We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never changes a score or a ranking. How we make money
Most buyers should pick TimeClock Plus.
For a small team that mainly needs punches, hours, leave and payroll calculations, TimeClock Plus is the more focused fit. Choose Dayforce if you need HR, payroll, talent and workforce operations in one platform and can get a quote that fits your budget. Neither vendor lists a free plan or starting price, so compare written quotes before deciding. Ask what each quote includes, especially implementation, support, required modules and, for TimeClock Plus, any clock hardware.
01Side by side
| Dayforce | TimeClock Plus | |
|---|---|---|
| Free plan | No free plan listed | No free plan listed |
| Cheapest paid plan | Quote-based; starting price unpublished | Quote-based; starting price unpublished |
| Price per seat | Not published; request a quote | Not published; request a quote |
| Cost for five | No published team total | No published team total |
| Setup effort | Implementation timeline not published | Implementation timeline not published |
| Learning curve | Onboarding time not published | Onboarding time not published |
| Small-team integrations | Specific integrations not published | Specific integrations not published |
| Support | Support terms not published | Support terms not published |
Dayforce Choose Dayforce if
- Choose Dayforce if HR, payroll and workforce operations belong together.
- Choose Dayforce if talent management and workforce analytics matter.
- Choose Dayforce if a custom quote fits your budget.
TimeClock Plus Choose TimeClock Plus if
- Choose TimeClock Plus if time and attendance are your main needs.
- Choose TimeClock Plus if you need leave, overtime and hours tracking.
- Choose TimeClock Plus if clock hardware or K-12 tools matter.
02What each costs a small team
Neither is a free-plan pick: the pricing information lists no free plan for either vendor. Dayforce uses custom quotes; its starting price and monthly or annual billing terms are not published. TimeClock Plus is also quote-based, with no published starting price or billing terms. For one person, there is no list price to use for a monthly estimate. The same goes for a team of three to five: neither vendor publishes a per-seat rate or a team-of-five total, so we can’t calculate a reliable cost. Dayforce covers HR, payroll, talent and workforce operations, while TimeClock Plus focuses on time and attendance, payroll calculations and leave. Ask each vendor for a written quote that spells out seats, modules, implementation, support and any hardware charges. For time tracking alone, check whether Dayforce’s broader scope justifies its quote.
03Setup and day-to-day use
Neither vendor publishes a typical setup timeline, so a small team should ask what implementation involves before signing. Dayforce combines HR, payroll, talent and workforce operations; confirm which areas you need and what must be configured for your team. TimeClock Plus centers on time collection, hours, leave and payroll calculations. Its options include on-site, mobile and web clocks, as well as hardware, so ask which setup fits your locations and whether hardware is needed. Day to day, Dayforce also describes employee self-service, while TimeClock Plus lets employees request time off for managers to review. The vendors don’t publish onboarding times or enough information to compare learning curves directly. Request a demo using your real approval, timekeeping and payroll scenarios, and ask who handles setup and training.
04What you get on the cheaper plans
There are no published plan tiers or prices to show which features come with a cheaper plan. Both vendors sell by quote, so ask for a feature-by-feature breakdown before comparing totals. Dayforce’s platform covers HR information, payroll, talent management, workforce management, reporting and analytics, plus AI and automation. Its homepage also describes employee self-service. That breadth may suit a team that wants more than time tracking, but check which modules the quote includes. TimeClock Plus covers employee time collection, hours, breaks, leave, overtime, job codes, pay rates and payroll calculations. It also offers leave requests and approval, multiple clock options and hardware. Its K-12 tools cover attendance, extra duty and absence management. Ask whether the quoted package includes the specific time clocks, rules, locations and leave workflows your team needs. Don’t assume a feature is included just because the platform offers it.
Questions people ask
What is Dayforce?
Dayforce is a human capital management platform for HR, payroll, talent and workforce operations. The vendor says it also provides reporting and analytics, AI and automation, and employee self-service. It’s broader than a time clock, so small teams should confirm which parts they need and what the quote includes.
What is the best system for employee time tracking?
For a small team primarily tracking employee time, TimeClock Plus is the more focused option in this comparison. It covers punches, hours, breaks, leave, overtime and payroll calculations. Dayforce may fit better when time tracking needs to sit alongside HR, payroll and talent management. Compare quotes and required features.
How do I enter time off in Dayforce?
Dayforce’s homepage describes employee self-service, but the steps for entering a time-off request aren’t published in the available product details. Ask your Dayforce administrator for your organization’s process or consult the vendor’s documentation. Confirm how requests are routed and approved for your team.
What is TimeClock Plus?
TimeClock Plus is employee time and attendance software for frontline teams. It collects time, tracks hours and leave, and calculates payroll. The vendor also offers on-site, mobile and web clock options, hardware, and tools for K-12 attendance and resource management.