We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never changes a score or a ranking. How we make money
A small team may not need a full accounting platform if it mainly sends invoices and tracks bills. But if you need integrations, cash-flow forecasts or accountant access, compare those needs before switching. Xero’s listed starting price is $7, while plan limits and extras can raise the bill. One r/nzbusiness thread describes frustration with price rises and paying for features the business rarely used. Here are alternatives with different tradeoffs for lean teams.
01Why people leave Xero
Price rises and payroll add-ons
One r/nzbusiness poster said extra payroll users cost $4 each and described a rising bill. That is one user's New Zealand experience, not a universal quote.
Paying for features you rarely use
Commenters described using Xero mainly for invoicing, bills and reconciliation, and feeling the extra features did not justify the cost.
Accountant and payroll constraints
Some commenters said their accountant required Xero; others complained about its payroll. Switching may depend on accountant support and your payroll needs.
02The alternatives, ranked by fit
- Best free starting point
WaveWaveFor a solo business or small team focused on invoices and bookkeeping basics, Wave is the clearest budget-first option. Its listing includes a free plan and a paid starting price of $15.83. Seat pricing and setup time aren't published, so ask about both and check what the free plan covers before moving records.
Trade-off: Costs need checking as you grow, and the free plan's limits aren't listed.
6.8/10from
$15.83/mofree plan - Best for accountant access
QuickBooks OnlineQuickBooks OnlineQuickBooks Online suits teams that need accounting, payroll or a workflow with their accountant. The listing includes a free plan and a starting price of $20, and calls out support for small teams needing five seats. It also warns that a few seats can make the monthly bill sizable. Seat pricing and setup time aren't published; confirm them before switching.
Trade-off: A few seats can quickly turn a low starting price into a sizable bill.
5.8/10from
$20/mofree plan - Best for client invoicing
FreshBooksFreshBooksFreshBooks is aimed at freelancers and small firms tracking time and expenses, with accountant access. It starts at $23 and has no free plan. The listing warns that paid seats raise the bill, so ask for pricing for your team size. Setup time isn't published; check what help is available for bringing over invoices and records.
Trade-off: No free plan, and extra paid seats can raise the cost.
6.8/10from
$23/mo - Best for vendor bill pay
MelioMelioIf your main reason for using Xero is paying vendor bills, Melio may be a narrower fit. Its listing includes a free plan and a $20 starting price, and highlights bill approvals and QuickBooks Online users. Seat pricing and setup time aren't published. Ask how transaction fees and seats would affect your actual monthly spend.
Trade-off: It focuses on bill pay; budget for seats and transaction fees as you grow.
7.0/10from
$20/mofree plan - Best for broader finance
Exact OnlineExact OnlineExact Online is for SMEs needing finance and ERP features, and may suit teams in its supported industries or accountants managing client work. The listed starting price is $25, but the listing says small teams need a quote to know the real seat cost. Setup time isn't published; ask for a quote covering your team and migration needs.
Trade-off: The real seat cost requires a quote, and its broad feature set may be more than a small team needs.
6.4/10from
$25/mo - Best for desktop accounting
QuickBooks Desktop ProQuickBooks Desktop ProQuickBooks Desktop Pro is worth considering only if your team specifically wants desktop accounting and enters transactions manually. The listing gives no starting price and advises confirming current licensing first. Setup time isn't published, so ask about licensing, migration and support before choosing it as a lower-cost replacement for Xero.
Trade-off: Current licensing costs aren't listed; confirm them before committing.
4.2/10from
Custom
03Side by side
| Tool | Score | From | Free plan | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 7.0 | $7/mo | No | Small businesses needing core accounting | |
| 6.8 | $15.83/mo | Yes | Solo businesses watching costs | |
| 5.8 | $20/mo | Yes | Businesses that need accounting and payroll | |
| 6.8 | $23/mo | No | Freelancers invoicing a few clients | |
| 7.0 | $20/mo | Yes | Solo businesses paying vendor bills | |
| 6.4 | $25/mo | No | SMEs needing finance and ERP | |
| 4.2 | Custom | No | Teams committed to desktop accounting |
Questions people ask
Is there an alternative to Xero?
Yes. Wave offers a free plan for bookkeeping and invoices; QuickBooks Online covers accounting and payroll; FreshBooks focuses on invoicing, time and expenses. Compare the features you actually use, the cost for your number of seats and whether your accountant supports the alternative.
Why don't accountants like QuickBooks?
We wouldn't assume accountants generally dislike QuickBooks. The available listing positions QuickBooks Online for teams working with an accountant, but preferences vary. Ask your accountant which products they support and whether they can access the records you plan to keep in another system.
Why is Xero declining?
One Reddit thread reports frustration with price rises, payroll costs and paying for features the poster rarely used. That reflects individual complaints, not evidence of a broad decline. For your own decision, compare Xero's current plan and extras with the features and seat costs of alternatives.
