review galore

Head-to-head · Photo editing

Cleanup.pictures vs Magic Eraser

For simple team photo cleanup, Cleanup.pictures has clearer pricing. Magic Eraser adds headshots and team tools, but its photo-pack cost is unclear.

Cleanup.pictures

7.0/10
VS

Magic Eraser

6.3/10

We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never changes a score or a ranking. How we make money

Short answer

Most buyers should pick Cleanup.pictures.

For a small team that mainly removes objects, text, or blemishes, we’d pick Cleanup.pictures: its free plan allows unlimited images, and Pro costs $5 monthly for one user or $3 per month billed annually. Magic Eraser is worth considering if you also need AI headshots and team photo management. Its free plan lists 40 AI generations, but the vendor says Magic Eraser editing requires a photo pack, and doesn’t publish that pack’s price.

01Side by side

Cleanup.picturesMagic Eraser
Free planUnlimited images; exports capped at 720p40 AI generations; limited-resolution, watermarked downloads
Cheapest paid optionPro: $3/month billed annuallyPRO: $4.99/month billed annually
Price per seat$3/month annually; one user per subscriptionSeat pricing isn't published
Cost for five$15/month annually, if each needs ProTeam subscription cost isn't published
Setup effortSetup time isn't publishedInvite members; setup time isn't published
Learning curveFocused on photo cleanupMore tools to learn
Small-team integrationsInpainting API for product integrationMagicStudio.com, iOS, and Android access
SupportReview score: 5/10; channels not publishedReview score: 5/10; channels not published

Choose Cleanup.pictures if

  • Choose Cleanup.pictures if you need unlimited free, lower-resolution edits.
  • Choose Cleanup.pictures if one-person Pro pricing matters.
  • Choose Cleanup.pictures if you want an inpainting API.

Choose Magic Eraser if

  • Choose Magic Eraser if AI headshots are part of the job.
  • Choose Magic Eraser if teams need shared headshot progress and downloads.
  • Choose Magic Eraser if you want several AI image tools in one service.

02What each costs a small team

Cleanup.pictures’ free plan lists unlimited images, with exports limited to 720p. Pro is $5 monthly or $36 annually ($3 per month), and the pricing page says each subscription covers one user. That makes one Pro seat $5 month to month or $3 per month billed annually. For five people, five subscriptions work out to $25 monthly or $180 annually.

Magic Studio’s free plan lists 40 AI generations, limited-resolution downloads, and watermarks. Its PRO plan is $14.99 monthly or $4.99 per month billed yearly. That is the listed price for one plan, but seat terms and a five-person total aren’t published. There’s another wrinkle: the homepage says Magic Eraser editing requires a photo pack, and the pack price isn’t published. Ask Magic Studio whether PRO includes the pack or whether each teammate needs to buy one.

03Setup and day-to-day use

Neither vendor publishes a setup time, so we wouldn’t promise a same-day rollout or a particular learning curve. Cleanup.pictures is focused on removing objects, people, text, and defects. That narrow scope should make it easier to evaluate for a team that only needs photo retouching, without setting up a broader editing workflow.

Magic Studio covers more use cases, including headshots, appearance edits, and team headshot management. Its team feature lets members be invited and lets a team manage progress and downloads from one dashboard. A personal AI model uses uploaded photos, so teams should decide who supplies images and who manages the results. For either product, confirm who needs paid access before buying. Cleanup also offers an API with documentation for teams adding inpainting to a product; the setup work and time aren’t published.

04What you get on the cheaper plans

Cleanup.pictures’ free plan is generous on image count: it lists unlimited images, but exports are capped at 720p. The product removes objects, people, text, logos, date stamps, watermarks, and defects, and can retouch blemishes and wrinkles. Pro removes the resolution limit, adds a high-quality refiner, and still lists unlimited images. The FAQ says Pro supports images of any size.

Magic Studio’s free plan lists 40 AI generations, limited-resolution downloads, watermarks, and one image at a time. But those plan details don’t establish that Magic Eraser itself is free: the homepage says editing is available after purchasing a photo pack, and says Magic Eraser doesn’t use credits. Ask the vendor what the pack includes and costs. Magic Studio also lists headshot generation, a personal AI model, appearance edits, and previews of 50 watermarked photos before purchase. Team headshots can be managed from one dashboard.

Questions people ask

Is Cleanup.pictures free for a small team?

The free plan lists unlimited images, but exports are limited to 720p. It doesn’t list team seats, so don’t assume one free account covers several people. For high-resolution exports, Pro costs $5 monthly or $36 annually per user.

Does Magic Eraser have a free plan?

Magic Studio lists a free plan with 40 AI generations and watermarked, limited-resolution downloads. However, its homepage says Magic Eraser editing is available after purchasing a photo pack. The vendor doesn’t publish the pack price, so check what’s included before relying on free access.

Which is cheaper for five people?

Cleanup.pictures Pro lists one user per subscription, so five annual subscriptions cost $180 per year, or $15 per month averaged across the year. Magic Studio doesn’t publish seat pricing or a five-person total, and its photo-pack price isn’t published either.

Can a team use Magic Eraser for headshots?

Magic Studio lists headshot generation and team features for inviting members, managing progress, and handling downloads from one dashboard. It also lists previews of 50 watermarked photos before purchase. Confirm the team price and whether each person needs a separate photo pack.