We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never changes a score or a ranking. How we make money
Most buyers should pick Paychex.
For a 1–10-person team, Paychex is the more natural first call: its offerings serve self-employed owners and small businesses, and its Basic payroll plan lists tax filing and year-end forms. ADP offers broad payroll and HR solutions, but its Workforce Now pricing and fit for very small teams aren’t clear. Neither has a listed free plan or published rates, so ask both for an itemized quote for your headcount before choosing.
01Side by side
| ADP Workforce Now | Paychex | |
|---|---|---|
| Free plan | No free plan listed | No free plan listed |
| Cheapest paid plan | Workforce Now price not published | Basic; price not published |
| Price per seat | Not published | Not published |
| Cost for five | Quote required | Quote required |
| Setup effort | Not published; ask for onboarding details | Not published; ask for onboarding details |
| Learning curve | Not published | Not published |
| Small-team integrations | Not published | Not published |
| Support | Support details not published | Lists 7,600+ support and HR professionals |
ADP Workforce Now Choose ADP Workforce Now if
- Choose ADP Workforce Now if you need payroll and HR from a broad provider.
- Choose ADP Workforce Now if your team is midsize or growing.
- Choose ADP Workforce Now if a custom quote fits your buying process.
Paychex Choose Paychex if
- Choose Paychex if you have a small team or are self-employed.
- Choose Paychex if Basic payroll, tax filing, and year-end forms fit.
- Choose Paychex if listed access to support and HR professionals matters.
02What each costs a small team
Neither vendor lists a free plan, and neither publishes a starting price or per-seat rate. Trial availability also isn’t published, so ask before treating a demo or quote as a trial.
For one person, Paychex lists Basic for essential payroll and HR, including payroll tax filing and W-2 and 1099 year-end processing; the monthly price is quote-only. ADP’s homepage doesn’t specifically describe Workforce Now or list its price. A low-confidence pricing listing names Select, Plus, and Premium, but publishes no rates or seat limits. Confirm which, if any, applies to your business.
For three to five people, neither vendor provides a published total. Request an itemized quote for your exact headcount, including setup, tax services, add-ons, and any minimum fees. Don’t compare a headline quote without checking those costs.
03Setup and day-to-day use
Neither vendor publishes a time-to-launch estimate or a small-team setup checklist, so we can’t give a reliable number of hours or days. Before signing, ask who handles payroll and employee-data setup, what information you must provide, whether onboarding costs extra, and how support works during your first payroll run.
For either product, a small team should clarify who will configure pay schedules, employee records, tax details, time tracking, and benefits. The available descriptions don’t establish which tasks are self-serve or handled by the vendor. Paychex lists digital tools and advisory support; ADP lists payroll and HR solutions across business sizes. Those descriptions don’t tell us how much day-to-day administration falls on your team.
Learning curve details aren’t published for either option. Ask for a walkthrough of the tasks your one payroll administrator will do each pay period, plus any employee steps for viewing pay or submitting information.
04What you get on the cheaper plans
Paychex’s listed Basic plan covers unlimited payroll processing, employee pay options, payroll tax filing, and W-2 and 1099 year-end processing. The vendor also describes online payroll with automated tax administration. Its Foundations plan adds AI and HR features, but prices for both plans are not published. Ask whether those features are included in your quote or cost extra.
ADP’s homepage lists payroll and HR solutions for small, midsized, and large businesses, but it doesn’t specifically map those features to Workforce Now plans. Its broader offerings include time and attendance for small and midsized businesses, and benefits administration for midsized and large businesses. The listed Select, Plus, and Premium prices and seat limits aren’t published, so confirm what a small team can actually buy.
Paychex also lists time tracking, benefits, and HR services, but add-on prices aren’t published. For either vendor, get the needed features, support, and any add-on costs in writing before comparing plan names.
Questions people ask
Which one is better, ADP or Paychex?
For a small team, Paychex is the more natural starting point because it serves self-employed owners and small businesses and lists a Basic payroll plan. ADP offers broad payroll and HR solutions, but confirm Workforce Now is suitable for your headcount. Neither publishes pricing, so compare written quotes.
What is the Paychex controversy?
We can’t identify a specific controversy from the available vendor details. The term may refer to different complaints or events, so check the date, claim, and source before relying on it. For a buying decision, review current regulatory records and recent customer complaints, and ask Paychex about concerns relevant to your contract.
Is there a difference between ADP and ADP Workforce Now?
ADP is the provider, with payroll and HR solutions across business sizes. Workforce Now is the product name in this comparison, but ADP’s homepage doesn’t specifically describe it. Ask ADP which features, employee-size range, and pricing apply to Workforce Now rather than assuming every ADP service is included.
Who is Paychex’s biggest competitor?
ADP is a direct alternative for payroll and HR in this comparison, but we can’t establish that it is Paychex’s biggest competitor. The answer depends on the service and customer size being compared. For a small-team shortlist, compare both vendors’ written quotes, included payroll services, support, and add-on costs.