We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never changes a score or a ranking. How we make money
Most buyers should pick SurePayroll.
For most teams with 1–10 people, we’d start with SurePayroll: its listed plans cover payroll, and Full Service files and deposits payroll taxes. A five-person team’s listed monthly total works out to $40 for No Tax Filing or $64 for Full Service, before conflicting alternate prices. ADP Workforce Now lists broader payroll and HR offerings, but its pricing and setup effort aren’t published. Get an ADP quote if you need its wider workforce capabilities and can confirm the total cost.
01Side by side
| ADP Workforce Now | SurePayroll | |
|---|---|---|
| Free plan | No free plan listed | No free plan listed |
| Cheapest paid plan | Price not published | $20 listed base; alternate listing says $29 |
| Price per seat | Not published; ask for a quote | Base plus $4 or $7 per employee |
| Cost for five | Not published | $40 No Tax; $64 Full Service, before conflicts |
| Setup effort | Not published | Not published |
| Learning curve | Not published | Not published |
| Small-team integrations | Not published | Accounting and timeclock integrations listed |
| Support | Not published | Customer support included |
ADP Workforce Now Choose ADP Workforce Now if
- Choose ADP Workforce Now if you need broader HR and workforce offerings.
- Choose ADP Workforce Now if your team needs time and attendance solutions.
- Choose ADP Workforce Now if you can get a quote before committing.
SurePayroll Choose SurePayroll if
- Choose SurePayroll if you want payroll for a small business.
- Choose SurePayroll if you want payroll taxes filed and deposited.
- Choose SurePayroll if you pay both W-2 employees and 1099 contractors.
02What each costs a small team
Neither vendor lists a free plan. ADP Workforce Now pricing isn’t published, so a one-person or five-person monthly total isn’t available; ask ADP for a quote. SurePayroll lists monthly plans, but its base prices conflict across listings, so confirm your price before signing up.
Using the $20 No Tax Filing base plus $4 per employee, one person works out to $24, three to $32, and five to $40 monthly. Full Service at a $29 base plus $7 per employee works out to $36, $50, and $64, respectively. Alternate listed bases of $29 and $39 would raise those totals. Annual plan pricing isn’t published. These calculations assume the per-employee fee applies to each person.
03Setup and day-to-day use
Neither vendor publishes a setup timeline in the available plan details, so we can’t promise that either will be ready in a particular number of days. ADP’s pricing page doesn’t spell out setup effort either. Ask for an onboarding estimate and what it includes before comparing quotes.
SurePayroll lets businesses run payroll online, schedule runs, and access payroll reports, paystubs, and history. Its setup requirements and learning curve aren’t published. Before choosing either product, ask what information you’ll need to provide, who configures payroll, and whether help is available during setup. For SurePayroll, confirm how it handles your tax jurisdictions and employee types. For ADP, ask which payroll and HR features are included in the quote, rather than assuming every listed solution comes with the plan.
04What you get on the cheaper plans
SurePayroll’s No Tax Filing plan lists unlimited payroll runs and customer support; the employer handles tax filing and deposits. Full Service adds automatic calculation, filing, and deposits for federal, state, and local payroll taxes, plus free two-day direct deposit. Both plans list per-employee fees. SurePayroll also supports W-2 employees and 1099 contractors. Its listed add-ons include accounting software integration for $4.99 per month and timeclock integration from $5 per month plus $3 per employee.
ADP lists payroll and HR solutions across business sizes. Its homepage also names time and attendance for small and midsized businesses, and workforce management for large businesses. But those broad offerings don’t tell a small buyer which features are included in a particular Workforce Now plan. Ask ADP to itemize the features and any add-on costs in your quote.
Questions people ask
Does either product offer a free plan?
Neither product has a free plan listed. SurePayroll’s monthly plans start at a listed $20 base for No Tax Filing, plus $4 per employee, though another listing shows a $29 base. ADP doesn’t publish Workforce Now pricing, so ask for a quote rather than assuming a free or low-cost tier.
How much is SurePayroll for five people?
At the listed $20 base plus $4 per employee, No Tax Filing works out to $40 per month for five people. Full Service at $29 plus $7 per employee works out to $64. Alternate listed base prices would make the totals higher, so confirm the current price with SurePayroll.
Can SurePayroll pay contractors?
SurePayroll lists support for W-2 employees and 1099 contractors. Its listed plans include unlimited payroll runs, and Full Service includes payroll tax filing and deposits. The pricing also lists a $50 annual base fee plus $5 per form for W-2 and 1099-NEC forms; confirm which forms your team needs.
When should a small team choose ADP Workforce Now?
Consider ADP if your team needs more than basic payroll: ADP lists HR solutions across business sizes, along with time and attendance for small and midsized businesses. Its Workforce Now pricing and setup effort aren’t published, so get a written quote that spells out included features and total costs first.