Ask vendors for a quote covering your seats, billing period, and expected usage before comparing totals.