We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never changes a score or a ranking. How we make money
Most buyers should pick OnPay.
For a small team choosing between these two, OnPay is the practical pick if the need is payroll: its listed plan starts at $49 monthly plus $6 per worker, with a one-month trial. BlackLine is for finance teams automating close, intercompany work, or invoice-to-cash—not payroll—and sells on a custom quote. Neither has a free plan. If you need BlackLine’s finance workflows, ask sales for a small-team quote; the price gap cannot be compared from public rates.
01Side by side
| BlackLine | OnPay | |
|---|---|---|
| Free plan | No free plan listed | No free plan; one-month trial |
| Cheapest paid plan | Custom quote; price not published | Payroll Essentials: $49 + $6 per worker |
| Price per seat | Per-seat rate not published | $6 per worker, plus $49 base |
| Cost for five | Not published; request a quote | $79/month for five workers |
| Setup effort | Timeline and effort not published | Free data migration; timeline not published |
| Learning curve | Not published | Not published |
| Small-team integrations | Finance data integration and workflow orchestration | Accounting, 401(k), HR, and compliance tools |
| Support | Support channels not published | Live HR guidance by phone, chat, email |
BlackLine Choose BlackLine if
- Choose BlackLine if you need to automate financial close work.
- Choose BlackLine if intercompany matching and compliance are priorities.
- Choose BlackLine if invoice-to-cash automation is in scope.
OnPay Choose OnPay if
- Choose OnPay if your main need is payroll and tax filings.
- Choose OnPay if you need a published per-worker price.
- Choose OnPay if you want optional HR, benefits, or time tracking.
02What each costs a small team
Neither vendor lists a free plan. OnPay offers a one-month free trial; BlackLine does not publish whether a trial is available. For OnPay, the pricing page lists Payroll Essentials at $49 per month plus $6 per worker. That puts one worker at $55 monthly, three at $67, and five at $79, before optional add-ons. The plan includes unlimited pay runs, tax filings, W-2s, 1099s, and year-end filings.
BlackLine has no public starting price: pricing is custom and quote-based through sales demos, and monthly or annual terms aren't published. We can't calculate a one-person or five-person cost for BlackLine. Ask sales for a quote that spells out the included products, costs, and billing terms. For a budget-conscious team that simply needs payroll, OnPay is the only one with a price to plan around.
03Setup and day-to-day use
Neither vendor publishes a standard setup timeline, so don't assume a particular go-live date. OnPay says it provides free data migration for businesses switching providers, but that isn't a promise that every payroll setup takes a set number of days. A small team will need to gather worker and pay details and configure tax filing, pay schedules, and any selected add-ons.
BlackLine's sales-demo, quote-based process means first confirming which finance workflows are in scope: close, reconciliations, intercompany, or invoice-to-cash. Studio360 is described as integrating data and orchestrating workflows, so ask what data sources and governance configuration are needed. Implementation hours and ease-of-use details aren't published for either product. Compare the people-hours and services each vendor includes in its proposal.
04What you get on the cheaper plans
OnPay's least expensive listed plan, Payroll Essentials, covers core payroll: unlimited pay runs and schedules, federal, state, and local tax filings, W-2s, 1099s, year-end filings, and paying workers in any number of states. The service also advertises automated calculations and payments. HR, time tracking, and benefits are separately priced options. HR starts at $15 base plus $2 per worker, and time tracking at $15 base plus $4 per worker. Benefits integration and administration are listed as free, but plan premiums cost extra.
BlackLine's public description covers close automation, journal entries, reconciliations, financial statements, intercompany matching and compliance, collections, remittance capture, and governance, with Studio360 and Verity AI. But BlackLine doesn't publish a low-cost tier or say which features come with a starter plan. Ask sales which products are included in a quote; don't assume every capability is bundled.
Questions people ask
Is OnPay a good payroll service?
OnPay looks like a fit for a small business that wants payroll, tax filings, and year-end forms in one listed package, with optional HR, time tracking, and benefits. Payroll Essentials starts at $49 monthly plus $6 per worker. Check whether the add-ons meet your needs before signing.
Who are BlackLine's main competitors?
BlackLine doesn't publish an official competitor list. Its stated scope is record-to-report and invoice-to-cash, so compare it with vendors that cover those finance workflows, not payroll platforms such as OnPay. Ask peers which alternatives fit your ERP and close process.
Which is better, Gusto or OnPay?
The right choice depends on the payroll features and price you need. OnPay lists Payroll Essentials at $49 monthly plus $6 per worker, with a one-month trial. Compare Gusto's current price, included filings, and add-on costs against those terms before deciding.
How much does OnPay payroll cost?
The pricing page lists Payroll Essentials at $49 per month plus $6 per worker. That comes to $55 monthly for one worker, $67 for three, or $79 for five, before add-ons. OnPay also offers a one-month free trial; its page doesn't publish an annual rate.