We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never changes a score or a ranking. How we make money
It's a split decision.
For a solo publisher who wants free newsletters, podcasts, or video, Substack is the cheaper pick: it lists no monthly platform fee and unlimited subscribers. beehiiv is a better fit if your small team needs a no-code site, automations, A/B testing, or built-in monetization. Its free plan has one seat; a team of five needs Pro at $95 per month when billed yearly. Substack seat costs aren't published, so check how a shared workflow would work before choosing.
01Side by side
| beehiiv | Substack | |
|---|---|---|
| Free plan | 2,500 subscribers, one seat, unlimited email sends | Unlimited subscribers, sends, posts, and media |
| Cheapest paid option | Lite: $49/month, billed yearly | No monthly platform fee; paid subscriptions incur fees |
| Price per seat | Lite: $24.50 per seat at two seats | Seat costs aren't published |
| Cost for a team of five | Pro: $95/month billed yearly; up to 10 seats | $0 platform fee; seat costs aren't published |
| Setup effort | No-code website builder and drag-and-drop email editor | Publishing tools for writing, podcasts, and video |
| Learning curve | More tools to configure for growth and monetization | A narrower publishing and subscription toolkit |
| Small-team integrations | MCP read access on Free; write access on Lite | Stripe processing for paid subscriptions |
| Support | 24/7 priority support on Pro | Support details aren't published |
beehiiv Choose beehiiv if
- Choose beehiiv if your team needs more than a basic publishing setup.
- Choose beehiiv if you want automations and A/B testing on Lite.
- Choose beehiiv if you need five seats under one publication account.
Substack Choose Substack if
- Choose Substack if you want free publishing with unlimited subscribers.
- Choose Substack if you plan to earn through paid subscriptions.
- Choose Substack if free newsletters, podcasts, or video cover your needs.
02What each costs a small team
Substack lists no monthly platform fee, with unlimited subscribers, sending, and posts. beehiiv's Free plan costs $0 and covers up to 2,500 subscribers, one seat, and unlimited sends. For one person who wants paid beehiiv features, Lite is $49 per month when billed yearly; it includes two seats. That works out to $24.50 per seat at full capacity.
A beehiiv team of three to five needs Pro, listed at $95 per month when billed yearly, with up to 10 seats. Substack doesn't publish seat costs, so its $0 platform fee doesn't tell you whether a five-person team can share the account as needed. For paid Substack subscriptions, the platform takes 10% of revenue, plus Stripe processing fees. beehiiv lists a 2.9% + $0.30 Stripe fee on paid subscriptions and digital products.
03Setup and day-to-day use
Neither vendor publishes a setup-time estimate, so we wouldn't promise you can be up and running in a particular number of hours. beehiiv gives you a drag-and-drop email editor and a no-code website builder. A small team will need to set up its publication and decide who needs a seat; the Free plan allows one seat, Lite two, and Pro 10.
Substack's listed tools focus on publishing, subscriptions, mailing lists, and discussions, with newsletters, podcasts, and video available at no platform fee. That narrower scope may mean fewer choices to configure if publishing is all you need. beehiiv has more growth and monetization features to learn, including automations on Lite. For either product, agree on who publishes, who manages paid subscriptions, and how the team handles reader discussions before inviting collaborators. Substack doesn't publish seat limits or seat costs.
04What you get on the cheaper plans
beehiiv Free includes up to 2,500 subscribers, one team seat, one publication, a 30-day analytics lookback, unlimited email sends, and a no-code website builder. Lite raises the limits to 100,000 subscribers, two seats, and three publications, with a 12-month analytics lookback. It also includes automations, A/B testing, and beehiiv MCP; the pricing page lists ad network access from Lite. Paid subscriptions have a 0% beehiiv take rate on Lite, but Stripe processing fees still apply.
Substack's free platform allows unlimited subscribers, sending, and posts, and includes free newsletters, podcasts, and video. It also offers discussions and paid subscriptions. For paid subscriptions, Substack takes 10% of revenue, alongside Stripe fees. The lower-cost beehiiv plans don't include Pro's 10 seats, unlimited analytics lookback, or removal of beehiiv branding. Substack doesn't publish seat costs, so ask the vendor about team access before planning a shared workflow.
Questions people ask
Is Substack worth using?
It can be a good fit if you want free publishing and unlimited subscribers without a monthly platform fee. If you charge for subscriptions, Substack takes 10% of revenue, plus Stripe processing fees. A team should also ask about seat access, since Substack doesn't publish seat costs.
What topics are most popular on Substack?
Substack doesn't publish a definitive list of its most popular topics in the details available here. The platform supports written work, newsletters, podcasts, and video, but that doesn't establish which subjects attract the largest audiences. Check Substack's current discovery pages if topic popularity will guide your choice.
What compares to Substack?
beehiiv is one alternative for newsletter publishers who want a website builder, audience-growth features, automations, and monetization tools. Its Free plan is limited to 2,500 subscribers and one seat; Lite starts at $49 per month when billed yearly. Substack offers a $0 monthly platform fee and unlimited subscribers.
Is Substack a blog?
Substack can be used to publish written work for readers and subscribers, so it can serve a blog-like purpose. It also supports newsletters, podcasts, video, paid subscriptions, and discussions. Unlike a simple publishing-only setup, it connects posts with mailing-list and subscription features.