We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never changes a score or a ranking. How we make money
A small team may not need to replace Manatal at all: one Reddit commenter says a lower-cost ATS can be enough when hiring volume is modest. But other Reddit users say Manatal’s agency-oriented workflow can frustrate in-house hiring teams. Our picks cover different needs, from an ATS with a listed free plan to developer assessments and background checks. Prices below are starting points, not a promised bill for your team; ask vendors what a few seats and onboarding will cost.
01Why people leave Manatal
The workflow feels agency-first
A Reddit commenter says Manatal centers on clients, job ads, shortlists, and placements rather than customizable in-house job requisitions.
Candidate matching falls short
One Reddit commenter criticized Manatal’s candidate matching and UI. Treat that as an individual report, not a guarantee your team will agree.
You need more process visibility
Reddit users say higher-priced ATS tools can help with automation, reporting, and multi-interviewer hiring—but may not pay off for a small team.
02The alternatives, ranked by fit
- Best free starting point
GemGemChoose Gem if you want to check a free option before committing to another paid ATS. Its listing shows a free plan and pricing from $130, and positions it for teams hiring regularly or replacing several recruiting tools. The free-plan limits and price for a few seats aren’t clear, so ask for those details along with onboarding requirements before switching.
Trade-off: The free tier’s limits and a small team’s total cost need confirmation.
6.5/10from
$130/mofree plan - Best for ATS and CRM
CATSCATSCATS is worth comparing if your small recruiting team wants ATS and CRM features with candidate-stage workflows. The listing starts at $95, but also notes per-user pricing, so don’t treat that figure as the cost for your whole team. Ask for a quote covering your actual seats and for details on setup before moving your process.
Trade-off: Per-user pricing can make the total harder to predict.
5.8/10from
$95/mo - Best for staffing agencies
BullhornBullhornFor an agency that wants ATS and CRM together, Bullhorn is a more directly matched option than a general in-house hiring tool. Its listing starts at $99 and notes free implementation, which may help with setup costs. Confirm the price for your seats and ask what implementation includes; the listing doesn’t specify a free plan.
Trade-off: It is aimed at staffing workflows, not a free starter.
6.8/10from
$99/mo - Best for occasional screening
CheckrCheckrCheckr may suit a small team that mainly needs background screening for occasional hires, rather than a replacement ATS. Its listing includes a free plan and a starting price of $24.99; the product summary says teams pay per report. Ask which checks are included and what each report costs before budgeting.
Trade-off: It handles screening, not the full recruiting workflow.
5.6/10from
$24.99/mofree plan - Best for developer hiring
HackerRankHackerRankIf your team hires software developers and needs technical screening, HackerRank is a focused alternative to a general ATS. The listing shows a free plan and pricing from $165. Its free-plan limits and annual pricing need scrutiny, so ask what the free tier includes and what a few users will pay before adopting it.
Trade-off: It is focused on assessments, not a general ATS replacement.
6.5/10from
$165/mofree plan - Best for growing pipelines
LeverLeverLever is worth a look if your team wants an ATS and CRM together for multiple roles and ongoing candidate pipelines. The listing describes those recruiting capabilities, but the vendor doesn’t publish a starting price; you’ll need a quote to compare it with Manatal. Ask for a price covering your seats and implementation before investing time in a switch.
Trade-off: No public price makes a small-team budget harder to assess.
5.8/10from
Custom
03Side by side
| Tool | Score | From | Free plan | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 7.2 | $15/mo | No | Small teams replacing spreadsheet hiring | |
| 6.5 | $130/mo | Yes | Small teams hiring regularly | |
| 5.8 | $95/mo | No | Recruiting teams needing ATS and CRM | |
| 6.8 | $99/mo | No | Staffing agencies building a recruiting workflow | |
| 5.6 | $24.99/mo | Yes | Teams screening occasional hires | |
| 6.5 | $165/mo | Yes | Teams hiring software developers | |
| 5.8 | Custom | No | Teams hiring across multiple roles |
Questions people ask
Which Manatal alternative has a free plan?
The listings show free plans for Gem, Checkr, and HackerRank. They don’t establish what each free plan includes or how long it lasts. Ask the vendor about limits, user access, and any paid features you’d need before treating a free tier as a workable replacement.
What should a small team budget for a few seats?
The listed starting prices are $95 for CATS, $99 for Bullhorn, $130 for Gem, and $165 for HackerRank; Checkr starts at $24.99 and charges per report. These figures don’t establish a total for several seats. Get a quote based on your users and expected usage.
Is Manatal too limited for in-house hiring?
It depends on your process. One Reddit commenter says Manatal’s workflow is geared toward agency recruitment and isn’t customizable, while another criticized its candidate matching. Those are individual opinions. If your team needs a different workflow, ask vendors to show how they handle your hiring steps and what migration requires.
