review galore

Head-to-head · HR software

Employee Navigator vs Gusto

Gusto publishes per-person payroll pricing; Employee Navigator is broker-oriented and requires a quote.

Employee Navigator

6.5/10
VS

Gusto

6.8/10

We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never changes a score or a ranking. How we make money

Short answer

Most buyers should pick Gusto.

For a small team that needs payroll with a clear monthly bill, Gusto is easier to budget: Simple costs $49 per month plus $6 per person. Employee Navigator may fit better when benefits administration through a broker is the main need, but its plan prices are not published. Get a written quote before comparing total costs, and check which integrations and support fees apply to your setup.

01Side by side

Employee NavigatorGusto
Free planNo free planNo free plan
Cheapest paid planEnhanced; price not publishedSimple: $49/month + $6/person
Price per seatNot published; request a quote$6/person plus $49 monthly base
Cost for a team of fiveNot published; request a quote$79/month on Simple
Setup effortSetup time not published; broker-led plansSetup time not published; onboarding tools offered
Learning curveNot published; ask for a walkthroughNot published; ask for a walkthrough
Integrations a small team needsMore than 600 integrations, per homepagePayroll integrations; catalog breadth not stated
SupportSupport fees vary; Platinum adds priority phone supportPremium Account Support is included on Premium

Choose Employee Navigator if

  • Choose Employee Navigator if benefits administration through a broker is central.
  • Choose Employee Navigator if you need ACA reporting tools.
  • Choose Employee Navigator if its broker integrations match your benefits setup.

Choose Gusto if

  • Choose Gusto if you want published payroll pricing for a small team.
  • Choose Gusto if Simple's payroll tax filings cover your needs.
  • Choose Gusto if you need time tracking or multi-state payroll on Plus.

02What each costs a small team

Neither vendor offers a free plan. Employee Navigator's entry plan is Enhanced, but the vendor does not publish plan prices or monthly versus annual billing. Ask your broker for a written quote, including any support and reporting fees.

Gusto's Simple plan is $49 per month plus $6 per person. That works out to $55 monthly for one person, $67 for three, and $79 for five. These totals use the listed base fee and per-person charge; they do not include optional add-ons or benefits costs. Gusto Plus is $80 per month plus $12 per person, or $140 for five. For a small team that mainly needs payroll, Simple is the clearest starting budget. Compare Employee Navigator only after you have a quote for your company.

03Setup and day-to-day use

Neither vendor publishes a typical setup time, so we would not budget by assuming a same-day launch. Employee Navigator connects employers, brokers, and partners. Its plans include online enrollment and carrier, payroll, and third-party integrations; the right setup will depend on which connections your broker uses. Ask who configures the benefits plans and what help costs extra.

Gusto offers hiring and onboarding tools, including checklists and digital signatures. Its payroll setup may also involve state tax registration, which Gusto prices by state. On an ongoing basis, Simple covers payroll runs, tax filings and payments, and basic PTO policies. Plus adds time tracking and scheduling. Before choosing, ask each vendor for a walkthrough using your actual payroll, benefits, and onboarding tasks. The learning curve is not published for either product.

04What you get on the cheaper plans

Employee Navigator's Enhanced plan is aimed at brokers needing benefits administration. It includes online enrollment, carrier, payroll, and TPA integrations, ACA reporting, and AI Plan Builds. Enhanced Plus adds 834 EDI files and third-party apps. Elite adds enrollment assistance, new-hire onboarding, and PTO and vacation tracking. Those extra functions are tiered, and prices for all three plans require a quote.

Gusto Simple is the lower-cost published option. Its listed plan features include unlimited monthly payrolls, tax filings and payments, basic PTO policies, and holiday pay. Gusto's broader platform also covers hiring, benefits, time tracking, and compliance, but check which plan or add-on includes each feature before budgeting. Plus lists time tracking and scheduling, multi-state payroll, and contractor invoice management. For a small team choosing between the lowest tiers, Gusto is more explicit about payroll costs; Employee Navigator's edge is its benefits-focused administration.

Questions people ask

What is Gusto payroll?

Gusto is a payroll and HR platform for businesses. Its Simple plan lists unlimited monthly payrolls, tax filings and payments, basic PTO policies, and holiday pay. Gusto also offers hiring, benefits, time tracking, contractor payments, and compliance tools, with some features tied to higher plans or add-ons.

Does Employee Navigator have an app?

Employee Navigator's listed features include benefits administration, HR tools, ACA reporting, onboarding, time-off tracking, and payroll integrations, but they do not confirm app availability. Ask Employee Navigator or your broker whether a mobile app is available and which tasks employees and admins can complete in it.

Who are Gusto's main competitors?

This comparison covers Employee Navigator as one alternative, not as a definitive competitor ranking. The two products have different centers of gravity: Gusto publishes payroll pricing, while Employee Navigator focuses on benefits administration through brokers. Compare tools based on your payroll, benefits, integration, and budget needs.

Is Ease the same as Employee Navigator?

Employee Navigator describes itself as a benefits, HR, and compliance platform. That description alone does not establish whether Ease is the same product or a related service. If your broker mentioned Ease, ask them to confirm the vendor name, product, and login URL before choosing a plan.