We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never changes a score or a ranking. How we make money
A team of 1–10 may not need a dedicated security-rating platform if vendor reviews are occasional; one Reddit commenter says third-party risk work can be done without tools like this. If you do need a system, start by matching the tool to the work: vendor assessments, questionnaires, or broader governance. Whistic is the closest fit in this list. Several options have unpublished pricing, so ask for a quote based on your seats and vendors before budgeting.
01Why people leave SecurityScorecard
Paid costs are hard to assess
SecurityScorecard’s paid starting price is unclear, making it difficult for a small team to budget before speaking with sales.
Some users distrust the scoring
Reddit commenters criticize the scores as arbitrary and describe difficulty disputing findings without a paid membership.
The tool may be more than you need
One Reddit commenter calls this category nice-to-have; smaller teams may prefer a simpler vendor-review process or a tool for a narrower job.
02The alternatives, ranked by fit
- Best for vendor assessments
WhisticWhisticWhistic is the closest fit if your main job is vendor assessments and sharing approved security evidence. It lists a free plan, but the included scope isn't clear, and paid pricing is unpublished, so get a quote for your number of vendors and seats. Ask what onboarding requires and whether its workflows cover your review process before moving off SecurityScorecard.
Trade-off: Paid costs and free-plan coverage are unclear.
6.2/10from
Freefree plan - Best for questionnaires
VantaVantaVanta suits a small team that wants compliance work alongside security questionnaires and vendor reviews. The vendor doesn't publish an entry price, so ask for a quote covering your seats and required workflows. The free-plan details aren't listed; confirm whether one is available. Before choosing it, ask how much setup your team will need to configure the work you actually plan to manage.
Trade-off: You need a sales quote to judge the cost.
6.4/10from
Custom - Best for broad GRC
AnecdotesAnecdotesAnecdotes includes vendor-risk workflows in a broader GRC platform, which may fit a team managing several frameworks rather than just monitoring ratings. Its pricing is custom and no entry price is published, so small teams should ask for a quote for their seats and scope. Free-plan availability and setup effort aren't clear; confirm both before taking on a broader system.
Trade-off: Its enterprise focus and custom pricing may be too much.
5.2/10from
Custom - Best for governance
Diligent One PlatformDiligent One PlatformDiligent One Platform is aimed at teams coordinating board and GRC work, not just checking vendor scores. It may be worth a quote when governance is the bigger need, but there is no published starting price to calculate a few-seat cost. Free-plan availability and setup effort aren't clear, so ask for a small-team quote and a description of implementation before comparing it.
Trade-off: Hard to recommend on a tight, predictable budget.
5.0/10from
Custom - Best for policy workflows
PowerDMSPowerDMSPowerDMS is a more focused option for compliance-heavy organizations managing policy approvals or preparing for accreditation. Pricing is custom, with no published entry point, so ask what a few seats would cost. Free-plan availability and setup effort aren't clear. It makes more sense when policy work is the priority than when your main need is external security ratings.
Trade-off: It focuses on policies and compliance, not vendor ratings.
6.0/10from
Custom - Best for security training
KnowBe4KnowBe4KnowBe4 is not a direct vendor-risk replacement, but it may fit if the real priority is security training and phishing simulations. Its listed starting price is $2.4, but pricing begins at 25 seats and requires a three-year term, which complicates budgeting for a team of 1–10. Confirm the free-plan options and setup requirements before deciding whether this narrower need is a better use of budget.
Trade-off: Training is a different job; the entry terms don't suit tiny teams.
6.8/10from
$2.40/mo
03Side by side
| Tool | Score | From | Free plan | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 5.0 | Free | Yes | Teams formalizing vendor-risk reviews | |
| 6.2 | Free | Yes | Teams managing vendor assessments | |
| 6.4 | Custom | No | Teams preparing for a compliance audit | |
| 5.2 | Custom | No | Enterprise GRC teams | |
| 5.0 | Custom | No | Teams coordinating board and GRC work | |
| 6.0 | Custom | No | Compliance-heavy small organizations | |
| 6.8 | $2.40/mo | No | Small IT teams formalizing security training |
Questions people ask
Does SecurityScorecard have a free plan?
SecurityScorecard is listed with a free plan, but its limits are hard to assess. Before relying on it, ask what the plan covers, including monitored assets, vendor count, alerts, and access to support for disputing findings. Also confirm which features require a paid plan.
Which SecurityScorecard alternative is best for a small team?
For vendor assessments and sharing approved security evidence, Whistic is the closest fit in this list and has a free plan. Its included scope and paid pricing aren't clear, so ask for a quote based on your seats and vendors. Vanta may fit better if questionnaires and compliance work are also priorities.
How much do SecurityScorecard alternatives cost for a few seats?
Several options here don't publish an entry price, including Whistic, Vanta, Anecdotes, Diligent One Platform, and PowerDMS. KnowBe4 lists a $2.4 starting price, but its 25-seat entry and three-year term complicate costs for a small team. Ask vendors for a quote covering your actual seats and needs.
