We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never changes a score or a ranking. How we make money
If your team hires only occasionally, ask whether you need a full ATS—or just a simpler way to track applicants and schedule interviews. Teamtailor is aimed at in-house teams building a career site, nurturing candidates between roles, and using AI tools. But its pricing is quote-based, so small teams cannot compare the bill from a public starting price. We’d ask about the minimum plan, seat costs, and setup scope before moving a live pipeline.
01Why people leave Teamtailor
You need a clear price
Teamtailor asks buyers to request a quote. One Reddit commenter called it a jump in spend from Manatal, making the price worth checking early.
The workflow feels clunky
Reddit users report confusing scheduling and past freezing or clunky behavior. Others say it works well, so ask for a walkthrough of your key tasks.
You want more control
A Reddit commenter found personalization hard because parts felt hard-coded; another disliked the recruiter name on some emails. Check whether your needed settings are available.
02The alternatives, ranked by fit
- Best free-plan option
GemGemGem is worth comparing if your small team hires regularly and wants recruiting tools without replacing its existing ATS. The listing includes a free plan and a starting price of $130, but does not state the few-seat total or free-plan limits. Ask what the free tier covers, what triggers paid pricing, and what migration or onboarding involves.
Trade-off: Pricing and free-plan limits need confirmation before you can budget.
6.5/10from
$130/mofree plan - Best budget ATS and CRM
CATSCATSCATS combines ATS and CRM workflows, which may suit a small team that wants candidate stages and sourcing in one tool. Its listed starting price is $95, and the pricing is per user, so ask for the total for your seats. Confirm whether a free plan exists and what setup help is included before switching.
Trade-off: Per-user pricing can add up as you add seats.
5.8/10from
$95/mo - Best for staffing agencies
BullhornBullhornBullhorn is a closer fit than Teamtailor for a small staffing agency that needs recruiting tools and a CRM together. Its listed starting price is $99, and the listing highlights free implementation. Ask what that implementation covers, whether the price changes by seat, and which features are included at the starting price.
Trade-off: It is aimed at staffing agencies, not every in-house team.
6.8/10from
$99/mo - Best for candidate nurturing
LeverLeverLever combines ATS and CRM capabilities for teams managing several roles and keeping candidate pipelines warm. Its pricing is quote-based, so ask for a written total for your team rather than assuming it will cost less than Teamtailor. One Reddit user preferred Lever Nurture’s ease of use, but that is a personal comparison, not a guarantee.
Trade-off: You still need a quote to judge the cost.
5.8/10from
Custom - Best for regular hiring
AshbyAshbyAshby combines recruiting tools and may suit a startup hiring regularly that wants to replace separate products. The listed starting price is $400 per month, which is a high bar for many small teams. Ask how the starting plan scales with seats and what setup requires before deciding whether consolidating tools offsets the cost.
Trade-off: The $400 monthly starting price may stretch a small budget.
6.2/10from
$400/mo - Best for occasional screening
CheckrCheckrCheckr is not a full ATS replacement, but it may be enough if the main job you need handled is screening occasional hires. The listing shows a free plan and a $24.99 starting price. Ask what the free plan covers and what each report costs; per-report charges can matter when hiring volume changes.
Trade-off: It handles screening, not the broader hiring workflow.
5.6/10from
$24.99/mofree plan
03Side by side
| Tool | Score | From | Free plan | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 6.3 | Custom | No | In-house teams building a career site | |
| 6.5 | $130/mo | Yes | Small teams hiring regularly | |
| 5.8 | $95/mo | No | Recruiting teams needing ATS and CRM | |
| 6.8 | $99/mo | No | Staffing agencies building a recruiting workflow | |
| 5.8 | Custom | No | Teams hiring across multiple roles | |
| 6.2 | $400/mo | No | Teams hiring regularly | |
| 5.6 | $24.99/mo | Yes | Teams screening occasional hires |
Questions people ask
What are the top 5 ATS systems?
There is no single best ATS for every small team. For teams comparing Teamtailor, CATS, Gem, Lever, Bullhorn, and Ashby are options to consider, depending on whether you need ATS and CRM tools, candidate nurturing, or staffing-agency workflows. Compare the starting price and ask for the cost for your actual seat count.
Is Teamtailor an ATS system?
Yes. Teamtailor is a hiring tool for in-house teams, with a focus on building a career site, nurturing candidates between roles, and using AI tools. Its pricing is quote-based, so ask the vendor for the cost of the plan and seats your team would need.
What companies use Teamtailor?
Teamtailor is positioned for in-house hiring teams building a career site, nurturing candidates between roles, and using AI tools. That describes the types of teams it targets, not a list of named customers. Ask the vendor for examples from companies with a similar team size and hiring process.
