We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never changes a score or a ranking. How we make money
Most buyers should pick OnPay.
For a team of 1–10, we’d start with OnPay: its published Payroll Essentials price is $49 monthly plus $6 per worker, and five workers cost $79 before add-ons. ADP may be worth a quote if you’re planning for broader HR and workforce needs as you grow. But its pricing and setup details aren’t published, and its listed tiers are generally aimed at organizations with 50 to 999+ employees. For a tiny team watching cash flow, OnPay is easier to budget.
01Side by side
| ADP Workforce Now | OnPay | |
|---|---|---|
| Free plan | No free plan | No free plan; one-month free trial |
| Cheapest paid plan | Price not published; request a quote | $49/month + $6 per worker |
| Price per seat | Not published | $6/worker, plus $49 monthly base |
| Five-person monthly cost | Not published; quote required | $79 before add-ons |
| Setup effort | Setup details and timeline not published | Free data migration; timeline not published |
| Learning curve | Review ease-of-use score: 4/10 | Review ease-of-use score: 7/10 |
| Small-team integrations | Not listed on the homepage | Accounting, 401(k), HR, and compliance tools |
| Support | Review support score: 5/10 | Phone, chat, and email; review score 6/10 |
ADP Workforce Now Choose ADP Workforce Now if
- Choose ADP Workforce Now if your organization is approaching midsize scale.
- Choose ADP Workforce Now if you need a quote for broader workforce needs.
- Choose ADP Workforce Now if you’re comparing its payroll and HR offerings.
OnPay Choose OnPay if
- Choose OnPay if you want a published payroll price for a small team.
- Choose OnPay if you need multi-state payroll and year-end filings.
- Choose OnPay if free data migration matters when switching providers.
02What each costs a small team
Neither vendor lists an ongoing free plan. OnPay offers a one-month free trial, not a permanent free tier. Its Payroll Essentials plan is $49 monthly plus $6 per worker: one worker costs $55, three cost $67, and five cost $79 before add-ons. The plan lists unlimited pay runs and schedules, tax filings, and W-2, 1099, and year-end filings. An annual rate isn’t published.
ADP doesn’t publish a monthly or annual price, seat limit, or starting price. Select, Plus, and Premium are listed for midsize-to-enterprise organizations and are generally targeted at 50 to 999+ employees; that pricing information is low confidence. So we can’t calculate a one-person or five-person cost. Ask ADP for a written quote that spells out payroll, setup, and required add-ons before comparing totals.
03Setup and day-to-day use
Neither provider publishes a setup timeline in the information available from its vendor pages. OnPay says it offers free data migration for businesses switching providers, but ask what the migration covers and how long it takes. Its payroll plan supports multiple states and unlimited pay schedules, so confirm the states, pay cycles, and filings you need before signing up.
ADP’s homepage describes payroll and HR offerings across business sizes, but doesn’t explain Workforce Now setup steps. Ask for a walkthrough of implementation, employee onboarding, and any extra fees. OnPay lists customizable hiring workflows, eSignature templates, and personnel tools; those can help with onboarding employees, but aren’t a published setup-time estimate. Review scores rate ease of use at 7/10 for OnPay and 4/10 for ADP. Treat those as review scores, not a promise about your team’s learning curve.
04What you get on the cheaper plans
OnPay’s Payroll Essentials plan lists unlimited pay runs and schedules, federal, state, and local tax filings, multi-state payroll, and W-2 and 1099 year-end filings. The service also describes automated payroll calculations and payments, plus human support and free migration. Its broader offering includes hiring workflows, benefits administration, mobile time tracking, and integrations with accounting software, 401(k) providers, and HR and compliance tools. Check which of those features cost extra: listed add-ons include HR and time tracking, while insurance and retirement premiums depend on the plans selected.
ADP lists payroll and HR solutions across small, midsize, and large businesses. Its homepage also lists time and attendance for small and midsize businesses, talent for midsize businesses, and workforce management for large businesses. But ADP doesn’t publish which features come with each Workforce Now tier. Get the inclusions in writing rather than assuming a listed capability is part of the base price.
Questions people ask
Does ADP do payroll?
Yes. ADP lists payroll solutions for small, midsize, and large businesses. Its homepage also lists HR and other workforce offerings by business size. Ask ADP to confirm which payroll features are included in a Workforce Now quote, since the homepage doesn’t detail that product’s plan inclusions.
Is OnPay a good payroll service?
OnPay may suit a small business that wants published payroll pricing, multi-state payroll, tax filings, and year-end forms. Its Payroll Essentials plan starts at $49 monthly plus $6 per worker. Check the cost of add-ons and confirm the tax-filing support you need before committing.
How much does OnPay cost for five workers?
Payroll Essentials costs $49 per month plus $6 per worker. For five workers, that comes to $79 monthly before add-ons. OnPay’s pricing page lists a one-month free trial, but doesn’t publish an annual rate. Benefits premiums and some other add-on costs depend on your selections.
Does ADP publish Workforce Now pricing?
ADP doesn’t publish a monthly or annual Workforce Now price, seat limit, or starting price. Its listed Select, Plus, and Premium tiers are generally aimed at organizations with 50 to 999+ employees. Ask ADP for a written quote with any setup and add-on costs included.