We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never changes a score or a ranking. How we make money
The bottom line
Worth a look for small payrolls that want tax filing, but confirm your monthly price first.
A team with a few employees or household workers may not need a bigger payroll platform. SurePayroll covers payroll runs, tax filing on Full Service, direct deposit, and online records; there is no free plan to test first.
The listed entry price is $20 per month plus $4 per employee for No Tax Filing, or $29 plus $7 per employee for Full Service. The pricing also shows alternate prices, so confirm the total with SurePayroll before choosing. Reddit reports range from smooth paydays to serious complaints about account access and year-end forms.
Good fit if
- Small businesses with straightforward payroll
- Households paying an in-home employee
- Teams wanting automatic tax filing
Skip it if
- Teams needing a free payroll tool
- Businesses needing extensive HR features
- Owners who need published setup timelines

ScoresHow it rates
What works
- Unlimited payroll runs, including off-cycle runs
- Full Service files and deposits payroll taxes
- Free 2-day direct deposit on listed plans
- Supports W-2 employees and 1099 contractors
- Online reports and payroll records available 24/7
What doesn't
- No free plan or published free trial
- Per-employee fees add up as teams grow
- Pricing page lists two prices for each core plan
- Local tax areas may carry a separate fee
- Some Reddit users report account and document problems
01Who SurePayroll is for
SurePayroll is aimed at small businesses, household employers, and people paying themselves or contractors. For a team of one to ten, it can handle the regular job of paying workers, calculating payroll taxes, and keeping pay records online. Full Service is the fit if you want the provider to file and deposit federal, state, and local payroll taxes. No Tax Filing leaves those tasks with the employer.
The core plans charge a monthly base price plus a fee per employee, so the cost depends on both the plan and headcount. That can suit a small team with predictable payroll, especially one that values tax handling over a larger bundle of HR tools. Household employers can also consider the separate Nanny & Household Payroll plan, which lists one employee in its price. If you need broader employee management, time tracking, or a more complex workflow, compare those needs before signing up; the listed integrations are paid add-ons.
02SurePayroll free plan and trial
SurePayroll has no free plan, and a free trial is not listed. That means you cannot use a free tier to run payroll for a small team before paying. The cheapest listed option is No Tax Filing at $20 per month plus $4 per employee. It includes unlimited payroll runs and customer support, but the employer handles tax filing and deposits.
For a team that wants SurePayroll to take care of taxes, Full Service is the relevant plan, listed at $29 per month plus $7 per employee. The pricing page also lists alternate prices for both plans, so confirm which amount applies before enrolling. Plans are billed monthly and can be canceled anytime. The vendor does not publish annual plan pricing.
03What a small team pays for SurePayroll
The listed No Tax Filing price is $20 per month plus $4 per employee. Using that rate, one employee costs $24 monthly, three cost $32, and five cost $40. Full Service is listed at $29 plus $7 per employee, which works out to $36 for one, $50 for three, and $64 for five. These are monthly totals, before any add-ons; annual plan pricing is not published.
There is a pricing wrinkle: the page also lists No Tax Filing at $29 plus $4 per employee and Full Service at $39 plus $7 per employee. At those alternate rates, three employees would cost $41 or $60 monthly, respectively. Ask SurePayroll which listed price applies to your account.
Potential extras include multi-state payroll at $9.99 per month, with the first state included; a separate fee may apply to local tax areas. W-2 and 1099-NEC forms cost $50 annually plus $5 per form. Accounting software integration is $4.99 per month, and timeclock integration starts at $5 per month plus $3 per employee.
04Getting started with SurePayroll
SurePayroll is online payroll software, with reports, paystubs, and payroll history available online around the clock. The pricing and feature details do not give a setup-time estimate or spell out each onboarding step, so ask the vendor how long setup will take for your state, worker types, and tax situation. The vendor also does not publish a learning-curve rating.
For day one, decide whether you want to file taxes yourself or pay for Full Service, and check whether you need to pay W-2 employees, 1099 contractors, or both. The listed plans support W-2 and 1099 workers, and Full Service handles payroll tax filing and deposits. If you need accounting or timeclock connections, budget for the listed paid integrations rather than assuming they are included. Reddit users describe both regular direct-deposit paydays and account access trouble, so confirm how workers and administrators will access the system before moving an active payroll.
05When small teams outgrow SurePayroll
The first pressure point is cost: each added employee brings a $4 monthly fee on No Tax Filing or $7 on Full Service, at the listed prices. Teams operating across states may add $9.99 per month for multi-state payroll, and local tax areas can have a separate fee. The listed product details focus on payroll, taxes, records, and integrations; teams needing a wider HR or operations system should check whether SurePayroll covers those workflows before they grow into them.
User accounts on Reddit are mixed. One commenter says they have received weekly direct deposit without issues, while other commenters describe trouble getting tax documents after ending service and problems involving reseller payments. Those reports are individual experiences, not a guarantee of what will happen to your business. Still, they make offboarding and year-end records worth asking about before switching. A team with more complex payroll, support needs, or administrative workflows may want to compare providers before headcount and add-on costs rise.
From the threadsWhat users say
Reddit sentiment is mixed: some commenters report dependable direct deposits and a smooth experience, while others describe serious issues with account access, tax documents, or reseller payments. These are individual accounts, so we would verify offboarding and support procedures with SurePayroll.
I love gusto and Onpay but their pricing is more expensive than SurePayroll (from what I’ve seen)
I get paid via sure payroll, and get paid weekly through direct deposit. There was no lag period, and I get paid each Friday for the current week
They won't give you tax documents if you end your membership with them before the year ends
Despite numerous calls, emails, and completed documentation they have not paid our monthly revenue share in 4 MONTHS!
Questions people ask
Is SurePayroll a legitimate payroll service?
SurePayroll is online payroll software for small businesses and household employers. Its listed features include payroll runs, online records, and tax filing on Full Service. Reddit users report different experiences, so ask the vendor about support, access, and tax-document handling before choosing it.
Does SurePayroll file payroll taxes?
Full Service calculates, files, and deposits federal, state, and local payroll taxes. No Tax Filing does not: the employer is responsible for filing and deposits. Check the plan and any local tax fees that apply to your business.
Can SurePayroll pay 1099 contractors?
The listed plans support W-2 employees and 1099 contractors. Year-end W-2 and 1099-NEC forms are listed as a separate charge: $50 annual base fee plus $5 per form. Confirm which forms and charges apply to your account.
Does SurePayroll offer direct deposit?
The Full Service plan includes free 2-day direct deposit, and the Nanny & Household Payroll plan also lists free 2-day direct deposit. A Reddit commenter says they receive weekly direct deposit, but your pay schedule depends on how payroll is set up.
Can I cancel SurePayroll monthly?
SurePayroll lists its plans as monthly billing with cancellation anytime. Before leaving, ask how you can access payroll records and year-end forms after cancellation. Some Reddit commenters report problems retrieving tax documents after ending service.
