review galore

Simpler and cheaper options · 6 options

Plum alternatives

For teams of 1–6, compare assessment tools and recruiting options by price, free-plan details, and fit.

We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never changes a score or a ranking. How we make money

A small team may not need a behavioral assessment for every hire. Plum assesses traits and potential, but its listed price is n/a, so budgeting is difficult before you talk to the vendor. These alternatives cover structured assessments, technical screening, background checks, and recruiting workflows. Some list free plans or starting prices, but plan limits and setup effort are not always clear. Ask for the total cost for your headcount and the work required to get started.

01Why people leave Plum

Pricing is hard to budget

Plum’s listed starting price is n/a. A small team may want a published price or a quote for its actual hiring volume.

The assessment focus may not fit

Plum assesses behavioral traits and potential. Teams focused on technical screening, background checks, or recruiting workflows may need a different tool.

Setup effort needs checking

Before committing, ask Plum what setup involves, how long it takes, and whether your team needs help configuring assessments.

02The alternatives, ranked by fit

  1. Best for structured assessments

    Criteria

    Criteria is the closest fit if you want structured assessments rather than a broader recruiting platform. Its listed scope includes assessments, interviews, and development tools. The vendor does not publish a starting price, so ask for a quote for your number of users and hiring volume. Free-plan details and setup effort also need confirming before you compare total cost with Plum.

    Trade-off: Custom pricing makes a small-team budget harder to judge.

    5.2/10
    from
    Custom
  2. Best free recruiting suite

    Gem

    Gem may suit a small team that wants recruiting tools beyond behavioral assessments: it covers much of the recruiting stack and can work with an existing ATS. The pricing lists a free plan and a $130 starting price, but the free-plan limits and price basis need checking. Ask what setup requires and whether Gem fits your current hiring process before switching tools.

    Trade-off: It is a broader recruiting tool, not a direct assessment match.

    6.5/10
    from
    $130/mo
    free plan
  3. Best for occasional screening

    Checkr

    Checkr fits teams that need background screening for occasional hires, not teams looking for a behavioral assessment. Its listing includes a free plan and a $24.99 starting price, and screening is paid per report. Ask which checks are included, what the free plan covers, and how to handle accuracy concerns before deciding whether its per-hire cost suits your volume.

    Trade-off: Per-report screening does not assess behavioral traits or potential.

    5.6/10
    from
    $24.99/mo
    free plan
  4. Best for developer hiring

    HackerRank

    For teams hiring software developers, HackerRank offers technical screening and interviews instead of Plum’s behavioral assessment. Its listing includes a free plan and a $165 starting price, but the free-plan limits are unclear. Ask whether the plan fits your hiring volume, what the listed price covers, and how much setup is needed to create and run assessments.

    Trade-off: Its focus is technical hiring, not general behavioral assessment.

    6.5/10
    from
    $165/mo
    free plan
  5. Best for recruiting workflows

    CATS

    CATS is worth considering if your small team needs an ATS and CRM with candidate-stage workflows, rather than an assessment-only tool. Its listed starting price is $95, and pricing is per user, so ask for the total for your team and billing terms. Check whether assessments meet your needs and ask what setup is involved before moving your process.

    Trade-off: Per-user pricing can add up, and assessment fit needs checking.

    5.8/10
    from
    $95/mo
  6. Best for growing hiring teams

    Ashby

    Ashby combines recruiting tools and may suit a team planning to hire regularly or replace separate systems. The listed starting price is $400 monthly, which is a substantial commitment for a team of 1–10. Ask what that price includes, how many users it covers, and what implementation involves. It is a broader recruiting option, not a direct Plum assessment replacement.

    Trade-off: The $400 monthly starting price may be too high for a small team.

    6.2/10
    from
    $400/mo

03Side by side

ToolScoreFromFree planBest for
Plum (current)5.5CustomNoHiring teams assessing durable skills
Criteria5.2CustomNoTeams hiring across several roles
Gem6.5$130/moYesSmall teams hiring regularly
Checkr5.6$24.99/moYesTeams screening occasional hires
HackerRank6.5$165/moYesTeams hiring software developers
CATS5.8$95/moNoRecruiting teams needing ATS and CRM
Ashby6.2$400/moNoTeams hiring regularly

Questions people ask

Who are Plum’s main competitors?

For behavioral and structured assessments, Criteria is the closest alternative in this list. HackerRank focuses on technical hiring, while Checkr handles background screening. Gem, CATS, and Ashby cover broader recruiting needs. The right competitor depends on whether you need assessment, screening, or a full recruiting workflow.

What are some apps similar to Plum?

Criteria is the most directly comparable option listed for structured assessments. HackerRank is a fit for technical screening, while Checkr focuses on background checks. Gem, CATS, and Ashby offer broader recruiting tools, so they may replace parts of a hiring stack rather than Plum’s assessment focus.

Which is better, Emma or Plum?

That depends on which Emma product you mean and what your team needs. Plum is described as a tool for assessing behavioral traits and potential in hiring. Compare the specific Emma product’s purpose, pricing, plan limits, and setup requirements before choosing between them.