review galore

Head-to-head · Network security

Cisco Umbrella vs Rubrik Security Cloud

Choose by the risk you need to cover: unsafe internet access or data and identity recovery.

Cisco Umbrella

6.0/10
VS

Rubrik Security Cloud

5.4/10

We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never changes a score or a ranking. How we make money

Short answer

It's a split decision.

For a small team focused on DNS-layer security or safer internet access, Cisco Umbrella is the closer fit, and its listed plans include a 14-day trial. Rubrik Security Cloud is aimed at protecting and recovering data, identities, and AI agents. Neither vendor publishes prices, so we can’t say which costs less for one person or five. Ask for a quote based on your team and coverage needs.

01Side by side

Cisco UmbrellaRubrik Security Cloud
Free planNo free plan; listed plans include a 14-day trialNo free plan or published trial
Cheapest paid planDNS Security Essentials; price not publishedFoundation Edition; price not published
Price per seatNot publishedNot published
Cost for fiveNot published; request a quoteNot published; request a quote
Setup effortSetup steps and timing not publishedSetup steps and timing not published
Learning curveNot rated in the published reviewNot rated in the published review
Small-team integrationsSpecific integrations not publishedSpecific integrations not published
SupportReview score: 6/10Review score: 5/10

Choose Cisco Umbrella if

  • Choose Cisco Umbrella if DNS-layer security is your main need.
  • Choose Cisco Umbrella if you want to try a listed plan for 14 days.
  • Choose Cisco Umbrella if secure internet access matters more than recovery.

Choose Rubrik Security Cloud if

  • Choose Rubrik Security Cloud if data recovery is your priority.
  • Choose Rubrik Security Cloud if you need identity monitoring and recovery.
  • Choose Rubrik Security Cloud if AI-agent controls matter to your team.

02What each costs a small team

Neither vendor lists a free plan. Cisco Umbrella offers a 14-day free trial on its listed plans; Rubrik does not publish a free trial. At one person or a team of three to five, neither has a public price per seat or total. Umbrella lists DNS Security Essentials and Advantage, plus SIG Essentials and Advantage, but not monthly or annual prices. The pricing details name Rubrik's Foundation, Business, and Enterprise editions and quote-based pricing, with flexible fixed yearly installments mentioned for Foundation. They give no dollar figure to calculate a one-person subscription or five-seat bill. Umbrella also lists DNS Security for Education, licensed by faculty and staff with students included at no extra charge, but that does not establish pricing for ordinary small businesses. Ask both vendors for a written quote tied to users, protected devices, and required coverage.

03Setup and day-to-day use

Neither vendor publishes setup timing or a step-by-step estimate for a small team, so we wouldn’t budget this as a quick self-serve install without confirming the work first. Umbrella’s listed products cover DNS security and secure internet access. Ask Cisco what needs configuring for your users and devices, and whether your team needs help setting policies or testing access. Rubrik describes backups, clean recovery points, automated recovery, identity monitoring, and AI-agent controls. Ask Rubrik which sources must be connected, who manages recovery settings, and what routine checks your team owns. The public details don’t establish how difficult either product is to learn or how much ongoing administration is required. Get implementation scope, training, and support responsibilities in writing before comparing quotes.

04What you get on the cheaper plans

Umbrella’s listed entry options are DNS Security Essentials and SIG Essentials. Both include a 14-day trial, and SIG Essentials lists 500 file-inspection sandbox samples per day. SIG Advantage lists unlimited samples, while DNS Security Advantage is named as the advanced DNS option; the vendor does not publish a detailed feature comparison here. Cisco’s homepage describes broader security capabilities, but does not describe Umbrella by name, so don’t assume every homepage capability comes with an Umbrella plan. Rubrik lists Foundation, Business, and Enterprise editions, but does not publish which features belong to each tier. Its platform description includes immutable backups, clean recovery points, automated recovery, identity monitoring, sensitive-data discovery, and AI-agent controls. Treat those as platform-level capabilities, not a confirmed Foundation checklist. Ask each vendor to map the features you need to the lowest qualifying plan.

Questions people ask

Is Cisco Umbrella or Rubrik Security Cloud better for a small business?

They address different risks. Cisco Umbrella is the closer fit for a team seeking DNS-layer security or secure internet access. Rubrik Security Cloud focuses on protecting and recovering data, identities, and AI agents. Since neither publishes prices, get a quote for your specific team before choosing on budget.

Can a team of five use either product for free?

Neither vendor lists a free plan. Cisco Umbrella lists a 14-day free trial for its plans. Rubrik does not publish a free trial in its pricing details. A trial is not the same as an ongoing free plan, so ask about trial eligibility and what happens when it ends.

How much does Cisco Umbrella or Rubrik cost per user?

Neither vendor publishes a per-user price or a total for five people. Umbrella’s monthly and annual prices are not published. Rubrik uses quote-based pricing, and Foundation has flexible fixed yearly installments. Request a quote that specifies users, protected devices, billing term, and required edition.

Do Cisco Umbrella and Rubrik Security Cloud replace each other?

Not based on their described focus. Umbrella’s listed plans cover DNS security and secure internet access; Rubrik describes data, identity, and AI recovery controls. A team may need one or both depending on its risks. Ask vendors to clarify overlap and confirm which protections each quoted plan includes.