We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never changes a score or a ranking. How we make money
The bottom line
A capable small-business payroll service, but check the price and tax-filing support before committing.
OnPay combines payroll, tax filings, HR, benefits, and time tracking, with a one-month trial and free data migration. Payroll Essentials costs $49 monthly plus $6 per worker, or $55 for one worker.
There’s no free plan, and Reddit feedback on tax filings and support is mixed. Small teams should confirm how OnPay handles their tax-filing needs before moving payroll.
Good fit if
- Small teams needing payroll and filings
- Businesses switching payroll providers
- Teams adding HR or time tracking
Skip it if
- Teams seeking free payroll software
- Businesses needing published annual pricing
- Teams wary of tax-filing support concerns

ScoresHow it rates
What works
- Federal, state, and local tax filings included
- Unlimited pay runs and schedules
- Can pay workers in any number of states
- Free data migration for switching businesses
- Optional HR, benefits, and time tracking
What doesn't
- No free plan
- One worker costs $55 monthly
- Annual pricing is not published
- Benefits premiums cost extra
- Reddit users report tax-filing problems
01Who OnPay is for
OnPay makes sense for a small business that needs payroll calculations, tax filings, and payments handled in one service. The pricing page lists Payroll Essentials at $49 monthly plus $6 per worker, so a one-worker business pays $55 a month. A team of three pays $67, and five workers cost $79, before optional add-ons.
The service also includes year-end filings, unlimited pay runs and schedules, and payroll in any number of states. That can suit a team with workers in multiple locations or a business replacing a CPA-run payroll process. HR, time tracking, and benefits are available as paid extras or bundles. OnPay’s homepage also says it offers free data migration for businesses switching providers. It is less attractive if you need a free payroll option, or if you want a published annual price to compare against your monthly budget.
02OnPay free plan and trial
OnPay has no free plan. The cheapest way in is Payroll Essentials at $49 per month plus $6 per worker. That works out to $55 monthly for one worker, $67 for three, or $79 for five. The pricing page lists a one-month trial, but it does not publish which features or services the trial includes, so ask OnPay what you can use during that month before signing up.
The base plan includes W-2s, 1099s, year-end filings, unlimited pay runs and schedules, federal, state, and local tax filings, and payroll in any number of states. That makes it a fairly complete payroll starting point, but not a no-cost way to run payroll. Optional HR, time tracking, and insurance costs are separate.
03What a small team pays for OnPay
The pricing page lists Payroll Essentials at $49 monthly plus $6 per worker. Using that per-worker rate, one worker costs $55 a month, three cost $67, and five cost $79. Those totals assume each person is a billable worker. The vendor shows monthly pricing; an annual rate is not published.
Optional services raise the bill. HR is $15 monthly plus $2 per worker; Time Tracking is $15 plus $4 per worker. HR + Time Tracking is listed at $21 plus $4 per worker. OnPay also lists Bundled HR at $71 plus $1 per worker and Bundled HR + Time Tracking at $81 plus $4 per worker. Check with OnPay which option fits your setup before adding it to the payroll price.
Integrated benefits administration and integration are listed as free, but plan premiums cost extra. Health insurance, workers’ comp, and 401(k) premiums depend on plan selections. Compliance Resources and Live HR Support have no published price.
04Getting started with OnPay
OnPay says it provides free data migration for businesses switching providers, which may reduce the work of moving payroll records. The homepage also advertises human support by phone, chat, and email. It does not publish a setup timeline, so ask what information it needs from your business and how long migration is likely to take.
The product covers payroll, onboarding, benefits, time tracking, and HR, so teams that want those tools together may have fewer separate services to coordinate. OnPay says employees can clock in on mobile devices and that hours and overtime can import into payroll. It also lists connections to accounting software, 401(k) providers, and HR and compliance tools. Check that your specific providers are supported before setup; the available integration list is not detailed in the pricing information.
Reddit feedback on setup is limited. One small-business commenter said the free migration and setup made switching easier, while another user described support as good and responsive.
05When small teams outgrow OnPay
OnPay’s listed payroll price scales by worker, so the base cost rises predictably: each additional worker adds $6 monthly. The published pricing lists no employee cap, but that does not mean every growing company’s payroll needs are covered. Businesses with more complex processes, especially around garnishments or payment controls, should ask for a walkthrough of the reports and workflows they need before committing.
Reddit comments show why that check matters. One user described unresolved state-tax issues and a long wait for a ticket response; another reported receiving IRS letters after missing quarterly tax documents and incorrect business-name filings. These are individual reports, not a measure of how often problems happen, but they are worth discussing with OnPay directly.
A team may also outgrow the basic price when it adds HR, time tracking, or benefits. Those services add monthly charges, and insurance premiums are extra. Ask for a full quote that includes the features and employee count you expect next.
From the threadsWhat users say
Reddit feedback is mixed: some small-business users describe adequate payroll and responsive support, while others report serious tax-filing problems and slow issue resolution. The concerns are specific user accounts, not proof of how common those issues are.
It was sufficient enough for a small staff and support was good & responsive
The state filed a lien on my company for unpaid taxes
they do free data migration and setup, so it is easy on your end
The last ticket I submitted went over a month without response
Questions people ask
How much does OnPay cost per month?
The pricing page lists Payroll Essentials at $49 per month plus $6 per worker. That makes the monthly total $55 for one worker, $67 for three, and $79 for five. Those figures exclude optional HR, time tracking, and insurance costs. The vendor lists monthly pricing but does not publish an annual rate.
Does OnPay have a free plan?
No. OnPay lists a one-month trial, but it does not publish the trial’s feature limits or terms in the pricing details. The cheapest listed plan is Payroll Essentials at $49 monthly plus $6 per worker. Ask OnPay what the trial includes and when billing begins.
Does OnPay handle payroll tax filings?
Yes. Payroll Essentials lists federal, state, and local tax filings, along with year-end filings. OnPay’s homepage also says it automates payroll calculations, tax filings, and payments. Because some Reddit users report tax-filing problems, confirm the filing process and how support handles corrections before switching.
Can OnPay handle payroll in multiple states?
The Payroll Essentials listing says you can pay workers in any number of states and includes federal, state, and local tax filings. If your team works across several states, confirm any state-specific setup steps and responsibilities with OnPay before you begin.
What bank does OnPay use?
OnPay’s listed pricing information does not name a banking partner. If the bank behind payments or payroll funding matters to your business, ask OnPay directly which bank or banks it uses and what account or transfer details apply to your setup.
