review galore

Simpler and cheaper options · 6 options

Heartland Payments alternatives

For a small shop, a free POS or a lower starting price may beat Heartland’s $89 entry point.

We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never changes a score or a ranking. How we make money

A team with one location may not need a payment system that starts at $89 a month. Heartland Payments suits some small restaurants and retailers, but the listed starting price and sparse cost details make it worth comparing simpler or free-starting options. Square and PayPal offer free plans; Clover lists a $29.95 starting price. These aren’t per-seat prices, so ask each vendor what a few staff accounts, processing, hardware, and setup will cost before you switch.

01Why people leave Heartland Payments

The entry price may be too high

Heartland’s listed $89 entry plans can be hard to justify when a free-starting option may cover a small team’s basic payment needs.

The full bill is unclear

The entry price doesn’t settle the total cost. Ask Heartland for processing, hardware, add-on, and account costs for your location.

Setup details are sparse

If your shop needs a quick, simple switch, get the setup steps and timeline in writing before choosing Heartland or an alternative.

02The alternatives, ranked by fit

  1. Best free POS

    Square

    Square is a strong first comparison for small sellers who want to start without a monthly software bill: Square Free covers core selling tools, and the plan is free. A paid starting price isn’t listed, and processing and hardware add-ons affect the real cost. Ask about setup and any paid features you need before moving over from Heartland.

    Trade-off: Budget separately for processing, hardware, and paid features.

    7.2/10
    from
    Free
    free plan
  2. Best small-shop POS

    Clover

    Clover may fit a small retailer, restaurant, or service business that wants POS hardware and a clear listed starting price. Its plan starts at $29.95, and a free plan is listed. That gives a team a lower monthly entry point than Heartland’s $89 plans, but device, processing, and hardware costs need checking. Ask for setup steps and the total quote.

    Trade-off: Device, processing, and hardware costs can add to the bill.

    6.8/10
    from
    $29.95/mo
    free plan
  3. Best for online checkout

    PayPal

    PayPal suits a small shop that mainly needs online payments, PayPal and Venmo checkout, or payment transfers. It has a free plan and lists a $5 starting price, giving teams a lower entry point than Heartland’s $89 plans. Ask which features the paid plan adds, what processing costs, and what setup requires before switching.

    Trade-off: Variable fees and reported account problems merit caution.

    6.8/10
    from
    $5/mo
    free plan
  4. Best for eCheck

    Authorize.Net

    Authorize.Net is worth comparing if your business already has a merchant account or needs payments across channels and U.S. eCheck support. Its listed price starts at $25 a month, with transaction fees, and there’s no free plan listed. That’s a lower monthly starting point than Heartland’s $89 entry plans, but ask about setup and total processing costs.

    Trade-off: It’s a paid-first option, with transaction fees on top.

    6.2/10
    from
    $25/mo
  5. Best for nonprofits

    Vanco

    Vanco is a closer fit than Heartland for a church or nonprofit focused on recurring donations, online giving, and in-person payments. It has a $0 starting plan, though its listed starting price is also $54; ask which package that refers to and what processing fees and extras cost. Get setup details and a full quote before deciding whether it beats Heartland for your team.

    Trade-off: Processing fees and extras shape the actual cost.

    6.8/10
    from
    $54/mo
    free plan
  6. Best for payment channels

    Windcave

    Windcave may suit a small business that needs payments across several channels, global acquiring, or a wider choice of payment methods. Its pricing is quote-based, so there’s no published starting price to compare with Heartland’s $89 plans. Ask for a quote covering your expected processing, any hardware, and setup; without that, it’s difficult to judge the cost for a small team.

    Trade-off: Quote-based pricing makes budgeting harder.

    5.8/10
    from
    Custom

03Side by side

ToolScoreFromFree planBest for
Heartland Payments (current)5.5$89/moNoSingle-location restaurants
Square7.2FreeYesSmall in-person sellers
Clover6.8$29.95/moYesSmall retail shops
PayPal6.8$5/moYesSmall shops accepting online payments
Authorize.Net6.2$25/moNoBusinesses already using a merchant account
Vanco6.8$54/moYesChurches starting online giving
Windcave5.8CustomNoMerchants accepting payments across channels

Questions people ask

Who are Shift4 Payments’ main competitors?

There isn’t one best competitor for every small team. Square and Clover are options for small sellers wanting POS tools; PayPal focuses on online checkout and transfers. Authorize.Net, Vanco, and Windcave may fit more specific payment needs. Compare processing, hardware, and setup costs—not just the monthly starting price.

What is Heartland Pay?

Heartland Payments is a payment and POS option aimed at businesses such as single-location restaurants and retailers with one or two POS stations. Its listed entry plans start at $89. Before buying, ask what the price includes and get processing, hardware, add-on, and setup costs for your business in writing.

Is there a lawsuit against Heartland Payment Systems?

We can’t confirm a specific lawsuit without a case name, court, or filing date. If a legal claim could affect your buying decision, check current court records and official statements, and distinguish allegations from rulings. Don’t rely on an unsourced mention as proof of a case or its outcome.