review galore

Head-to-head · Payroll tools

ADP Workforce Now vs When I Work

When I Work has a clear starting price for hourly scheduling. ADP offers broader payroll and HR solutions, but its Workforce Now pricing isn’t published.

ADP Workforce Now

5.2/10
VS

When I Work

6.2/10

We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never changes a score or a ranking. How we make money

Short answer

Most buyers should pick When I Work.

For most 1–10-person teams, When I Work is the easier budget choice if you mainly need hourly scheduling: Essentials is $2.50 per user monthly, with a 14-day trial and no free plan. Its time-tracking add-on costs extra, but the price isn’t published. ADP is the better fit if you need payroll and broader HR solutions, but ADP doesn’t publish Workforce Now pricing or setup effort, making it hard to budget for a very small team.

01Side by side

ADP Workforce NowWhen I Work
Free accessNo free plan; trial not publishedNo free plan; 14-day trial
Cheapest paid planPrice not publishedEssentials: $2.50 per user monthly
Price per seatNot published$2.50 monthly for Essentials
Cost for fiveNot published; request a quote$12.50 monthly, before add-ons
Setup effortSetup time not publishedSetup time not published
Learning curveEase-of-use score: 4/10Ease-of-use score: 6/10
IntegrationsDetails not publishedDetails not published
SupportSupport score: 5/10Support score: 4/10

Choose ADP Workforce Now if

  • Choose ADP Workforce Now if payroll and broader HR solutions matter most.
  • Choose ADP Workforce Now if you’re prepared to request a custom quote.
  • Choose ADP Workforce Now if your needs extend beyond hourly scheduling.

Choose When I Work if

  • Choose When I Work if you need affordable scheduling for hourly staff.
  • Choose When I Work if you want a published per-user starting price.
  • Choose When I Work if shift messaging and schedule templates are priorities.

02What each costs a small team

Neither product has a free plan. When I Work offers a 14-day trial; ADP’s trial terms aren’t published. When I Work Essentials is $2.50 per user per month, so one person costs $2.50 monthly, three cost $7.50, and five cost $12.50 before add-ons. The vendor offers annual billing too, but doesn’t publish annual prices. Time Tracking & Attendance is an add-on with an unpublished price.

ADP doesn’t publish Workforce Now pricing or seat limits, so we can’t calculate a one-person or three-to-five-person bill. Available plan listings name Select, Plus, and Premium, but don’t list their prices. Ask ADP for a quote covering your headcount and required services. For a small team watching each subscription, When I Work is the only option here with a clear monthly starting price.

03Setup and day-to-day use

Neither vendor publishes a setup-time estimate, so ask about onboarding before you commit. With ADP, confirm what setup help comes with your quote and how payroll and HR needs affect the work involved. ADP lists payroll and HR solutions, but doesn’t detail Workforce Now setup on its homepage.

When I Work Essentials includes schedule templates, multi-week and multi-location scheduling, auto scheduling, and team messaging. A small team will need to set up schedules and decide how to handle messages and shift coverage. Pro adds scheduling rules and role permissions if you need more control. The ease-of-use scores are 4/10 for ADP and 6/10 for When I Work. Those scores offer a comparison, not a promise about your team’s learning curve; ask for a product walkthrough if setup complexity could affect your choice.

04What you get on the cheaper plans

ADP lists payroll and HR solutions across business sizes, plus time and attendance for small and midsized businesses. Its homepage doesn’t describe Workforce Now’s cheapest plan or say which of those services are included at a particular price. Ask ADP to spell out the modules in your quote rather than assuming every listed solution comes with one plan.

When I Work’s Essentials plan covers scheduling, schedule templates, multi-week and multi-location schedules, auto scheduling, and team messaging. It also lets employees receive shift notifications and communicate without sharing phone numbers. Time tracking and attendance are a separately priced add-on, and its price isn’t published. Pro adds scheduling rules, role permissions, custom reporting, and time-zone toggles. Premium adds API key access, webhooks, and SAML/SSO. For a small hourly team, Essentials is the lowest-priced starting point; check the add-on cost if tracking hours is essential.

Questions people ask

What’s the difference between ADP and ADP Workforce Now?

ADP is the provider; Workforce Now is the product named in this comparison. ADP’s homepage describes its broader payroll, HR, and workforce solutions, but doesn’t detail Workforce Now. Ask ADP which services, employee range, and support are included in the specific quote you receive.

What are the benefits of using ADP Workforce Now?

ADP lists payroll and HR solutions for small, midsized, and large businesses. It also lists time and attendance for small and midsized businesses, and benefits administration for midsized and large businesses. Ask ADP which of these solutions are included in your Workforce Now quote.

What are the key differences between ADP Workforce Now and Workforce Manager?

Ask ADP to compare the two products against your needs, including payroll, time and attendance, workforce management, employee limits, and price. The product names alone aren’t enough to confirm which features overlap or which one fits a small team.

Who uses ADP Workforce Now?

Available pricing listings generally target midsize-to-enterprise organizations, roughly 50 to 999+ employees, but prices and seat limits aren’t published. ADP also describes payroll and HR solutions for businesses of different sizes. Ask ADP whether Workforce Now fits your headcount and required services.