We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never changes a score or a ranking. How we make money
A small team may not need to leave Printify: its free plan is a solid starting point, and its paid plan is listed from $24.99. But if per-order costs, provider choices or fulfillment concerns are pushing you to compare, these alternatives offer different starting points. The prices below are listed starting figures, not quotes for a few seats. Seat allowances and per-user charges aren't published in these listings, so check those before choosing.
01Why people leave Printify
Order costs can add up
One Reddit commenter argues Printify adds product and shipping costs versus going direct. Treat that as one seller's view and compare your actual landed costs.
Fulfillment experiences vary
Reddit users report mixed quality and service. One seller reported six issues across 228 orders, all resolved; that's one account, not a service-wide rate.
The provider network adds a layer
Commenters describe Printify as connecting sellers with separate print providers. One says buying direct can offer more control, though not every provider has its own tools.
02The alternatives, ranked by fit
- Best for niche testing
EPROLOEPROLOEPROLO's listing includes a free plan and a $1.66 starting figure, which may suit a small store testing product niches without taking on a higher listed starting price. It also offers optional custom branding. The listing doesn't spell out seat allowances or per-user charges, so ask about those, plus product and shipping costs, before scaling.
Trade-off: Check extra costs and fulfillment details before growing.
7.4/10from
$1.66/mofree plan - Best for no subscription
GootenGootenGooten is listed from $0 with a free plan, and its broad product catalog can help a small shop test print-on-demand without a subscription. It may fit teams using one of its listed integrations. The listing doesn't provide a few-seat quote, and fulfillment reports call for caution, so verify product and shipping costs before routing more orders.
Trade-off: User reports suggest checking fulfillment carefully.
4.8/10from
Freefree plan - Best for local production
GelatoGelatoGelato has a free plan and is listed from $19.99. It targets new sellers and small Shopify or Etsy shops, with local production and team access among its stated draws. That makes it worth comparing for a small team. The listing doesn't give seat limits or per-seat charges; check those and shipping costs before switching.
Trade-off: Shipping costs and team access terms need checking.
7.0/10from
$19.99/mofree plan - Best for connected fulfillment
PrintfulPrintfulPrintful is listed with a free plan and a $24.99 starting price, close to Printify's listed $24.99 starting price. It suits small teams testing custom products without inventory and stores needing connected fulfillment. Compare product and shipping costs before moving: the listing warns that margins and fulfillment reliability deserve attention, and doesn't give a few-seat quote.
Trade-off: Watch margins and fulfillment reliability.
7.1/10from
$24.99/mofree plan - Best for merch variety
CustomCatCustomCatCustomCat has a free plan and is listed from $25, with many product types and connected stores among its stated fits. A small team can use it to start a merch store, but the starting price isn't the whole order cost: budget for wholesale costs and shipping on each order. Seat pricing isn't listed, so ask for a quote for your team.
Trade-off: Wholesale costs and shipping apply to every order.
7.4/10from
$25/mofree plan - Best for global production
MerchizeMerchizeMerchize is listed with a free plan and a $79 starting price, and targets small teams starting with print-on-demand, no-MOQ fulfillment and global production. It costs more upfront on the listed starting figures than several picks here. Before investing setup time, check how setup works and ask about paid-store fees and seat costs.
Trade-off: Check setup requirements and paid-store fees first.
6.8/10from
$79/mofree plan - Best for order automation
AutoDSAutoDSAutoDS is listed from $19.90 and targets sellers automating regular orders, Shopify stores with growing catalogs and teams wanting product research tools. It may suit a team that needs those selling tools more than a basic POD starting point. Its trial and billing deserve extra care; seat pricing and the cost for a few users aren't listed.
Trade-off: Trial and billing terms need careful checking.
5.2/10from
$19.90/mo
03Side by side
| Tool | Score | From | Free plan | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 6.7 | $24.99/mo | Yes | New print-on-demand sellers | |
| 7.4 | $1.66/mo | Yes | Solo dropshippers starting out | |
| 4.8 | Free | Yes | Small shops testing print-on-demand | |
| 7.0 | $19.99/mo | Yes | New print-on-demand sellers | |
| 7.1 | $24.99/mo | Yes | Small teams testing product ideas | |
| 7.4 | $25/mo | Yes | Small teams starting a merch store | |
| 6.8 | $79/mo | Yes | Small teams starting with POD | |
| 5.2 | $19.90/mo | No | Sellers automating regular orders |
Questions people ask
Which Printify alternative has the lowest listed starting price?
Gooten is listed from $0 with a free plan; EPROLO is listed from $1.66 with a free plan. Those figures don't show the full cost of fulfilling orders. Compare product and shipping costs for the items you sell, and ask each vendor for any seat charges before deciding.
Which alternative is best for a small team?
It depends on what your team needs: Gelato lists team access and local production, while Printful targets stores needing connected fulfillment. Their seat limits and per-user charges aren't published in these listings. Ask vendors for the cost and access terms for your actual number of users.
How much setup work do these alternatives require?
Setup effort isn't specified in the listings, so we can't rank these tools by onboarding time. Before switching, ask the vendor how to connect your store, move product designs and handle existing orders. Confirm that your store platform is supported and ask whether setup help is included.
