We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never changes a score or a ranking. How we make money
A team of 1–10 may not need Paychex’s full payroll and HR coverage, especially if the price or setup feels like too much. Paychex doesn’t publish a starting price, so you’ll need a quote to compare costs. For straightforward payroll, look at SurePayroll or QuickBooks Online Payroll; for payroll plus HR, consider Gusto or Justworks. These vendors don’t publish enough setup detail to predict the work involved, so ask about migration and onboarding before you commit.
01Why people leave Paychex
The price is hard to assess
Paychex pricing starts at n/a, so small teams need a quote before they can judge whether the cost fits.
Payroll problems can cost time
One Reddit thread reports missing information, incorrect withholdings and payment withdrawals that took days to reverse.
The service may feel like too much
A small team with straightforward payroll may prefer a narrower option; one Reddit commenter suggested a local payroll service.
02The alternatives, ranked by fit
- Straightforward payroll
SurePayrollSurePayrollSurePayroll is worth comparing if your team mainly needs payroll and automatic tax filing. Its listed starting price is $20, below the $49 starting price listed for Gusto. That is a starting figure, not a confirmed total for several employees. Ask for the price for your headcount and what migration or setup help is included; setup effort isn’t published.
Trade-off: Confirm the monthly total and tax-filing details for your situation.
7.0/10from
$20/mo - QuickBooks teams
QuickBooks Online PayrollQuickBooks Online PayrollIf your books already run through QuickBooks, this option combines payroll tax filing with time tracking. The pricing page lists a $25 starting price, but the actual total for a few employees isn’t published here. Ask for a quote based on your roster and whether help moving payroll data is included; setup effort isn’t published.
Trade-off: The base fee can make a small roster cost more.
6.2/10from
$25/mo - Payroll plus HR
GustoGustoGusto combines payroll and HR and supports teams paying employees and contractors. Its listed starting price is $49, so compare the full bill for your headcount rather than treating that as the total. Ask about onboarding and support before switching: setup effort isn’t published, and Reddit users report uneven support experiences.
Trade-off: Budget for the base fee, seats and possible support frustrations.
6.8/10from
$49/mo - Benefits and HR
JustworksJustworksJustworks may suit a small team that wants payroll, HR and benefits administration together, plus expert support. Its listed starting price is $8, but the total for your team and benefits can change the calculation. Ask for a quote that includes your headcount and benefits, and confirm the migration and onboarding steps.
Trade-off: The base fee and benefit renewals need close review.
6.5/10from
$8/mo - Payroll and HR tools
PaycomPaycomPaycom brings payroll and HR together and includes employee self-service. It may be a fit if those tools matter more than seeing a price online, but the vendor doesn’t publish a starting price. Request a quote for your team size and ask what setup requires; without that, a small team can’t easily compare its total cost.
Trade-off: You’ll need a quote to judge affordability.
5.3/10from
Custom - Free pay-access perk
ZayZoonZayZoonZayZoon lists $0 monthly pricing for employers and offers pay access and perks for deskless teams. It is not a replacement for payroll software, so consider it only as an added employee benefit alongside a payroll provider. Ask about fees and paycheck deductions before offering it; those can affect the value to workers.
Trade-off: It adds a benefit; it does not run payroll.
6.2/10from
Freefree plan
03Side by side
| Tool | Score | From | Free plan | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 5.0 | Custom | No | Teams wanting payroll and HR together | |
| 7.0 | $20/mo | No | Small businesses with straightforward payroll | |
| 6.2 | $25/mo | No | Small teams already using QuickBooks | |
| 6.8 | $49/mo | No | Small teams running one-state payroll | |
| 6.5 | $8/mo | No | Small teams consolidating payroll and HR | |
| 5.3 | Custom | No | Teams wanting payroll and HR together | |
| 6.2 | Free | Yes | Deskless teams offering employee benefits |
Questions people ask
Which Paychex alternative is cheapest for a small team?
Among the listed starting prices for payroll options here, SurePayroll starts at $20, QuickBooks Online Payroll at $25 and Gusto at $49. Those figures don’t establish the total for your employees. Ask each vendor for a quote based on your roster and required services.
Is there a free Paychex alternative?
ZayZoon lists $0 monthly pricing for employers, but it offers pay access and perks rather than payroll processing. DailyPay also lists a $0 standard option, but depends on employer setup. Treat these as potential benefits alongside payroll software, not as a full payroll replacement.
What should a small team ask before switching from Paychex?
Ask for the total monthly price at your headcount, what tax filing and HR services are included, and whether onboarding or migration help costs extra. Also confirm the setup steps and support options. The vendors don’t publish enough setup detail to estimate the effort in advance.
