We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never changes a score or a ranking. How we make money
The bottom line
Free publishing and an owned mailing list are appealing; paid subscriptions bring transaction costs.
A small team that wants to publish newsletters, build a mailing list, and try paid subscriptions can start on Substack for $0 per month. The free platform includes unlimited subscribers, posts, and sending, and you retain ownership of your mailing list and intellectual property.
The trade-off is that paid subscriptions cost 10% of subscription revenue, plus payment processing fees. Reddit users praise the easy publishing setup, while some find the social feed noisy or inauthentic. Substack fits best when publishing is the main job and the team is comfortable with its platform.
Good fit if
- Writers building a newsletter audience
- Small teams testing paid publishing
- Creators who want simple publishing
Skip it if
- Teams needing published seat pricing
- Creators avoiding platform social feeds
- Businesses needing custom integrations

ScoresHow it rates
What works
- Free platform lists unlimited subscribers
- Unlimited sending and posts on the free platform
- Free newsletters, podcasts, and video
- Mailing list and intellectual property stay yours
- Paid subscriptions are available
What doesn't
- Substack takes 10% of subscription revenue
- US card processing adds transaction fees
- Custom domain costs $50 one-time
- Seat costs are not published
- Some Reddit users dislike the social feed
01Who Substack is for
Substack is for a solo writer or a small team of up to 10 people that wants to publish and build a mailing list without paying a monthly platform fee. It combines publishing with email delivery, so a team can send free work, offer paid subscriptions, and take part in discussions with readers and creators.
The free platform lists unlimited subscribers, posts, and sending, making it a practical place to test whether readers will pay. Substack says publishers retain ownership of their mailing list and intellectual property, and have editorial control. A Reddit commenter describes it as a blog and newsletter in one, while another says it makes subscriber setup and paid subscriptions easier than running a self-hosted blog. It is less compelling if your main goal is a standalone website or you want to avoid Substack’s social features. Team seat pricing and any seat limits are not published.
02Substack free plan and trial
Substack’s free platform has no monthly price, and a plan name is not published. The pricing page lists unlimited subscribers, unlimited sending and posts, and free newsletters, podcasts, and video. The platform also says publishers retain ownership of their mailing list and intellectual property.
There is no free trial listed because the platform itself is free to use; a trial offer is not published. The main cost begins when you charge for subscriptions: Substack takes 10% of subscription revenue, and Stripe processing fees apply. A custom domain is a separate $50 one-time charge. Substack does not publish a subscriber cap or seat price for this free offering, so ask the vendor if your team needs a specific account setup.
03What a small team pays for Substack
The pricing page lists the Free platform (plan name not published) at $0 per month. That makes the platform cost $0 per month for one person, three people, or five people, based on the published price. Substack does not publish a seat charge, a seat minimum, or an annual platform price, so we can’t confirm whether those team setups have additional account costs. The published monthly platform fee works out to $0 per year, but an annual platform fee is not published.
Paid subscriptions change the math. Substack takes 10% of subscription revenue. Stripe processing for US card payments is typically 2.9% plus $0.30 per transaction, with a 0.7% recurring billing fee. A $50 one-time custom-domain charge is optional. For example, the exact fee on a paid subscription depends on its price and billing frequency, so there isn’t one fixed team total to quote. Ask about account access and any team-specific costs before relying on it for a multi-person publishing workflow.
04Getting started with Substack
The basic job is clear: publish writing or other media, build a mailing list, and optionally charge subscribers. That should be a lighter setup than arranging separate website hosting and newsletter delivery; a Reddit commenter says Substack makes mailing lists and paid subscriptions easier than setting up a blog independently. Another says it works best as a simple publishing and newsletter platform, rather than as a social network.
Substack does not publish setup time or team-seat costs in the published pricing details. Integration options and a list of day-one integrations are also not published, so check with Substack if your workflow depends on connecting another tool. For a small team, the first decisions are likely to be who publishes, whether posts are free or paid, and whether to buy the $50 custom domain. The platform lists unlimited sending and posts on its free offering.
05When small teams outgrow Substack
The free platform does not list a subscriber, post, or sending cap, so audience size alone may not force an upgrade. The pressure is more likely to come from paid-subscription fees, account needs, or a desire for more control over the publishing experience. Substack takes 10% of subscription revenue, on top of Stripe processing fees. Seat pricing and an annual platform fee are not published, which can make budgeting harder as more teammates need access.
Reddit feedback points to another possible mismatch: some writers say the Notes feed feels crowded or performative, while others recommend treating Substack as a publishing and newsletter tool and bringing readers from elsewhere. If your team needs a standalone blog, specific integrations, or clear multi-user pricing, confirm those needs with Substack before committing. A Reddit commenter says they publish on WordPress and mirror work on Substack, one option for teams that want a separate website too.
From the threadsWhat users say
Reddit sentiment is mixed. Some writers value the simple publishing and newsletter setup; others criticize the feed’s feel and say audience growth may come from elsewhere.
Substack makes setting up mailing lists, paid subscription and analytics much easier
It’s a great platform as a writer and has everything you need to publish things simply
Lots of copy/paste Notes stacked on top of each other
You have to curate your experience. You have to find your people
Questions people ask
Is Substack worth using?
It can be worth using if your small team wants to publish newsletters and build a mailing list without a monthly platform fee. The free platform lists unlimited subscribers, posts, and sending. If you charge readers, budget for Substack’s 10% share of subscription revenue and Stripe processing fees.
Does Substack have a comment section?
Substack offers discussion features for readers and creators. The vendor's site does not specify how comments work on individual posts or whether every post supports them, so check the current product details if comment settings are important to your publication.
Can a small team use Substack for free?
The free platform is listed at $0 per month and includes unlimited subscribers, sending, and posts, plus free newsletters, podcasts, and video. Substack does not publish seat pricing, so confirm how team access works before planning around multiple staff accounts.
What does Substack charge for paid subscriptions?
Substack takes 10% of subscription revenue. For US card payments, Stripe processing is typically 2.9% plus $0.30 per transaction, with a 0.7% recurring billing fee. The exact amount depends on the subscription price and payment details.
Do you own your mailing list and writing on Substack?
Substack says publishers retain ownership of their mailing list and intellectual property, along with editorial control. If your team has specific export, access, or rights requirements, confirm the details directly with Substack before publishing.
Sources
- Substack homepage
- Substack pricing, compiled via web search from smarttoolspick.com, substack.com, amysuto.com, niusleters.com
- Reddit: If substack is so popular why don’t people just go back to blogging
- Reddit: Substack Is So Inauthentic
- Reddit: Substack is not what I thought it would be.
- Reddit: I want to start a substack account but everyone here is shitting on it. Should I still do it or are there better alternatives of what I want?
