review galore

Simpler and cheaper options · 7 options

Gusto alternatives

Lower-cost payroll starts at $7, but few-seat totals and setup details can be hard to pin down.

We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page. It never changes a score or a ranking. How we make money

A small team may not need to replace Gusto if its payroll and HR features work and the price fits. But Gusto starts at $49, and one Reddit thread describes support frustrations while others report tax and payment issues. For a leaner payroll, SurePayroll starts at $20 and QuickBooks Online Payroll at $25. Those are starting prices, not guaranteed totals for your team: ask about seat charges, setup and tax support before switching.

01Why people leave Gusto

Support that misses the mark

Reddit users describe communication problems with support, including difficulty getting clear answers and reaching teams handling sensitive issues.

Tax issues need timely help

One Reddit thread reports a time-sensitive tax issue waiting more than a month for assignment, with penalties accruing.

Costs can climb for small rosters

Gusto starts at $49. A base fee plus seat charges can make the bill feel steep when a team has only a few employees.

02The alternatives, ranked by fit

  1. Straightforward payroll

    SurePayroll

    SurePayroll is the lowest published starting price among these payroll picks at $20. It suits small businesses with straightforward payroll and offers automatic tax filing. The vendor says to confirm your monthly price first, so ask for a quote for your employee count and setup needs. Setup time and any per-seat charges aren't published.

    Trade-off: Confirm your actual monthly price before switching.

    7.0/10
    from
    $20/mo
  2. QuickBooks teams

    QuickBooks Online Payroll

    The pricing page lists QuickBooks Online Payroll from $25, making it a candidate for small teams already using QuickBooks. It includes payroll tax filing and can combine payroll with time tracking. The vendor's exact cost for a few seats isn't published here; ask how the base fee and roster size affect your bill and what setup requires.

    Trade-off: A base fee can weigh on a small roster.

    6.2/10
    from
    $25/mo
  3. Payroll and benefits

    Justworks

    Justworks starts at $8 and combines payroll, HR and benefits administration, which may suit a small team trying to consolidate vendors. Founders who value expert support are also a stated fit. The price for a few seats and setup effort aren't published; ask about the base fee and benefit renewals before comparing it with Gusto.

    Trade-off: Check base fees and benefit renewal costs.

    6.5/10
    from
    $8/mo
  4. Payroll and HR

    Paychex

    Paychex is worth a quote if you want payroll and HR together, payroll tax filing or the option to consider PEO services. Its price isn't published, so a small team can't compare a few-seat total from the starting price alone. Ask for an itemized quote and details on implementation before deciding whether the extra coverage is worth it.

    Trade-off: You need a quote to judge affordability.

    5.0/10
    from
    Custom
  5. Employee self-service

    Paycom

    Paycom combines payroll and HR and may fit teams prioritizing employee self-service or automated time-off decisions. There is no published starting price, so request a quote for your headcount and ask whether fees change as seats are added. Setup effort isn't published either; get a timeline and implementation requirements before committing.

    Trade-off: Custom pricing makes small-team budgeting harder.

    5.3/10
    from
    Custom
  6. Broader workforce tools

    Paylocity

    Paylocity may fit small employers consolidating HR and payroll who also need finance, IT tools or workforce reporting. The vendor doesn't publish a price or offer a listed free plan, so ask for a few-seat quote. Setup details aren't published; confirm implementation work and which tools are included before comparing it with Gusto.

    Trade-off: No published price or free plan.

    5.2/10
    from
    Custom
  7. Healthcare payroll

    Viventium

    Viventium is the niche pick for healthcare and post-acute care providers that need healthcare payroll, HR and scheduling together. Its price is custom, so a small team will need a quote to budget. Setup details aren't clear from the published information; ask what implementation involves and which services are included in your proposal.

    Trade-off: Custom pricing and unclear setup make planning harder.

    5.8/10
    from
    Custom

03Side by side

ToolScoreFromFree planBest for
Gusto (current)6.8$49/moNoSmall teams running one-state payroll
SurePayroll7.0$20/moNoSmall businesses with straightforward payroll
QuickBooks Online Payroll6.2$25/moNoSmall teams already using QuickBooks
Justworks6.5$8/moNoSmall teams consolidating payroll and HR
Paychex5.0CustomNoTeams wanting payroll and HR together
Paycom5.3CustomNoTeams wanting payroll and HR together
Paylocity5.2CustomNoSmall employers consolidating HR and payroll
Viventium5.8CustomNoHealthcare and post-acute care providers

Questions people ask

Which Gusto alternative has a free plan?

ZayZoon lists $0 monthly pricing for employers, while DailyPay lists a $0 standard option that depends on employer setup. Both focus on pay access or employee benefits, not replacing payroll. Treat them as possible add-ons, and ask about fees or paycheck deductions before enrolling.

What will payroll cost for a few employees?

SurePayroll starts at $20, QuickBooks Online Payroll at $25 and Justworks at $8. These are starting prices, not confirmed totals for a particular roster. Ask each vendor for an itemized quote that shows the base fee, seat charges and any other required costs.

How hard is it to switch from Gusto?

Setup effort and migration timelines aren't published for these alternatives. Before you choose, ask who handles the switch, what payroll and employee information you must provide, how tax records transfer and when the first payroll can run. Get the answers and any implementation costs in writing.