We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never changes a score or a ranking. How we make money
It's a split decision.
For a small team that mainly needs schedules and messaging, When I Work is the cheaper starting point: Essentials is $2.50 per user monthly. Choose Deputy if you want timekeeping, timesheets, and labor-law compliance included in the entry plan; Lite lists those features at $5 per user monthly with annual billing. Neither has a free plan. Compare the full cost before choosing: When I Work prices time tracking separately, and Deputy’s monthly plans have a $30 minimum invoice in the US.
01Side by side
| Deputy | When I Work | |
|---|---|---|
| Free plan | No free plan; trial up to 31 days | No free plan; 14-day trial |
| Cheapest paid plan | Lite: $5 per user monthly, annual rate | Essentials: $2.50 per user monthly |
| Price per seat | $5 monthly equivalent with annual billing | $2.50 monthly |
| Cost for five | $25 monthly equivalent; $30 monthly invoice minimum | $12.50 monthly for Essentials |
| Setup effort | Setup time estimate not published | Setup time estimate not published |
| Learning curve | No learning-curve estimate published | No learning-curve estimate published |
| Small-team integrations | One-click approved-timesheet handoff to Paycor | Integration details not published |
| Support | 24/7 live chat on Pro | Support details not published |
Deputy Choose Deputy if
- Choose Deputy if timekeeping and timesheets belong in your base plan.
- Choose Deputy if labor-law compliance is a core scheduling need.
- Choose Deputy if you need a listed Paycor timesheet handoff.
When I Work Choose When I Work if
- Choose When I Work if low-cost scheduling and messaging come first.
- Choose When I Work if you need multi-location scheduling at Essentials.
- Choose When I Work if you want auto scheduling on the entry plan.
02What each costs a small team
Neither vendor lists a free plan. Deputy offers a trial of up to 31 days; When I Work offers 14 days. Deputy’s pricing page lists Lite at $5 per user monthly with annual billing. That’s a $5 monthly equivalent for one person, $15 for three, or $25 for five. US monthly Lite plans have a $30 minimum invoice, so ask Deputy how billing works for your team size.
When I Work Essentials costs $2.50 per user monthly: $2.50 for one person, $7.50 for three, or $12.50 for five. Annual prices aren’t published. Essentials includes unlimited users, but pricing is still per user. One caveat: When I Work sells Time Tracking & Attendance as an add-on and doesn’t publish its price, so get a quote before comparing total costs.
03Setup and day-to-day use
Neither vendor publishes a setup-time estimate, so we wouldn’t budget a specific number of hours based on the listed features alone. Before signing up, map out who creates schedules, who approves swaps and time off, and whether you need one or multiple locations.
Deputy Lite includes leave and availability management, scheduling, timesheets, clocking, and compliance features. A small team should decide how it will record availability and handle breaks and overtime. When I Work Essentials includes schedule templates, multi-week and multi-location scheduling, messaging, and auto scheduling; the team will need to settle its scheduling rules and communication habits. More advanced scheduling rules and role permissions are on When I Work Pro, not Essentials.
Neither vendor publishes a learning-curve estimate. If you need a specific onboarding plan or training commitment, ask the vendor before choosing.
04What you get on the cheaper plans
Deputy Lite is the more complete entry plan if you want scheduling plus attendance basics. Its listed features include basic scheduling and timesheets, basic time clocking, labor-law compliance, and leave and availability management. That gives a small team a way to manage shifts and record work without buying a separate listed time-tracking add-on. Auto-scheduling, demand forecasting, timesheet auto-approval, and wage and labor budgets are in Core, which starts at $6 per user monthly with annual billing.
When I Work Essentials focuses on scheduling and communication. It includes auto scheduling, multi-week and multi-location schedules, templates, team messaging, and unlimited users. But Time Tracking & Attendance is a separately priced add-on, and the vendor doesn’t publish its price. Pro adds scheduling rules, role permissions, custom reporting, and time-zone switching. For a team that needs clock-ins, breaks, and attendance, ask for the add-on price before treating Essentials as the cheaper complete option.
Questions people ask
Does Deputy have a free plan?
No. Deputy doesn’t list a free plan; its pricing details say the trial lasts up to 31 days. The cheapest listed plan is Lite at $5 per user monthly with annual billing. For US monthly Lite plans, Deputy lists a $30 minimum spend per invoice.
Does When I Work include time tracking?
Time Tracking & Attendance is a When I Work add-on, not a listed Essentials feature. The vendor doesn’t publish the add-on price, so ask for a quote that includes it before comparing the total with Deputy Lite, which lists timekeeping and timesheets.
Which costs less for a team of five?
At listed entry-plan rates, When I Work Essentials is $12.50 monthly for five users. Deputy Lite works out to $25 monthly at its annual-billing rate, but US monthly Lite plans have a $30 minimum invoice. These figures don’t include When I Work’s unpriced time-tracking add-on.
Which tool is better for a small hourly team?
When I Work suits a team prioritizing low-cost scheduling, auto scheduling, and messaging. Deputy is a better fit when the entry plan needs to include timekeeping, timesheets, and compliance features. If you need attendance tracking in When I Work, ask the vendor for the add-on price before deciding.